One screamingly cheap small-cap stock I’d avoid and one I’d buy

Despite performing fairly well over the last year (up 18%), shares in property regeneration business U and I Group (LSE: UAI) are still way below the highs they achieved back in the middle of 2015. Today’s interim results — along with the market’s subdued reaction to them — would suggest that there’s still a long way to go before they can recapture their former glory. 

In line with guidance

To be clear, there’s was nothing particularly awful in today’s numbers. Having realised gains of £7.2m in the six months since the end of February (and £2.2m post-period-end), the company believes it is now on track to deliver £65m-£70m of development and trading gains over the full year. According to CEO Matthew Weiner, this is in line with expectations and supportive of its three-year target to deliver “a minimum of £155m” of such gains and total annual returns of 12%. He went on to state that demand for accommodation within London, Manchester and Dublin “continues to grow” as the supply of existing housing stock reduces, suggesting a fairly positive outlook for U and I over the medium term.

So why aren’t I more bullish? It’s mostly to do with the growing amount of debt on the company’s books. At the end of August 2016, this stood at £128m. By the end of August this year, this number had climbed to almost £160m. This is despite management attempting to cut costs where it can (a £2m reduction in overheads has been targeted by the end of the financial year) and reporting “good progress” on repositioning its investment portfolio, including the identification of £50m of non-core assets for sale. 

With returns on capital employed pitifully low and levels of free cash flow anything but consistent, the cheap-as-chips valuation attached to the company’s shares — at just eight times predicted earnings — isn’t quite so compelling as it first appears, in my opinion. 

Strong performer

Thanks to last month’s excellent set of final results, I can’t help thinking that £370m cap industry peer and strategic land specialist MJ Gleeson (LSE: GLE) might be a better pick.

In the 12 months to the end of June, the Sheffield-based business grew revenue 13% to just over £160m. Pre-tax profit rose 17% to £33m and cash flow increased 42% to £19.7m. In sharp contrast to the aforementioned small-cap, MJ Gleeson had a net cash position at the end of the reporting period of £34.1m. Building on a trend that’s developed over the last few years, returns on capital invested also continue to increase, standing at just over 25% for the 2016/17 year.   

Over the reporting period, it sold 1,013 units — albeit at a slightly lower average selling price than the previous year — leading management to set a new target of doubling sales within five years. According to the company, demand for its affordable housing in the North of England currently exceeds supply with buyers “queueing on-site during open days“. Elsewhere, its South of England-focused strategic land segment reported “a record year” with the completion of eight sales as a result of strong demand from housebuilders. 

Trading on just under 13 times forecast earnings for the new financial year, shares in MJ Gleeson still look very reasonably priced and are expected to offer a 3.7% dividend yield.

Another great opportunity

If you're looking for the best small-cap stocks on the market today, you should definitely read a special report from the Fool's Head of UK Investing. Mark Rogers thinks he's found another great opportunity in the shape of a company that appears to be flying under many investors' radars.

Access to Mark's report is completely FREE and comes with no obligation. Just click here for your copy.

Paul Summers has no position in any of the shares mentioned. The Motley Fool UK has no position in any of the shares mentioned. Views expressed on the companies mentioned in this article are those of the writer and therefore may differ from the official recommendations we make in our subscription services such as Share Advisor, Hidden Winners and Pro. Here at The Motley Fool we believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.