The Motley Fool

Will Taylor Wimpey plc Outperform Barratt Developments Plc, Berkeley Group Holdings PLC & Persimmon plc In 2015?

Housebuilders are in a sweet spot and their shares will continue to outperform the market in 2015, the bulls argue. I am not so sure.

However, if the bulls are right, should you add Taylor Wimpey (LSE: TW) to your portfolio? Or should you choose one among Berkeley (LSE: BKG), Persimmon (LSE: PSN) and Barratt (LSE: BDEV)?

Sign up for FREE issues of The Motley Fool Collective. Do you want straightforward views on what’s happening with the stock market, direct to your inbox? Help yourself with our FREE email newsletter designed to help you protect and grow your portfolio. Click here to get started now — it’s FREE!

Taylor Wimpey: Cheap Enough? 

Taylor Wimpey stock is up 20% in 2014, but still trades some 10% below the average price target from brokers, which has risen by 20% since December 2013. The shares are trading around their five-year highs. 

This is one of the cheapest stock in the peer group, based on earnings and cash flow multiples, so Taylor Wimpey could be a bet worth taking in 2015. Its dividend yield will likely come in above 7% in the next couple of years, while its dividend cover ratio stands at 1.5x, with a free cash flow yield north of 7%.

Taylor Wimpey’s pipeline is healthy and its needs are almost fully covered, given that the builder has secured land for 2015 and 2016. Operating profitability could be higher than 20% over the medium term, which is one element I like. This may turned out to be the most obvious investment in the sector, but management must maintain financial discipline in order to deliver shareholder value.

Barratt’s On A Roll 

Barratt stock is up almost 30% in 2014. The average price target from brokers has risen by roughly the same amount in the last 12 months. So, what lies ahead for shareholders? 

Based on trading multiples and fundamentals, Barratt shares may offer more upside in 2015, although its free cash flow yield is less appealing than that of rivals at the moment. However, Barrett is expected to continue to grow revenues above UK inflation, while its operating profit margin is expected to rise over time, which should boost Barratt’s cash flow and payout profile.

Its aggressive capital structure could help it boost shareholders’ returns into 2018. Moreover, the stock’s price to earnings ratio stands at 10x and 9x for 2015 and 2016, respectively, so the shares are not particularly expensive.

Berkeley/Persimmon: The Laggards? 

Berkeley stock is in negative territory (-5%) for 2014. This is a bet on London and the South East, where growth prospects have now become less enticing, the bears argue. To a certain degree, there’s merit in that view. 

On the one hand, the shares of players boasting a more diverse geographical mix, such as Barratt, could offer more upside. On the other hand, Berkeley stock looks a bit overvalued based on trading multiples.

My best guess?

Berkeley shares will likely underperform those of rivals by at about 10% in 2015. 

Finally, Persimmon shares have risen by 25% in 2014. They are rather expensive right now and trade at a premium of 10% against those of competitors. The average price target from brokers is in line with Persimmon’s current stock price, which is not a warning sign, in my view, because Persimmon offers better returns than the sector — but whether its stock will continue to rally, that is another matter. 

The UK government has reduced the stamp duty, and interest rates will remain low for years, but I am not upbeat about short-term prospects for the sector. I prefer a different risk profile, such as the one associated with a less cyclical businesses, whose shares have bottomed out in recent weeks, in my view.

More broadly, the stocks identified in our FREE report offer a market-beating yield and capital gains north of 10% in 2015: view it right away by simply clicking hereThis report is completely free and comes without further obligation for a limited amount of time!

Alessandro Pasetti has no position in any shares mentioned. We Fools don't all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.