Does USwitch Deal Make Zoopla Property Group PLC A Buy, Or Are Rightmove Plc & Moneysupermarket.Com Group PLC Still A Better Choice?

The owner of the UK’s number two property website, Zoopla Property Group (LSE: ZPLA), has purchased price comparison website uSwitch, in a £160m deal that puts it in direct competition with sector leader Moneysupermarket.Com Group (LSE: MONY).

uSwitch’s 2014 revenue of £62.9m is only a quarter of the £238.1m reported by last year, making uSwitch very much a number two player in this market.

That’s also a fair description of Zoopla’s share of the online property sector, versus market leader Rightmove (LSE: RMV).

Zoopla will now be a number two player in two big, profitable markets.

In this article, I’ll ask whether owning shares in Zoopla is likely to be more profitable than owning shares in Rightmove and, which are both top players in a single market?

A closer look

Zoopla’s purchase of uSwitch is a clear admission that it cannot unseat Rightmove, so is going to diversify, in order to try and stimulate growth and extend its relationship with its users.

Zoopla is also fighting a second problem: it lost 11% of its advertisers to new property portal OnTheMarket at the start of this year. The best way to stem this decline is to increase user numbers.

Buying uSwitch isn’t a bad idea: uSwitch claims to be the number one comparison site for energy and broadband, providing obvious cross-marketing opportunities with Zoopla’s property business.

However, uSwitch hasn’t come cheap. Zoopla’s purchase price of £160m equates to 9.9 times uSwitch’s 2014 earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation (EBITDA) of £16.2m, rising to 11.7 times EBITDA, if a £30m performance earn-out payment is triggered.

Zoopla will spend around £25m of its £31m net cash balance and open up a new £150m debt facility to pay for this deal, adding risk and cost to the business. The firm has promised to maintain its current dividend policy of paying out 35-45% of group profits, putting further pressure on cash generation.

Some risks

uSwitch’s revenue has grown at a compound average rate of 20% per year over the last three years, but this deal isn’t without risk, in my view.

uSwitch’s business has always been based around encouraging customers to switch energy supplier and receiving a commission payment in return.

I don’t see this as being the most attractive area of the price comparison market, as it’s a business model that could be vulnerable to politically-led regulatory restrictions, and to changing tariffs and marketing practices among the big utilities.

In contrast, makes most of its profits in the less regulated areas of personal finance and insurance.

My view

In my view, Zoopla’s property and price comparison assets are less attractive than those of Rightmove — whose 73% operating margin is twice that of Zoopla — and, which today confirmed it expects to meet full-year expectations of a 36% hike in earnings per share in 2015.

It’s often better to be the best at one thing than second best at several, and I believe this is the case here: in my view, both Rightmove and Moneysupermarket remain more attractive buys than Zoopla.

The best online growth buy?

However, if you are looking for a really profitable online growth opportunity, I believe the answer could lie in the UK retail sector.

The Motley Fool's market-beating analysts have identified a UK retailer that's in the early stages of a massive online expansion.

The Fool's experts have crunched the numbers and believe that this firm's sales could rise by 200% in just five years.

For more details about this unique opportunity, download "3 Hidden Factors Behind This Daring E-commerce Play" today.

It's FREE and without obligation.

To get your copy, simply click here now.

Roland Head has no position in any shares mentioned. The Motley Fool UK has recommended We Fools don't all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.