Share your opinion and earn yourself a free Motley Fool premium report!

We are looking for Fools to join a 75 minute online independent market research forum on 15th / 16th December.

To find out more and express your interest please click here

Is this 14% high-dividend-yield portfolio too good to be true?

Jon Smith considers whether the reward outweighs the risk of investing in an ultra-high-dividend-yield selection of stocks.

The content of this article was relevant at the time of publishing. Circumstances change continuously and caution should therefore be exercised when relying upon any content contained within this article.

Bearded man writing on notepad in front of computer

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More.

High-dividend-yield stocks form a part of my overall portfolio. True, these stocks can often be quite risky, with the dividends potentially less sustainable than others. But there’s something to be said about assembling such stocks into a portfolio with the aim of generating a high yield overall. So that’s what I’m looking at today.

On the hunt for income

To begin with, I don’t want to just pick one stock with a yield above 10% and stop there. The main reason is that I don’t feel this diversifies my risk enough. If I put all my eggs in one basket and then the company falls on hard times, 100% of my income is at risk of being cut.

Given that there are many stocks in the FTSE 100 and FTSE 250 that currently have double-digit yields, I can add in more shares without compromising my dividend level. So not only can I retain a high yield, but I can reduce my risk at the same time.

From the FTSE 100 I’ll bring together Rio Tinto (14.05% yield) and Persimmon (13.23%). In the FTSE 250, I’d buy Hammerson (19.58%), Synthomer (13.11%), Diversified Energy Company (12.4%) and Jupiter Fund Management (12.21%).

If I invest the same amount in each stock then I’ll get an average dividend yield of 14.09%.

Risks and rewards

There are ups and downs with this strategy. Let me start with the positives. If the dividends remain the same for all the businesses, the income I’ll receive will be exceptionally high. It will allow me to make a positive return even when taking into account the current rate of inflation (9.1%). It’s also considerably higher than any kind of cash deposit on offer.

However, this concept could be too good to be true. My main concern is the risk level. For instance, I’ll have exposure to property via Hammerson and Persimmon. I’m optimistic about the outlook for the sector, but I acknowledge that some are concerned about it.

Further, I’m exposed to volatile commodity prices from buying shares in Rio Tinto. As for Diversified Energy Company, I don’t need to remind myself about the risk of investing in an oil and gas exploration and production firm!

In reality, it’s the unstable share prices that often provide the high yield in the first place. For example, the Jupiter Fund Management share price is down 50% in the past year. The lower share price pushes up the dividend yield.

Managing my risk with high-dividend-yield stocks

I’m happy to take some exposure to this area. I think blending a mix of stocks is the smart play. However, I’d still only want to invest a small amount of money. It’s not that this portfolio is exactly too good to be true, but I think the probability of earning this level of income for a long period of time isn’t that high.

Jon Smith has no position in any share mentioned. The Motley Fool UK has recommended Jupiter Fund Management and Synthomer. Views expressed on the companies mentioned in this article are those of the writer and therefore may differ from the official recommendations we make in our subscription services such as Share Advisor, Hidden Winners and Pro. Here at The Motley Fool we believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.

More on Investing Articles

Young woman holding up three fingers
Investing Articles

Want to start investing in 2026? 3 things to get ready now!

Before someone is ready to start investing in the stock market, our writer reckons it could well be worth them…

Read more »

Investing Articles

Can the stock market continue its strong performance into 2026?

Will the stock market power ahead next year -- or could its recent strong run come crashing down? Christopher Ruane…

Read more »

Businessman hand stacking money coins with virtual percentage icons
Investing Articles

Here’s how someone could invest £20k in an ISA to target a 7% dividend yield in 2026

Is 7% a realistic target dividend yield for a Stocks and Shares ISA? Christopher Ruane reckons that it could be.…

Read more »

A quiet morning and an empty Victoria Street in Edinburgh's historic Old Town.
Investing Articles

How little is £1k invested in Greggs shares in January worth now?

Just how much value have Greggs shares lost this year -- and why has our writer been putting his money…

Read more »

Businessman using pen drawing line for increasing arrow from 2024 to 2025
Investing Articles

This cheap FTSE 100 stock outperformed Barclays, IAG, and Games Workshop shares in 2025 but no one’s talking about it

This FTSE stock has delivered fantastic gains in 2025, outperforming a lot of more popular shares. Yet going into 2026,…

Read more »

Close-up of British bank notes
Investing Articles

100 Lloyds shares cost £55 in January. Here’s what they’re worth now!

How well have Lloyds shares done in 2025? Very well is the answer, as our writer explains. But they still…

Read more »

Thoughtful man using his phone while riding on a train and looking through the window
Investing Articles

How much do you need in an ISA to target £2,000 a month of passive income

Our writer explores a passive income strategy that involves the most boring FTSE 100 share. But when it comes to…

Read more »

Investing Articles

£5,000 invested in a FTSE 250 index tracker at the start of 2025 is now worth…

Despite underperforming the FTSE 100, the FTSE 250 has been the place to find some of the UK’s top growth…

Read more »