Will Barclays PLC’s Depressed Shares Spring Back To Life?

BarclaysInvesting in a bank is among the riskier decisions an investor can make. That is, unless you’re able to thoroughly analyse a bank’s financial statements. Remember, risk comes from not knowing what you’re doing. Most people don’t have the expertise — not to mention the free time — to fully appraise themselves of the prospective downside of investing in a business like Barclays (LSE: BARC) (NYSE: BCS.US).

During the financial crisis, shares of Barclays bottomed at 59p. The shares have risen nearly fourfold since then, but are still some way off their pre-crisis peak.

The performance of UK shares have been volatile in 2014 and Barclays has fallen 17% year to date. While a few companies have made big gains — the pharmaceutical sector has done well, along with consumer goods — the banking sector remains depressed.

Profits at Barclays are still dropping; the threat of litigation looms; and the market has very little faith in the prospective 4%+ dividend yield. Let’s look a little closer at what’s going on.

The core business

Despite strong performance from the retail, corporate banking and Barclaycard, pretax profit fell from £3.6bn to around £3.3bn in the first half of the year, which hasn’t inspired investors.

It’s sensible to invest in a wide range of companies, across a number of different sectors. That way, we spread our risk — and hopefully one or two shares will be big winners. If you’re thinking of investing in Barclays, you need to first familiarise yourself with what the bank does.

There is a cultural clean-up under way at Barclays, and the thrust of it seems to be to engender public trust after multiple mis-selling scandals and bonus backlashes.

Barclays’ customers want somewhere safe to store their savings, as well as access to loans and credit cards. It makes money on the difference between the interest on deposits and the returns from deploying that capital through loans and advances to lending customers.

A deathly overhang

Profits in the personal banking and corporate banking division grew by 23% in the first half of the year. The shares were weighed on, however, by weakness in the investment bank, where revenue fell 16%. This is becoming something of a theme at Barclays and the market fears something is seriously deficient there.

The market is likewise fearful of more big fines coming down the slipway which, if sizeable enough, could put excess strain on the bank’s capital adequacy, and a rights issue would be required to sure up its finances.

Barclays’ tangible assets are valued at around 315p per share versus a share price of only 234p. The prospective dividend yield, according to analyst forecasts, is 4%. It’s on a forward P/E of just 10. Those metrics would be appealing for any other share, but the problem is that Barclays is a bank, and fairly or not, it’s still seen as a falling knife.

Should you buy?

I’d advocate that ordinary investors should maintain a portfolio of between 10 and 20 companies. Stick with what you know. 

But that's only one idea for your portfolio and it might not be right for everyone. The Motley Fool's top analysts believe that only a handful of companies will make big gains this year, so I recommend you read our free report to discover Where We Think The Smart Money Is Going Right Now.

The report offers in-depth commentary on building the 'perfect portfolio' for an unpredictable bull market, is completely FREE and without obligation. Simply click here to get yours sent to you instantly, while it remains available.

Mark Stones has no position in any shares mentioned. The Motley Fool UK has no position in any shares mentioned. We Fools don't all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.