NEW! Our Hero’s Journey tool can help you with your next step towards financial freedom - click here to try now.
Woman pulling baffled face

Why is my car insurance so high with no accidents?

By:  Karl Talbot | 21st July 2021

The cost of car insurance can be eye-watering, especially if you’re new to the roads. Yet we’re led to believe that if we drive carefully and don’t make any claims, the cost of our premium should come down.

So why do some insurers quote you an arm and a leg even if you’ve never had an accident? 

How does car insurance work?

Before we tackle the main question, it’s important to establish that the cost of car insurance differs depending on the type of cover. There are three main types of cover:

Besides the type of cover you choose, the cost of your car insurance can also vary depending on a number of other factors. These can include your age, where you live, how much your car is worth, where you park your car at night and whether you have any driving convictions.

There are other factors to consider too. For the full list, see our article on how to get cheaper car insurance.  

Why is my car insurance so high even with no accidents?

Now we’ve discussed the main variables that can impact the cost of car insurance, let’s explore the main question. Why do some insurers quote you a hefty sum even though you’re a careful driver?

Here are four reasons why you could be quoted a high price.

1. The loyalty penalty

While insurers love careful drivers who don’t make costly claims, they’re businesses too, which is why some will attempt to boost profits by any means necessary.

This often means quoting existing policyholders more than new customers, hoping that they’ll renew without doing any research. Customer apathy – also known as the ‘loyalty penalty’ – is big business in the personal finance world,

Try to avoid just automatically renewing your policy. Take the time to compare quotes from a number of providers. The easiest way to do this is by using the services of a price comparison website such as MoneySuperMarket. If you can, use more than one comparison site because different sites compare different insurers. 

2. Changing variables

We’ve already touched on the factors that can impact the cost of your car insurance policy. If any of these have changed, then it’s possible that your insurer sees you as higher risk. So, if you’ve bought a more expensive car, made modifications to it or even moved house, your premium may increase.

While some variables are within your control, others aren’t. For example, you can’t control your age (elderly drivers may face higher premiums) or the crime rate in your neighbourhood. Both of these variables can have a big impact on your quote.

3. Wider changes in the market

External factors may also influence the price of car insurance, which can lead to increased premiums. For example, back in 2012, a European Court ruling prevented insurers from discriminating by gender. In the past, insurers typically charged men higher premiums as they were perceived as higher risk.

As a result of this change, women’s renewal premiums increased massively across the board, even for those who shopped around.

4. A ‘no claims bonus’ not being as valuable as you think

Insurers typically offer no claims discounts to reward careful drivers with years of accident-free driving under their belt. Some policies also offer to protect your no claims discount. This means it’s possible to keep on adding years to your discount, even if you do have an accident.

Because of this, insurers know that those with several years of ‘no claims’ may have made a recent claim on their policy. As a result, almost all insurers will now ask whether you made any claims in the past, as well as asking for the number of years associated with your no claims discount. 

So while having a big ‘no claims’ figure is certainly a positive, don’t think it will automatically mean you’ll get a cheaper quote. 

What’s being done to make insurance costs fair?

From 1 January 2022, insurers will be banned from offering cheaper quotes to new customers over existing policyholders. This is good news for those who don’t compare providers as it provides protection from the ‘loyalty penalty’. 

However, some consumer groups have expressed concern that the change will lead to higher insurance premiums across the board. This is due to a perception that insurers will try to claw back some of their profits previously made from unsuspecting loyal customers.

Whatever your views on the new policy, from 2022 onwards, it will still make sense to shop around for car insurance to ensure you get the cheapest quote.

For more cost-cutting tips, see our article offering three tricks to getting cheaper car insurance.


Some offers on MyWalletHero are from our partners — it’s how we make money and keep this site going. But does that impact our ratings? Nope. Our commitment is to you. If a product isn’t any good, our rating will reflect that, or we won’t list it at all. Also, while we aim to feature the best products available, we do not review every product on the market. Learn more here. The statements above are The Motley Fool’s alone and have not been provided or endorsed by bank advertisers. John Mackey, CEO of Whole Foods Market, an Amazon subsidiary, is a member of The Motley Fool’s board of directors. The Motley Fool UK has recommended Barclays, Hargreaves Lansdown, HSBC Holdings, Lloyds Banking Group, Mastercard, and Tesco.

Was this article helpful?
YesNo