A 15% Yield From Property

Published in Company Comment on 11 June 2010

This German property company offers a 15% dividend yield.

Since I became a financial writer in 2003, I've warned Fool readers about what I believe to be a growing bubble in UK domestic housing.

In contrast to the UK, you couldn't find a more different property market than Germany's. From living in Germany on and off from the Seventies to the Nineties, I know it to be the world's most stable -- even boring -- property market. It may come as a shock to UK homeowners to learn that more than half (55%) of Germans rent rather than own!

Deutschland unten alles

Indeed, during the UK's boom of the mid-Nineties to the late Noughties, property prices in Germany barely budged. Likewise, in the financial meltdown of 2007/08, they held up well. Most recently, Germany recorded a lacklustre 0.9% rise (before inflation) in property prices between the first quarters of 2009 and 2010.

The reunification of East and West Germany in 1990 led to predictions of a boom which never arrived. Even in Berlin -- Germany's cultured, lively capital of 3.4 million people -- prices have barely moved over the past two decades, in line with the rest of the country.

Investing in Germany property

So, forget about capital gains, as investing in Germany property is all about weighing up rental yield against maintenance costs. What you want are property vehicles which are well-diversified with stable borrowing costs and attractive rental yields.

One such company, much discussed this year in our popular Paulypilot's Pub discussion board, is Speymill Deutsche Immobilien Company (LSE: SDIC). My Foolish friend David Holding covered SDIC as a play on German property in November 2009. Alas, Speymill's share price has suffered badly due to worries over its running costs and banking covenants. 

Gagging for Gagfah?

Although I never took the plunge, watching Speymill's story unfold did alert me to an exciting play on German property: Gagfah.

Founded in 2005, Gagfah is Germany's largest listed housing association with 165,000 rental units, plus a further 20,000 managed units, spread across 350 German towns and cities.

Although Gagfah is a large, liquid, listed company, you should note that over 60% of its equity is still owned by its founder, the US hedge fund Fortress Investment Group. Fortress was one of a number of investment groups that snaffled up German property in the early Noughties. Given this dominant shareholding, Gagfah's future and strategy will be decided largely by Fortress, rather than Gagfah's other shareholders.

Shares in Luxembourg-based Gagfah SA trade on the Frankfurt Stock Exchange under the ticker GFJ, mostly via the Xetra Trading Platform. Here are Gagfah's basic fundamentals:

NameGagfah SA
TickerGFJ
Shares in issue226m
Market cap€1,234m
Price€5.46
Net asset value per share*€12.52
Funds from operations per share*€0.21
Dividend€0.80
Yield14.6%

* as at 31 March 2010

For more detail, read Gagfah's latest quarterly update (1.7 Mb PDF document; 44 pages).

As you can see, at €5.46, Gagfah shares trade at a 56% discount to their underlying net asset value of €12.52. What's more, largely all of the firm's funds from operations are paid out in quarterly dividends. 

Just look at Gagfah's dividend record during the credit crunch. It has paid a stable quarterly dividend of €0.20 since the second quarter of 2007, with the latest dividend arriving last week.

The share price has been much more volatile. The shares were floated at €19 in October 2006 and although they initially did well, a steady decline soon set in that lasted all of 2007 and 2008. The shares sank as low as €2 in December 2008 before mounting a partial recovery. They've traded at the €5-€7 level for the last year or so.

The credit crunch has drastically slowed Gagfah's expansion plans, too. When the company floated back in 2006, it intended to double its stock of houses from 150,000 over the next five years. Nearly four years later, it's only managed to add 10,000 units.

Of course, nearly all real-estate firms borrow to invest and Gagfah is no exception. It has property valued at €9 billion, net assets of €2.4 billion and financial liabilities of €6.3 billion (with 90% of its loans falling due after 2013).

In summary

Gagfah offers a mammoth yield for income investors, backed by one of the world's most stable property markets.

Of course, there could be a few bumps in the road -- especially if the euro or the EU economy tanks -- but a near-15% yield looks worthy of investigation.

More from Cliff D'Arcy:

> To buy or sell shares, try an online broker account with The Motley Fool's Share Dealing Service. You can deal in real time for a flat rate of just £10 per trade. Click here to open an account for free today. 

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

HGfool 12 Jun 2010 , 11:21am

Are the dividends subject to (Luxembourg?) Witholding Tax?

TheWildshot 14 Jun 2010 , 9:16pm

Was it Fortress who took total holdings of Mapeley after they saw a similar fall in share price? I got stung on Mapeley shares which were a far too similar story to the one portrayed above. Too good to be true?

DarkFratBoy 14 Jun 2010 , 11:09pm

So far as I am aware, Luxembourg dividend WHT does not apply (my understanding is that Gagfah LuxCo falls within an exception for securitisation companies paying out all or almost all of their income receipts), although obviously do your own research (perhaps by checking their website).

Prompted by this article I looked at this stock over the weekend. My principal concern is that the discount to NAV illusory. The credit crunch seems to have had barely any impact on NAV, perhaps because the company is valuing its property portfolio on a discounted cashflow basis, rather than on the basis of a sale between willing buyer and seller. Given the leverage levels the accuracy of NAV here is particularly significant.

My other concern is the lack of director buying. With this sort of yield and discount the directors should be all over this. Compare this to UK listed (Guernsey) investment trust company ALPH, which holds 90% Paris commercial property. Similar yield, similar leverage, but massive mark downs to NAV since the crunch (property valued on an open market sale basis), and directors consistently topping up whenever the market brings the share price down.

I'm not saying buy ALPH (which of course has its own issues), I'm just saying that there may be serious problems with Gagfah (as indicated by the price) that aren't yet apparent from the accounts, and that is far more worrying than a company with bad news in the price, a dividend cut already made, and directors making frequent opportunistic purchases.

Would be interested to hear further thoughts on the topic, but on the basis of what I have seen so far I am not convinced.

Regards,
DFB

Join the conversation

Please take note - some tags have changed.

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: [b]bolded text[/b], [i]italicised text[/i]. All other tags will be removed from your post.

If you want to add a link, please ensure you type it as http://www.fool.co.uk as opposed to www.fool.co.uk.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.