One 9% dividend I’d buy more of, and one I’d dump as quickly as possible

With many 9%-plus dividend stocks on offer these days, we need to be very careful which ones to choose.

| More on:

The content of this article was relevant at the time of publishing. Circumstances change continuously and caution should therefore be exercised when relying upon any content contained within this article.

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More.

Shares in Low & Bonar (LSE: LWB) have had a dire couple of years, losing 80% of their value since a peak in the summer of 2017.

That includes a 10% drop on Wednesday after the company, which makes “advanced, high-performance materials from polymer-based yarns and fibres,” revealed it’s up against its banking covenant limits and needs to raise some new cash.

To that end, the firm is tapping the market for a £54m top-up in the form of a big new share issue. The offer will be at 15p per share, a discount of 17% on Tuesday’s closing mid-price, and that quickly led to an 11% drop by midday Wednesday, to 16p.

Cash problems

Chief executive Philip de Klerk said: “Over recent years, not enough was invested in some of the Group’s key manufacturing sites, a failed strategy to expand in Civil Engineering was pursued, and there was insufficient focus on cost and cash.”

The actual results took a bit of a back seat to the new funding plan, revealing a statutory pre-tax loss of £42.2m, more than twice last year’s loss. On an underlying basis, pre-tax profit came in 45.6% down at £16.7m, with underlying EPS falling 44.5% to 3.56p.

One of the key redeeming features of an investment in Low & Bonar over the past year has been its dividend. But that’s been slashed by more than half, from 3.05p per share to 1.42p. Too little, too late, in my view.

On today’s depressed share price, that still represents a yield of nearly 9%. I maintain my insistence that paying out big dividends while desperately short of cash is bad management, and a company that does so won’t see a penny of my investment pot.

I’d buy this one

When I rate a share as a buy but don’t buy any myself, I’m sometimes asked why? The simple answer is that I just don’t have enough cash to invest in every company I’m bullish about. I think there are many great big-dividend bargains out there now, especially in our undervalued FTSE 100. But my finances are, alas, not unlimited.

But one contrarian high-dividend stock I have bought is house-builder Persimmon (LSE: PSN).

Persimmon is forecast to provide dividend yields of 9.8% for this year and the next two, and I explained recently why it got the nod for some of my retirement cash.

We do, however, need to put those mooted 9.8% yields into perspective, as they include a big portion of special dividends as the company returns surplus capital to shareholders.

Cash cows

But even without that extra cash, ordinary dividends are expected to yield around 5.5% over the longer term, and I see that as one of the best long-term cash streams the FTSE 100 has to offer.

Mired in a long-term housing shortage as we are, I think the same about our other top house-builders. Taylor Wimpey shares are offering dividend yields of more than 10%, with Barratt Developments on forecast yields of around 8.5%. And we’re looking at three companies on P/E multiples of only around eight.

I know I’ve been banging on about these house-builder stocks being cheap for some time, but I do find their low valuations impossible to justify. And at least I’ve put my money where my mouth is.

Alan Oscroft owns shares of Persimmon. The Motley Fool UK has no position in any of the shares mentioned. Views expressed on the companies mentioned in this article are those of the writer and therefore may differ from the official recommendations we make in our subscription services such as Share Advisor, Hidden Winners and Pro. Here at The Motley Fool we believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.

More on Investing Articles

Businessman hand stacking money coins with virtual percentage icons
Investing Articles

£5,000 invested in Tesco shares 5 years ago is now worth this much…

Tesco share price growth has been just part of the total profit picture, but can our biggest supermarket handle the…

Read more »

Investing Articles

Here’s why I’m bullish on the FTSE 100 for 2026

There's every chance the FTSE 100 will set new record highs next year. In this article, our Foolish author takes…

Read more »

Thoughtful man using his phone while riding on a train and looking through the window
Growth Shares

UK interest rates fall again! Here’s why the Barclays share price could struggle

Jon Smith explains why the Bank of England's latest move today could spell trouble for the Barclays share price over…

Read more »

Man hanging in the balance over a log at seaside in Scotland
Investing Articles

2 out-of-favour FTSE 250 stocks set for a potential turnaround in 2026

These famous retail stocks from the FTSE 250 index have crashed in 2025. Here's why 2026 might turn out to…

Read more »

Young female business analyst looking at a graph chart while working from home
Investing Articles

Down over 30% this year, could these 3 UK shares bounce back in 2026?

Christopher Ruane digs into a trio of UK shares that have performed poorly this year in search of possible bargains…

Read more »

Mature people enjoying time together during road trip
Investing Articles

Yields up to 8.5%! Should I buy even more Legal & General, M&G and Phoenix shares?

Harvey Jones is getting a brilliant rate of dividend income from his Phoenix shares, and a surprising amount of capital…

Read more »

Light trails from traffic moving down The Mound in central Edinburgh, Scotland during December
Investing Articles

Up 7.5% in a week but with P/Es below 8! Are JD Sports Fashion and easyJet shares ready to take off?

easyJet shares have laboured in 2025, but suddenly they're flying. The same goes for JD Sports Fashion. Both still look…

Read more »

US Stock

I think this could be the best no-brainer S&P 500 purchase to consider for 2026

Jon Smith reveals a stock from the S&P 500 that he feels has the biggest potential to outperform the index,…

Read more »