Should You Buy Lloyds Banking Group plc Or HSBC Holdings plc?

Having made one of the UK banks one of my tips of the year, I’ve been a touch disappointed to see bank share prices falling rather than rising in the past month.

Perhaps, with the on-surge of the economic recovery, we have been a tad over-optimistic and ahead of ourselves about the prospects of the banks. When over-optimism meets reality, share prices fall.

But now that bank share prices have fallen, I see this as a buying opportunity, rather than a time to bale out of banks. The question is, which bank should you buy? In this article I write about a couple of heavyweight contenders…

LloydsBankLloyds Banking Group

In an economic recession where housing and finance were at the centre of the crisis, it is not surprising that the shares of the UK’s leading mortgage provider, Lloyds Banking Group (LSE: LLOY) (NYSE: LYG.US), tumbled.

Yet as we finally see the recession end, and the housing market recover strongly, banking shares — and Lloyds in particular — have bounced back. Over the past year, Lloyds has been the best performing of the banks.

Yet I expect Lloyds to continue to perform well this year as well. The bank is a contrarian play on the housing boom and the banking recovery. The past few months have shown that the number of houses being bought is steadily rising, and house prices are increasing. This is a positive for house builders such as Barratt Developments, as well as banks such as Lloyds.


 If Lloyds is a contrarian play on the housing boom and banking recovery, HSBC (LSE: HSBA) (NYSE: HSBC.US) is a value play in developed markets and a growth play in emerging and frontier markets.

Unlike Lloyds, the bulk of HSBC’s business is common-or-garden retail banking and business banking, with less emphasis on housing. It, alongside Banco Santander, is one of the few truly global banks, with businesses spanning the globe from Africa and Asia to Europe, North America and South America. By assets, it is the world’s biggest bank.

The bank has been relatively untroubled by the financial crisis, and its sheer scale means that it is a very stable business that produces profits consistently year after year. This means this is perhaps the ideal income share, producing a steadily rising dividend, as well as an increasing share price.

Yet the sheer size of the company also means that you are unlikely to see the rapid growth that you might see with other, smaller companies.

Foolish bottom line

So, my conclusion is that both companies are worthwhile buys. Which bank you invest in depends on whether you would like to invest in a company that is slightly riskier but which has great turn-around potential (Lloyds), or a stable but slow-growing company with a juicy dividend yield (HSBC). Personally, I have chosen Lloyds as I think it has better growth potential.

How to create dividends for life

If you want to make money from shares we at the Fool think that you should make dividend investing central to your investing strategy. The core of this strategy is to buy shares which are good value, with high dividend yields as well as the likelihood of long-term capital growth.

Reinvest these dividends on a regular basis, keep faith in your shares through the highs and the lows, and you may be surprised how quickly your money grows.

Want to learn more? Well our experts at the Fool have put together a free report which explains how you can be a dividend investor. Just click on this link to read about "How to create dividends for life", and it will be dispatched instantly to your inbox.

> Prabhat owns shares in Lloyds Banking Group and Barratt Developments.