Aviva plc Is A Punt, Prudential plc Is A Dead Cert

Comparing the prospects of Aviva plc (LON:AV) and Prudential plc (LON:PRU).

| More on:

The content of this article was relevant at the time of publishing. Circumstances change continuously and caution should therefore be exercised when relying upon any content contained within this article.

Betting analogies aren’t really appropriate for serious, long-term investors. But calling Aviva (LSE: AV) (NYSE: AV.US) a punt and Prudential (LSE: PRU) (NYSE: PUK.US) a dead cert is a good way of emphasising the different investment characteristics of the two firms.

Aviva is the composite insurer favoured by value investors that has serially disappointed, to the extent many consider it a value trap. Shareholders were particularly hurt by last March’s dividend cut, which knocked 15% off the share price.

The cut wasn’t completely unexpected, with a new CEO, an implausibly high yield and excessive gearing. But chairman John McFarlane had made great strides selling assets and paring costs after he seized the reins in the wake of disgraced former CEO’s departure, and had told investors he was striving to maintain the payout. It was bad signalling, if shrewd strategy, to do a volte face.

A split?

New CEO Mark Wilson’s strategy looks much like that set by Mr McFarlane with assets sales, cost cutting and cash generation prioritised. One intriguing difference is that Mr Wilson is eliminating the internal funding that the general insurance arm provides to the life assurance arm. Aviva has previously defended its composite structure by citing just that cash flow benefit. Maybe Mr Wilson has an eye on divesting the general insurance arm once the operational management is sorted out: now that would see value outed and put in the pockets of Aviva’s investors.

In any case, shareholders will need patience. Aviva has great brands and a significant franchise, but the value has been squandered on poor management. Streamlining operations and focussing on more profitable business units is starting to show through in better cash flow, reduced gearing and improved margins. But it will be a long haul with much of Aviva’s business in hock to the sick economies of Europe.

That’s not a problem at life assurer Prudential, which gets 40% of its new business from Asia. Its plan to buy AIG’s Asian arm was rejected by shareholders in 2010, but with a decades-long presence in the region it has plugged away at growing its position there. It’s pushing against an open door: as Asia’s middle classes grow in number and disposable income, so they are more interested in products such as life assurance. I suppose there are similar disparities between poor and middle class families in the UK.

Odds

Prudential’s 14.1 prospective P/E is nearly 20% higher than Aviva’s 11.9, and you get just a 2.8% dividend against Aviva’s 4.1%. But you’d expect a dead cert and a punt to offer different odds.

Whatever your attitude to risk, it’s sensible to have a core of dependable and low risk shares in your portfolio. The Motley Fool has picked its top five core shares you could tuck away and retire on. An exclusive report details five companies that have dominant market positions, healthy balance sheets and robust cash flows. You can download the report by clicking here — it’s free.

> Tony owns shares in Aviva and Prudential but no other shares mentioned in this article.

Should you invest, the value of your investment may rise or fall and your capital is at risk. Before investing, your individual circumstances should be considered so you should consider taking independent financial advice.

More on Investing Articles

Cheerful young businesspeople with laptop working in office
Investing Articles

Is now the perfect time to start buying AIM stocks?

Might it be worth taking on extra risk and buying AIM stocks for the recovery? One of our writers, though…

Read more »

Young female analyst working at her desk in the office
Investing Articles

1 top British growth stock I’d buy now

This growth stock has tripled since October 2020. Roland Head explains why he still wants to buy this quality business.

Read more »

Investing Articles

Should I buy Aviva shares for the dividend in 2022 and 2023?

Aviva shares have soared in value. Yet at current prices the insurer's dividend yields still smash the market average. Should…

Read more »

Close-up of British bank notes
Investing Articles

Forget income bonds! I’d buy these 2 high-yield UK dividend shares

These two UK dividend shares offer significantly more attractive passive income than boring bonds, in my opinion.

Read more »

Family holding hands in a circle on a beach
Investing Articles

11% dividend yield! 1 FTSE 100 dividend share to buy today

I'm hunting for the best dividend shares in the FTSE 100 and this industry leader could be one of my…

Read more »

Passive and Active: text from letters of the wooden alphabet on a green chalk board
Investing Articles

How I’d invest in UK dividend stocks to generate passive income for retirement

How I plan use the iShares UK dividend fund to invest in high-yield stocks in the UK to generate passive…

Read more »

Black woman using loudspeaker to be heard
Investing Articles

GSK shares plummet 15% in a week! What’s going on here?

GSK shares had a bad time last week. They're down 15% as investors' sentiment soured ahead of litigation proceedings in…

Read more »

Burst your bubble thumbtack and balloon background
Investing Articles

Stock market recovery: have all the bubbles now burst?

Asset bubbles keep on coming, and here's what I'm doing to navigate through them and invest for the stock market…

Read more »