The going remains tough for the big UK-listed banks, as the aftermath of the financial crisis rumbles on for longer than anybody dreamed.
The PPI mis-selling scandal has cost the big banks $26bn and rising (and will continue to hurt until spring 2018) while the tax and regulatory onslaught from politicians and regulators has cost even more in ceaseless levies, taxes, fines, penalties and customer redress provisions. I suspect the biggest losses are unquantifiable: the multi-billion sums the big banks will lose (in perpetuity) from clipping their global and investment banking wings.
Competition Killer
They also face a growing threat from challenger banks and their regulatory backer, the Competition & Markets Authority. The CMA is halfway through an 18-month investigation into the current account and SME markets, dominated by the big four. While most investors still want exposure to the key UK banking sector, in the current environment they should pick their stocks carefully.
Royal Bank of Scotland Group still has too many problems on its plate while HSBC Holdings must swallow a dollop of crisis-stricken China.
BARC And Bite
Barclays (LSE: BARC) is starting to make steady progress again, its share price up 13% in the last year. Executive chairman John McFarlane has warned investors of a tough 18 months as he looks to hammer the bank back into shape, focusing on core operations such as UK personal and commercial banking, European and US investment banking, Barclaycard and Africa, and dropping those where margins don’t match up. Expect no flip-flopping from hard man McFarlane, who recently banned the offending footwear from head office.
Focusing on core strengths is a sound strategy for a business that has come under fire from so many different angles. At a forecast 10.7 times earnings there is still value in Barclays, and while today’s 2.5% yield still disappoints the dividend is nicely covered 2.7 times and forecast to hit 3.6% by the end of next year. Forecast earnings per share growth of 36% this year and 19% in 2016 should keep the bandwagon rolling. If the hard work is done by 2017, as McFarlane reckons, investors will be glad they bought today.
Laugh Out LLOY
Don’t be distracted by next spring’s popular privatisation of Lloyds Banking Group (LSE: LLOY), there are good reasons to buy this stock now. At 8.8 times earnings the price is right, even without the incentives Chancellor George Osborne is promising next year. It still yields less than 1% but dividend take-off is almost upon us and City forecasts suggest this could top 5% as early as next year.
An expected 6% drop in earnings per share next year shows that Lloyds is still in recovery mode. Like Barclays, it is rightly focusing on its key strengths, the UK personal and small business banking markets, although this could backfire if the UK recovery stalls and interest rate rises are postponed. The Lloyds share price is up just 3% this year, despite rising profits, hobbled by institutional and now retail sell-offs.
Once the spring flotation is done and dusted, Lloyds is free to start climbing higher, especially if an over-subscribed privatisation whips up investor excitement.
