These under-the-radar FTSE 250 stocks haven’t just beaten the market. They’ve thrashed it!

If you think picking stocks never pays, our writer has news for you. Paul Summers highlights two FTSE 250 shares that have made a mockery of the index return.

| More on:

The content of this article was relevant at the time of publishing. Circumstances change continuously and caution should therefore be exercised when relying upon any content contained within this article.

A young woman sitting on a couch looking at a book in a quiet library space.

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More.

While the UK economy is far from firing on all cylinders, the home-focused FTSE 250 index has climbed just under 7% in value since January (and 13% in the last 12 months).

However, this is nothing compared to the performance of some of its constituents.

Magical stock

Harry Potter has been a literary phenomenon. Even so, I suspect many people won’t be aware that the company getting the books into readers’ hands is listed on our stock market. That’s Bloomsbury Publishing (LSE: BMY) and it’s been a superb investment for the last few years.

Since September 2019, the shares price is up a spell-binding 186%. But just buying the stock in January would still have delivered a 42% gain.

Oh, and there have been dividends on top of this!

Lockdown star

Bloomsbury’s purple patch really kicked off during the pandemic. Sent behind our doors, many of us fell back into the habit of reading for leisure and earnings boomed.

In contrast to other activities, this trend has endured since the bug was sent packing. Even a cost-of-living crisis doesn’t appear to have impacted momentum. In fact, the mid-cap has been busy upgrading guidance.

The big question is how much of this is now priced in.

More to come?

As I type, Bloomsbury stock changes hands for 20 times FY25 earnings. That’s more than the average across UK stocks.

One could also argue that publishers can’t really predict which titles will be successful and that profits are overly-dependent on a small group of very popular authors. And writing books takes time.

On the other hand, management’s efforts to grow the company’s academic arm by prioritising international sales, subject area expansion and digital scholarship could pay off. The balance sheet also looks pretty robust to me, with a decent net cash position.

All told, Bloomsbury continues to present as a quality business. But it’s also one I’d prefer to pick up during a period of general market malaise.

Stunning gains

Another stock delivering the goods for private investors willing to stray off the beaten track has been CMC Markets (LSE: CMCX).

Shares in the online trading platform provider have rocketed nearly 190% this year. Again, this doesn’t take into account the dividends received over the period (8.3p per share).

There have been a number of catalysts for this incredible return. Chief among these has been an increase in trading activity among clients as markets have become more choppy. In it’s most recent update, the company maintained its guidance on full-year operating profit of between £320m and £360m.

But investors have also been cheering news of potential partnerships, product launches, and a sustained period of cost-cutting.

Risky pick

As brilliant as recent returns have been, one does need to be aware that longer-term holders of CMC have endured a lot of pain. Between April 2021 and October 2023, the stock crashed by over 80% as the pandemic trading boom subsided.

It’s also worth noting that the share price has been drifting sideways for a couple of months. Perhaps it might take an earnings upgrade to move higher. In the absence of a significant geo-political event, I’m not convinced that will happen when half-year numbers are announced in November.

For this reason, CMC also stays on my watchlist.

Paul Summers has no position in any of the shares mentioned. The Motley Fool UK has recommended Bloomsbury Publishing Plc. Views expressed on the companies mentioned in this article are those of the writer and therefore may differ from the official recommendations we make in our subscription services such as Share Advisor, Hidden Winners and Pro. Here at The Motley Fool we believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.

More on Investing Articles

Rear view image depicting a senior man in his 70s sitting on a bench leading down to the iconic Seven Sisters cliffs on the coastline of East Sussex, UK. The man is wearing casual clothing - blue denim jeans, a red checked shirt, navy blue gilet. The man is having a rest from hiking and his hiking pole is leaning up against the bench.
Investing Articles

2 ideas for a SIPP or ISA in 2026

Looking for stocks for an ISA or SIPP portfolio? Our writer thinks a FTSE 100 defence giant and fallen pharma…

Read more »

Midnight is celebrated along the River Thames in London with a spectacular and colourful firework display.
Investing Articles

Could buying this stock at $13 be like investing in Tesla in 2011?

Tesla stock went on to make early investors a literal fortune. Our writer sees some interesting similarities with this eVTOL…

Read more »

Close-up of British bank notes
Investing Articles

3 reasons the Lloyds share price could keep climbing in 2026

Out of 18 analysts, 11 rate Lloyds a Buy, even after the share price has had its best year for…

Read more »

Chalkboard representation of risk versus reward on a pair of scales
Growth Shares

Considering these UK shares could help an investor on the road to a million-pound portfolio

Jon Smith points out several sectors where he believes long-term gains could be found, and filters them down to specific…

Read more »

Close-up image depicting a woman in her 70s taking British bank notes from her colourful leather wallet.
Investing For Beginners

Martin Lewis is embracing stock investing, but I think he missed a key point

It's great that Martin Lewis is talking about stocks, writes Jon Smith, but he feels he's missed a trick by…

Read more »

House models and one with REIT - standing for real estate investment trust - written on it.
Investing Articles

This 8% yield could be a great addition to a portfolio of dividend shares

Penny stocks don't usually make for great passive income investments. But dividend investors should consider shares in this under-the-radar UK…

Read more »

Queen Street, one of Cardiff's main shopping streets, busy with Saturday shoppers.
Investing Articles

Why this 9.71% dividend yield might be a rare passive income opportunity

This REIT offers a 9.71% dividend yield from a portfolio with high occupancy, long leases, and strong rent collection from…

Read more »

Portsmouth, England, June 2018, Portsmouth port in the late evening
Investing Articles

A 50% discount to NAV makes this REIT’s 9.45% dividend yield impossible for me to ignore

Stephen Wright thinks shares in this UK REIT could be worth much more than the stock market is giving them…

Read more »