Thinking of investing in buy-to-let? Buying FTSE 250 shares may be a better idea

The FTSE 250 (INDEXFTSE: MCX) could offer superior returns compared to buy-to-lets.

The content of this article was relevant at the time of publishing. Circumstances change continuously and caution should therefore be exercised when relying upon any content contained within this article.

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More.

Despite the potential risks of Brexit, UK property prices continue to rise. According to the Halifax House Price Index, they have increased by 3.7% in the last year. This highlights the imbalance between demand and supply, with house prices continuing to rise even though they have become increasingly unaffordable for first-time buyers in recent years.

As a result, many investors may be tempted to go ahead with a buy-to-let investment. After all, interest rates are low and house prices have a long track record of growth. However, doing so may not be the best move for long-term investors at the present time. Investing in the FTSE 250 could offer lower risk, as well as higher potential rewards.

Reward potential

In terms of the rewards that the FTSE 250 could offer, its track record suggests that it could deliver impressive capital growth in future. In the last 20 years, its total return per year has been around 10.5%. This is exceptionally high, and means that an investment of £1,000 in 1998 would now be worth around £4,668.

With FTSE 250 companies generating around 50% of their income in the UK, the index provides investors with significant exposure to the UK economy. At a time when confidence in the country is relatively low due to Brexit, this could mean that there are a number of stocks that offer wide margins of safety. For example, retailers are experiencing a difficult period due to weak consumer confidence, while the banking sector also faces an uncertain period. Therefore, investors who are looking for assets trading well below their intrinsic values may find such opportunities in the mid-cap index.

Risks

Buy-to-lets are a relatively risky investment. There is a lack of diversity, with all income and all capital growth coming from one asset. Even if an individual has more than one buy-to-let, it is still much easier to diversify via the FTSE 250. With a range of sectors and stocks, a portfolio of 20-30 shares can be built even with relatively limited funds. This could reduce the risks faced by an investor, with most companies likely to pay dividends over the medium term. In contrast, a struggling UK economy could mean that rent payments are delayed or missed for buy-to-let investors.

With 50% of the FTSE 250’s exposure being international, it provides diversification from a geographical perspective. As mentioned, Brexit could have a negative impact on the UK economy in the short run, so having stocks within a portfolio which operate internationally may be a sound move. That’s especially the case since countries such as China and India, as well as the US, continue to offer high growth potential over the medium term.

Takeaway

While investing in a buy-to-let may sound relatively easy due to past house price returns, the lack of diversity and the high reward potential of the FTSE 250 means that the mid-cap index may offer a more enticing investment opportunity. With an excellent track record, the index seems to be a sound place to invest for the long term.

More on Investing Articles

Sunrise over Earth
Investing Articles

Meet the ex-penny share up 109% that has topped Rolls-Royce and Nvidia in 2025

The share price of this investment trust has gone from pennies to above £1 over the past couple of years.…

Read more »

House models and one with REIT - standing for real estate investment trust - written on it.
Investing Articles

1 of the FTSE 100’s most reliable dividend stocks for me to buy now?

With most dividend stocks with 6.5% yields, there's a problem with the underlying business. But LondonMetric Property is a rare…

Read more »

Investing Articles

Is 2026 the year to consider buying oil stocks?

The time to buy cyclical stocks is when they're out of fashion with investors. And that looks to be the…

Read more »

ISA coins
Investing Articles

3 reasons I’m skipping a Cash ISA in 2026

Putting money into a Cash ISA can feel safe. But in 2026 and beyond, that comfort could come at a…

Read more »

US Stock

I asked ChatGPT if the Tesla share price could outperform Nvidia in 2026, with this result!

Jon Smith considers the performance of the Tesla share price against Nvidia stock and compares his view for next year…

Read more »

Investing Articles

Greggs: is this FTSE 250 stock about to crash again in 2026?

After this FTSE 250 stock crashed in 2025, our writer wonders if it will do the same in 2026. Or…

Read more »

Investing Articles

7%+ yields! Here are 3 major UK dividend share forecasts for 2026 and beyond

Mark Hartley checks forecasts and considers the long-term passive income potential of three of the UK's most popular dividend shares.

Read more »

Hand is turning a dice and changes the direction of an arrow symbolizing that the value of an ETF (Exchange Traded Fund) is going up (or vice versa)
Investing Articles

2 top ETFs to consider for an ISA in 2026

Here are two very different ETFs -- one set to ride the global robotics boom, the other offering a juicy…

Read more »