The Beginners’ Portfolio: What If We’d Bought Royal Dutch Shell Plc Instead Of BP Plc?

Did we do well to choose BP plc (LON: BP) ahead of Royal Dutch Shell plc (LON: RDSB)?

| More on:

The content of this article was relevant at the time of publishing. Circumstances change continuously and caution should therefore be exercised when relying upon any content contained within this article.

When investing, your capital is at risk. The value of your investments can go down as well as up and you may get back less than you put in.

Read More

The content of this article is provided for information purposes only and is not intended to be, nor does it constitute, any form of personal advice. Investments in a currency other than sterling are exposed to currency exchange risk. Currency exchange rates are constantly changing, which may affect the value of the investment in sterling terms. You could lose money in sterling even if the stock price rises in the currency of origin. Stocks listed on overseas exchanges may be subject to additional dealing and exchange rate charges, and may have other tax implications, and may not provide the same, or any, regulatory protection as in the UK.

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More.

This article is the latest in a series that aims to help novice investors with the stock market. To enjoy past articles in the series, please visit our full archive.

The Beginners’ Portfolio is a virtual portfolio, which is run as if based on real money with all costs, spreads and dividends accounted for.

I’m currently looking back over my past decisions, which is what we all should do at intervals in order to learn from our successes and mistakes, and as part of that I recently took a look at GlaxoSmithKline and wondered whether I should have gone for AstraZeneca instead.

Battle of the oilies

royal dutch shellThere are other obvious comparisons in the portfolio, and today I’m turning my attention to BP (LSE: BP) (NYSE: BP.US) and considering whether we’d be better off in Royal Dutch Shell (LSE: RDSB) (NYSE: RDS-B.US).

Since I chose BP on 2 August 2012 at a buy price of 434.5p, the shares have risen to 443p for a gain of only 2%. But Shell has actually fallen, from 2,276p on the day to 2,122p, for a drop of 6.7%. If we’d put a £500 slice of our money into Shell instead of BP, here’s how much we’d have paid in total and how much the stake would be worth today:

Company Cost Today Change Dividends Total %
BP £499.01 £480.34 -£12.74 £31.72 £18.98 3.8%
Shell £477.96 £435.62 -£54.53 £29.48 -£25.05 -5.2%

(As of 14 October 2013)

I was surprised by that outcome, as I’d been thinking of the two as pretty much neck and neck. And though it’s nice to see BP ahead and it might support my opinion a year or so ago that it was relatively undervalued, it doesn’t tell us anything yet about whether I made the best long-term choice.

Today’s valuation

Now that the prices have moved, what’s the valuation like?

BP EPS % P/E Dividend Yield Cover
2013 49p +33% 8.9 23p 5.2% 2.1x
2014 57p +16% 7.7 25p 5.7% 2.3x
Shell EPS % P/E Dividend Yield Cover
2013 230p -12% 9.2 115p 5.5% 2.1x
2014 255p +11% 8.3 119p 5.6% 2.2x

(Source: Morningstar)

We can see BP’s earnings set to recover as as expected, but other than that there’s no real difference in the market’s valuation of the two companies.

Back in 2012 I rather glibly glossed over any further costs from the Gulf of Mexico disaster. But that was clearly premature, as we’ve seen a lot more claims than expected at the time. And though BP’s recent court victory was welcome, there will still be the risk of more surprises until the last penny of compensation is paid.

Which is best?

If we were buying today, which would I go for? I recently had a look at Shell as an investment candidate for novices and, largely leaving out valuation, I preferred it to BP — Shell has less upstream risk exposure, has greater turnover and lower debt, and is better diversified geographically.

Overall, with share valuations looking pretty similar, I’m now leaning towards Shell as the better candidate for a multi-decade investment — I don’t think last year’s undervaluation was deep enough to cover the added risk with BP. In reality, I still think the long-term differences in returns will be minimal, but I think Shell’s lower risk could be key. Time will tell whether I got it wrong.

Should you invest, the value of your investment may rise or fall and your capital is at risk. Before investing, your individual circumstances should be assessed. Consider taking independent financial advice.

> Alan does not own any shares mentioned in this article.

More on Investing Articles

Mixed-race female couple enjoying themselves on a walk
Investing Articles

Are Raspberry Pi shares a once-in-a-lifetime chance to get rich?

With Raspberry Pi shares surging after a successful IPO, could this UK tech startup offer a long-term wealth creation opportunity…

Read more »

Newspaper and direction sign with investment options
Investing Articles

Huge gains and 9% yields: why now’s an amazing time to be a stock market investor

The stock market’s generating fantastic returns in 2024. Whether you're looking for gains or income, it’s a great time to…

Read more »

Hand of person putting wood cube block with word VALUE on wooden table
Investing Articles

This steady dividend payer looks like one of the best bargain stocks in the FTSE 100

A yield of 4.7% and a consistent dividend record make this FTSE 100 company look like good value in an…

Read more »

Young mixed-race couple sat on the beach looking out over the sea
Investing Articles

£9,000 in savings? That could become passive income of £19,175 a year

It's possible to invest affordable sums of money into building a big passive income stream. Here's how I'd go about…

Read more »

Black father and two young daughters dancing at home
Investing Articles

Legal & General shares: a once-in-a-decade passive income opportunity?

Is a dividend yield at its highest level in a decade, combined with a strong record of increasing payouts, a…

Read more »

Investing Articles

With a 7% yield and 4.1 P/E, is this the best passive income stock on the FTSE 350?

Millions of Britons invest for a passive income. While our writer isn't buying this stock yet, he believes it's worth…

Read more »

Middle-aged Caucasian woman deep in thought while looking out of the window
Investing Articles

This amazing FTSE 250 has a 8.8% dividend yield and trades at just 4x forward earnings!

Our Foolish writer believes this FTSE 250 stock is worth keeping a very close eye on. However, he's not keen…

Read more »

Portrait of elderly man wearing white denim shirt and glasses looking up with hand on chin. Thoughtful senior entrepreneur, studio shot against grey background.
Investing Articles

Could this brilliant airline stock be the most undervalued company on the FTSE 100?

Our writer believes this FTSE 100 stock may provide market-beating returns over the coming years, noting its undervalued metrics and…

Read more »