Which should I buy, the S&P 500 or the FTSE 100?

Since the global financial crisis of 2007-09, the S&P 500 index has blown away the FTSE 100. So why do I keep buying cheap British shares?

| More on:

Image source: Getty Images

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More.

Nowadays, my investing strategy is being tested. On one hand, I don’t wish to bet against America, so my family has huge exposure to the S&P 500 index. On the other, the FTSE 100 has rarely been so cheap, which appeals to my instincts as a value investor.

The Footsie falls far behind

In the recent past, there’s been no contest: the S&P 500 has absolutely thrashed the Footsie over all periods. Here’s how the two indexes have performed over five different timescales:

IndexFTSE 100S&P 500S&P
One month-1.6%+5.4%+7.0%
2024 so far-2.2%+5.1%+7.3%
Six months-0.7%+12.2%+13.0%
One year-4.4%+22.8%+27.3%
Five years+4.5%+80.6%+76.1%
*All figures exclude dividends

My table shows that — ignoring cash dividends — the FTSE 100 has produced negative returns in four of these five periods. Over five years, its annual growth works out to less than 1% a year. Big whoop.

Meanwhile, the S&P 500 has stormed ahead, producing attractive returns over periods ranging from one month to five years. Over half a decade, it has trounced the Footsie by more than 76 percentage points. Wow.

Why buy British?

I’m delighted that the vast majority of my family wealth has backed America for the past decade and more. This approach has paid off handsomely, delivering life-changing sums.

That said, I’m increasingly nervous about the strength of this latest market rally. Since 27 October, the US index has leapt by 21.7%. To me, this looks to be too far, too fast.

Then again, history shows that record market highs are usually followed by more of the same, driven by momentum. Thus, I’m reluctant to reduce my exposure to the world’s largest economy, stock market, and companies.

However, the London market looks too undervalued for me to ignore. Right now, the FTSE 100 trades on a lowly multiple of 10.2 times earnings, producing an earnings yield of 9.8%. That’s very cheap, both in geographical and historical terms.

Nevertheless, British shares also looked cheap five and 10 years ago, with nothing much having changed since. But investing theory suggests buying cheap assets is one way to produce superior future returns. Hence, I’ll keeping buying UK stocks, while maintaining my US exposure.

One cheap UK stock

One undervalued British business I’d like to own more of is Barclays (LSE: BARC). The shares are down 25% over one year and 10.9% over five years (excluding dividends). As I write, the share price stands at 142.2p, valuing this group at under £21.6bn.

Following these price slides, Barclays shares trade on a bargain-basement multiple of 4.2 times earnings, delivering a bumper earnings yield of 23.6% a year.

This means that their market-beating dividend yield of 5.4% a year is covered nearly 4.4 times by trailing earnings. To me, this payout looks rock solid, with room for further uplifts.

Alas, the Blue Eagle bank has slipped up a few times in recent years and faces strong headwinds in 2024. I’ve no doubt that loan losses and bad debts will be higher this year, while credit growth will be weak.

Despite this, I’m happy to hold onto my Barclays shares for the long haul, not least for their chunky cash yield. Indeed, I’d buy more, had I investable cash to spare!

Should you invest, the value of your investment may rise or fall and your capital is at risk. Before investing, your individual circumstances should be assessed. Consider taking independent financial advice.

Cliff D’Arcy has an economic interest in Barclays shares. The Motley Fool UK has recommended Barclays. Views expressed on the companies mentioned in this article are those of the writer and therefore may differ from the official recommendations we make in our subscription services, such as Share Advisor, Hidden Winners and Pro. Here at The Motley Fool, we believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.

More on Investing Articles

Young Asian man drinking coffee at home and looking at his phone
Investing Articles

2 recession-resistant UK stocks I’d buy and hold for a decade!

Our writer details two UK stocks she believes could still continue to perform well in a recession and not feel…

Read more »

Back view of blue NIO EP9 electric vehicle
Investing Articles

Down 31% this year! Is now the moment to buy NIO stock?

NIO stock has moved sharply downwards in the past couple of months. Christopher Ruane likes the business potential -- but…

Read more »

Smart young brown businesswoman working from home on a laptop
Investing Articles

2 dividend stocks I reckon could grow payouts for years to come!

This Fool is looking for dividend stocks and explains why these two picks could be primed to grow their payouts…

Read more »

Arrow symbol glowing amid black arrow symbols on black background.
Investing Articles

Should I buy, sell, or hold my Rolls-Royce shares at £3.50?

This Fool considers what he should do with his Rolls-Royce shares following the FTSE 100 company's excellent full-year results last…

Read more »

Couple working from home while daughter watches video on smartphone with headphones on
Investing Articles

With a spare £280, here’s how I’d start buying shares this March

Our writer reflects on what he has learnt on the stock market to explain how he would start buying shares…

Read more »

Businesswoman calculating finances in an office
Investing Articles

Are these expensive FTSE 100 stocks actually brilliant bargains?

Paul Summers takes a closer look at two FTSE 100 stocks that could recover strongly in time, despite already carrying…

Read more »

Investing Articles

What might the recent Aviva share price performance tell me as an investor?

Christopher Ruane looks at how the Aviva share price has performed over the past 12 months and considers whether he…

Read more »

Investing Articles

Down by a quarter, is the BT share price a steal?

The BT share price has more than halved in the past five years. What is holding it down -- and…

Read more »