I follow these lessons when comparing funds for my investment ISA or SIPP

ISAs and SIPPs are great vehicles for sheltering your fund investments from tax, and the benefits compound over time, but you need to think of the long term.

The content of this article was relevant at the time of publishing. Circumstances change continuously and caution should therefore be exercised when relying upon any content contained within this article.

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More.

I am going to ask you to choose between two hypothetical funds with a similar investment strategy, to hold long-term in your SIPP or ISA. In the last year, Capital Guard returned 8% and Wealth Defender grew by 5%. Which one do you choose?

Lesson 1: Don’t be short-sighted

Making a decision to buy (or sell) a fund based on short-term performance could leave you chasing returns by moving out of one fund and into last year’s best performer. Trading costs will eat into your savings. Furthermore, according to a 2004 study done by Vanguard Investments Australia, most of the top-performing funds in one year do not make it onto next year’s list, making further trading more likely.

If you are saving for the long term, then chose the fund with the best long-term performance. What is the long term? Well, at least seven years and almost certainly 30 years, but 10-year annualised performance is a good place to start. You want to see how the fund performs in both good and bad times, and how it deals with a changing economy.

Lesson 2: Results may vary

Let’s return to the Capital Guard and Wealth Defender funds. We have 10 years of performance data for them now, with the former returning 5% and the latter 3.5% on average over that period, and so Capital Guard seems to be the one to go with.

Looking back over the performance history you see that there were a couple of years where Capital Guard made negative returns of not more than 1%, and although Wealth Defender made 0% a few times, it never reported a negative return. Have you changed your mind about which one to buy?

Higher returns usually come with higher risk, so it should not be surprising that Capital Guard has more volatile returns compared with Wealth Defender and periods of poor performance can and do occur. The drawdowns are very small so it appears that excessive risk is not being taken. A well-managed fund with a consistent investing plan that has performed well over the long term will probably do so again. So, why not reach for the higher return if you have time on your side to recover of any losses that may occur.

There are no guarantees, of course – both of these funds could perform very differently in the future compared to the past, which leads us to the final lesson.

Lesson 3: Stick to the plan

Our hypothetical funds both claim to invest in large-cap UK income stocks, which is what we wanted. A fund that is moving away from what it was good at, as Neil Woodford’s Equity Income Fund did, is a warning that the future may not at all be like the past. 

If our funds start reporting increasing exposures to European or US equities or growth and small-cap stocks start appearing in their holdings, then they are no longer what we are looking for. Also, check to see that the management team responsible for the past performance is still in place.

While it is absolutely true that past performance does not guarantee future performance, having a consistent investing style and management team should give us more confidence when using historical data to inform our choices.

Should you invest, the value of your investment may rise or fall and your capital is at risk. Before investing, your individual circumstances should be assessed. Consider taking independent financial advice.

James J. McCombie has no position in any of the shares mentioned. The Motley Fool UK has no position in any of the shares mentioned. Views expressed on the companies mentioned in this article are those of the writer and therefore may differ from the official recommendations we make in our subscription services such as Share Advisor, Hidden Winners and Pro. Here at The Motley Fool we believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.

More on Investing Articles

Investing Articles

3 of my top FTSE 250 stocks to consider buying before April

Buying undervalued UK shares can be a great way to generate long-term wealth. Here, Royston Wild reveals a handful on…

Read more »

Ice cube tray filled with ice cubes and three loose ice cubes against dark wood.
Investing Articles

Just released: our 3 top income-focused stocks to buy before April [PREMIUM PICKS]

Our goal here is to highlight some of our past recommendations that we think are of particular interest today, due…

Read more »

Investing Articles

Is this the best chance to buy cheap FTSE 100 shares in a generation?

I want to buy shares when they're cheap, and sell... never, just keep taking the dividends. And the FTSE 100…

Read more »

Man putting his card into an ATM machine while his son sits in a stroller beside him.
Investing Articles

Could NatWest shares be 2024’s number one buy for passive income?

For those of us looking to earn some long-term passive income, how does NatWest's 7% dividend yield sound? It sounds…

Read more »

Investing Articles

£12K in savings? Here’s how I could turn that into £13K annual passive income

This Fool explains how investing a lump sum can help her build a passive income stream to enjoy in her…

Read more »

Aerial shot showing an aircraft shadow flying over an idyllic beach
Investing Articles

Here’s why Rolls-Royce shares are now set to fly over the £4 mark

Once again, Rolls-Royce shares are crushing the FTSE 100. Should I add to my holding of this stock at the…

Read more »

Investing Articles

1 under the radar FTSE 100 AI stock investors should consider buying

Our writer explains why this FTSE 100 pick could be a shrewd investment with its established experience of using AI…

Read more »

Investing Articles

Does the beaten-down Diageo share price make it a no-brainer buy?

Harvey Jones spent years waiting for the Diageo share price to look like good value, before finally buying it in…

Read more »