Are index funds safe?

Are index funds safe, or are they a bubble waiting to burst?

The content of this article was relevant at the time of publishing. Circumstances change continuously and caution should therefore be exercised when relying upon any content contained within this article.

A golden egg in a nest

Image source: Getty Images.

Index funds are often touted as being suitable for most investors. It’s easy to see the appeal of them. Hard-earned savings can be eaten away by extortionate fees of active fund managers. The usually low lump sum and monthly contribution amounts appeal to those who wish to start small and save a percentage of their regular income. And passive investors can set up a monthly direct debit and then forget about their savings until retirement. Or can they?

Warren Buffett believes in index trackers, as do many of my fellow Fool’s. However, of late, numerous people have been warning about the dangers of investing in them. I wanted to examine this side of the argument.

5 Stocks For Trying To Build Wealth After 50

One notable billionaire made 99% of his current wealth after his 50th birthday. And here at The Motley Fool, we believe it is NEVER too late to start trying to build your fortune in the stock market. Our expert Motley Fool analyst team have shortlisted 5 companies that they believe could be a great fit for investors aged 50+ trying to build long-term, diversified portfolios.

Click here to claim your free copy now!

Michael Burry, the famed investor from The Big Short, has concerns about passive funds. In Bloomberg, he likened index investing to the subprime CDOs that were instrumental in causing the 2008 financial crisis.

According to Burry, the similarities are caused because the price setting is not being done by “fundamental security-level analysis”. His worry is that passive investors are buying each company at a fixed ratio, rather than considering the actual value of the company in the underlying index.

Although I think index investing – or holding passive funds as part of an investment portfolio – could be a great strategy, I do share some of Burry’s concerns.

The main obstacle for me is – what happens if the markets go into free-fall?

The next bubble?

I question the temperament of a passive fund-holder. An investor with their money held totally in index funds could see their wealth drop by a huge margin. They would lack the benefit of an active fund or self-managed equities, which might enable them to shift assets to other territories or classes.

What would the average passive investor do in that situation? Hold and watch the price fall further, or sell and realise their losses? I think in this situation, a market sell-off could occur. Perhaps, then, we are in the bubble that Burry describes.

Of course, no one can predict what will happen in the market going forward. But in this situation, if the bubble pops, I think the true cool-headed passive investor who continues to buy at these low price points, might be rubbing their hands together.


I think that the problem of passive investors rushing to the door, and causing a downward spiral, could only arise if index funds owned the majority of the market. An estimate in 2017 put the global figure of shares owned by index funds at 18%.

Index funds have their place in the market, just as actively managed funds and personal investors who pick their investments do. Ultimately, though, if an investor can set aside time to learn about investing and keep up to date with the market news, and avoid picking a few losing stocks in the index, their returns should exceed the respective market index.

Is this little-known company the next ‘Monster’ IPO?

Right now, this ‘screaming BUY’ stock is trading at a steep discount from its IPO price, but it looks like the sky is the limit in the years ahead.

Because this North American company is the clear leader in its field which is estimated to be worth US$261 BILLION by 2025.

The Motley Fool UK analyst team has just published a comprehensive report that shows you exactly why we believe it has so much upside potential.

But I warn you, you’ll need to act quickly, given how fast this ‘Monster IPO’ is already moving.

Click here to see how you can get a copy of this report for yourself today

T Sligo has no position in any of the shares mentioned. The Motley Fool UK has no position in any of the shares mentioned. Views expressed on the companies mentioned in this article are those of the writer and therefore may differ from the official recommendations we make in our subscription services such as Share Advisor, Hidden Winners and Pro. Here at The Motley Fool we believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.

More on Investing Articles

Hand flipping wooden cubes for change wording" Panic " to " Calm".
Investing Articles

This cheap share fell 30% last week. I’d buy now

This huge US corporation saw its shares crash by 30% last week. But I'd buy this surprisingly cheap share now…

Read more »

Various denominations of notes in a pile
Investing Articles

These 7 shares produce passive income of 7% to 11% a year!

Passive income is extra money I make without working. By buying these seven shares, I could earn 8.9% a year…

Read more »

A person holding onto a fan of twenty pound notes
Investing Articles

6.6%+ dividend yields! 2 FTSE 100 dividend stocks to buy

Finding the best dividend stocks to buy requires extra care today as soaring inflation takes a bite out of shareholder…

Read more »

Arrow symbol glowing amid black arrow symbols on black background.
Investing Articles

At 85p, are Rolls-Royce shares a slam-dunk buy?

The Rolls-Royce share price is in penny stock territory. Roland Head explains why he thinks this FTSE 100 stalwart looks…

Read more »

Business development to success and FTSE 100 250 350 growth concept.
Investing Articles

‘Big Short’ investor Michael Burry is buying this quality growth stock! Should I?

In the first quarter, Michael Burry bought more of this growth stock. Is this a hint that I should also…

Read more »

A beach at sunset where there is an inscription on the sand "Breathe Deeeply".
Investing Articles

Stock market crash: here’s why falling prices is good news

Over in the US, a stock market crash is battering high-priced stocks. But I see falling shares as an opportunity…

Read more »

Hand flipping wooden cubes for change wording" Panic " to " Calm".
Investing Articles

These 5 FTSE 100 shares crashed in 2022. I’d buy 1 today

Although the FTSE 100 index is flat in 2022, some Footsie shares have crashed hard this year. But I see…

Read more »

Passive income text with pin graph chart on business table
Investing Articles

How investors can boost their passive income when the FTSE is falling

Stock markets are plagued with fears right now. Here's why I firmly believe those fears improve our passive income prospects.

Read more »