Whatever happens to interest rates, your Cash ISA will continue to disappoint

Interest rates have been at rock bottom for over a decade, and don’t look to be likely to rise any time soon.

The content of this article was relevant at the time of publishing. Circumstances change continuously and caution should therefore be exercised when relying upon any content contained within this article.

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More.

Chatting to someone the other day, I mentioned that I was sort of semi-retired – not actually drawing a pension, but not working as hard as I used to, either.
 
Instead, a lot of the day-to-day bills were paid by a monthly income that I took from a couple of ISAs.
 
The response was a combination of a scornful laugh and a look of incredulity.
 
“ISAs? You won’t get much of an income from one of those!”
 
On the contrary, I replied: I was getting a return of around 5% on my investments.

Again, there was that look of incredulity. But this time, without the scornful laugh.

On the floor

 I’m always surprised how few people are really aware of the possibilities offered by dividends, and by ISAs containing shares that pay decent and sustainable dividends.
 
Say the word ‘ISA’, and they generally think solely of Cash ISAs from banks and building societies, which for the last decade have paid truly derisory rates of interest.
 
When in early 2009 the Bank of England slashed Bank Rate three times in three successive months, it was supposed to be a temporary response to the financial crisis. Instead, the rate stayed at 0.5% until 2016 – when it was cut again, to 0.25%, in response to the post-referendum slump.
 
Eventually restored to 0.5%, it finally climbed above that level in late 2018. Now at a dizzying – yes, dizzying! – 0.75%, a cut is again on the cards as I write these words.
 
If it doesn’t come on January 30th, observers are already pencilling it in for the next time that the Bank’s Monetary Policy Committee meets to set rates. 

In real terms, you’re losing money

Clearly, it would be naïve to expect any early return to the interest rate regime of – say – the mid-2000s, when savers could actually get a positive return on the hard-earned money.
 
These days, rates are not only derisory. They are also negative, in real terms.
 
In other words, to spell it out in its starkest terms, typical bank account interest rates are dwarfed by the rate of inflation. In purchasing power terms, savers’ savings are actually shrinking.
 
Simply put, that means that what you can buy with these savings this month, is less than you could buy the month before, and less than you could buy the month before that.
 
Which for pensioners, is fairly bad news.

The dividend alternative

Yet, here’s the thing. Companies’ dividends relate to the profits that they make, and aren’t set by Bank of England policymakers.
 
(Ironically, too, when interest rates are low, many companies make higher profits – because debt is cheaper.)
 
So given a reasonable economy, companies tend to make reasonable profits, which they pay out to their shareholders in the form of dividends.

And right now, there are some tasty yields on offer – even with the Footsie at around 7600 at the time of writing.

5% plus

Among my own holdings, for instance, Royal Dutch Shell is on a yield of 6.7%, HSBC on a yield of 6.9%, mining giant BHP on a yield of 5.9%, and insurance firm Legal & General a yield of 5.5%.
 
All of those strike me as pretty dependable businesses, and those with an eye to take on a little more risk – tobacco firms BAT and Imperial Brands, maybe, or Royal Mail – will find yields that are even higher.
 
Opt for more of a ‘safety first’ stance, and there are plenty of attractive yields on offer at around the 4.5% mark – pharmaceutical giant GlaxoSmithKline, for instance, yields 4.4%. 

Time to take the plunge?

Buying a broadly-diversified clutch of such companies isn’t rocket science. These are businesses that should be big enough to withstand more than a few setbacks, and – for the most part – aren’t troubled by burdensome regulatory regimes.

Nor are brokerages expensive, or difficult to find. Buying shares, as I’ve written before, is easier than ever, and both far less expensive and far less complicated then when I started, all those years ago.
 
So if your bank or building society Cash ISA continues to disappoint, it could be time to think about a Stocks and Shares ISA instead.

Malcolm owns shares in Tesco, Royal Dutch Shell, Primary Health Properties, 3i Infrastructure, Empiric Student Property, British Land, Hammerson, and NewRiver Retail. The Motley Fool UK has recommended British Land Co, DS Smith, Primary Health Properties, and Tesco.

More on Investing Articles

Sunrise over Earth
Investing Articles

Meet the ex-penny share up 109% that has topped Rolls-Royce and Nvidia in 2025

The share price of this investment trust has gone from pennies to above £1 over the past couple of years.…

Read more »

House models and one with REIT - standing for real estate investment trust - written on it.
Investing Articles

1 of the FTSE 100’s most reliable dividend stocks for me to buy now?

With most dividend stocks with 6.5% yields, there's a problem with the underlying business. But LondonMetric Property is a rare…

Read more »

Investing Articles

Is 2026 the year to consider buying oil stocks?

The time to buy cyclical stocks is when they're out of fashion with investors. And that looks to be the…

Read more »

ISA coins
Investing Articles

3 reasons I’m skipping a Cash ISA in 2026

Putting money into a Cash ISA can feel safe. But in 2026 and beyond, that comfort could come at a…

Read more »

US Stock

I asked ChatGPT if the Tesla share price could outperform Nvidia in 2026, with this result!

Jon Smith considers the performance of the Tesla share price against Nvidia stock and compares his view for next year…

Read more »

Investing Articles

Greggs: is this FTSE 250 stock about to crash again in 2026?

After this FTSE 250 stock crashed in 2025, our writer wonders if it will do the same in 2026. Or…

Read more »

Investing Articles

7%+ yields! Here are 3 major UK dividend share forecasts for 2026 and beyond

Mark Hartley checks forecasts and considers the long-term passive income potential of three of the UK's most popular dividend shares.

Read more »

Hand is turning a dice and changes the direction of an arrow symbolizing that the value of an ETF (Exchange Traded Fund) is going up (or vice versa)
Investing Articles

2 top ETFs to consider for an ISA in 2026

Here are two very different ETFs -- one set to ride the global robotics boom, the other offering a juicy…

Read more »