Will BHP Billiton plc And Glencore PLC Ever Return To Their 2011 Highs?

Back in 2011 Glencore (LSE: GLEN) and BHP Billiton (LSE: BLT) seemed unstoppable. Glencore’s IPO had proved popular with investors and China’s seemingly insatiable demand for commodities had sent shares in BHP to their all-time high of £26.10. 

Unfortunately, the good times didn’t last long. By the end of 2011 shares in BHP and Glencore had lost 21% and 26% respectively, setting the pace for the next four years. 

New lows 

Since the beginning of 2011, shares in BHP and Glencore have lost more than three-quarters of their value and many investors are now asking if these mining giants will ever be able to return to their former glory. 

Well, for BHP’s shares to go back to their all-time high of £26.10, they would need to rise 320% from current levels, while Glencore’s shares would have to rise sixfold before returning to their IPO price. These gains aren’t wholly unrealistic. Both BHP and Glencore have a history of navigating volatile commodity markets and the two companies spent years building up their operations before hitting a cyclical peak back in 2011. 

There’s no reason why Glencore and BHP can’t repeat this performance, it’s just a question of time. 

Waiting out the cycle 

Like almost all markets, commodity markets are cyclical. Riding out the peaks and troughs of the market is just part of the job for Glencore and BHP. These two industry giants have what it takes to ride out the trough while smaller, more inefficient producers get pushed to the sidelines and struggle to compete. When these smaller producers start to collapse, BHP and Glencore’s profits will surge as supply dwindles and commodity prices recover. 

The two miners are pulling out all the stops to ensure that they’re in the best financial shape to weather the storm, no matter how long it takes. 

For example, BHP is slashing capital spending and the company already has some of the industry’s lowest production costs, which gives it an enormous advantage over smaller peers. Meanwhile, Glencore is selling off non-core assets, future production and paying down debt to reassure investors. Also, the group’s trading division continues to rack up profits, giving the group an edge over smaller producers. Glencore announced a few weeks ago that its debt reduction plan should be completed ahead of schedule, surprising City analysts and restoring some confidence in the company. 

Patience is a virtue

All in all, Glencore and BHP have what it takes to ride out the commodity cycle, but there’s no telling how long the downturn will last. Some City analysts believe that low commodity prices are here to stay. On the other hand, some analysts are forecasting that by the end of the decade, supply/demand will have rebalanced, and prices will recover. 

It’s impossible to tell which group of analysts is correct. It’s clear that it will take some time for commodity markets to rebalance. For the time being investors are being paid to wait for this recovery. BHP’s shares currently support a dividend yield of 13.9%, and analysts expect that Glencore’s shares will support a yield of 1.6% next year. 

If it's income you're looking for, there are plenty of top income stocks out there with brighter outlooks than BHP and Glencore.  

One such opportunity is revealed in the Motley Fool's new report. The report, titled A Top Income Share From The Motley Fool, gives a full rundown of the company our analysts believe is one of the market's most defensive dividend champions. 

This is essential reading for income investors.

The report is completely free and will be delivered straight to your inbox. Click here to download the free report today!

Rupert Hargreaves has no position in any shares mentioned. The Motley Fool UK has no position in any of the shares mentioned. We Fools don't all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.