Should you invest in a SIPP or an ISA?

Thinking of opening an ISA or SIPP but can’t decide which? See here how your money can grow in each of them.

The content of this article was relevant at the time of publishing. Circumstances change continuously and caution should therefore be exercised when relying upon any content contained within this article.

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More.

This is not pension planning advice, although I will be comparing a Self-Invested Personal Pension (SIPP) against an Individual Savings Account (ISA). I am assuming your financial security in retirement is secure, but that you have more to invest and are wondering if an ISA or SIPP is right for you.

Self-Invested Personal Pension

A huge benefit of making contributions to a SIPP is that the taxman tops them up by 20% directly, and if you are a higher rate taxpayer, you can claim an additional 20% through your self-assessment. The table below shows the effective costs to basic and higher rate taxpayers of various contributions, assuming claims are paid in full.

Contribution after top-up

Cost for a basic-rate taxpayer

Cost for a higher-rate taxpayer

£1,000

£800

£600

£2,000

£1,600

£1,200

£4,000

£3,200

£2,400

As you can see, you stand to gain an impressive return just by funding a SIPP, and your investment will grow free of capital gains or income tax.

The table below shows the value of varying investments in a SIPP made by a basic rate taxpayer, after receiving the top-up and growing at 5% per year, untaxed over time.

Initial contribution to a SIPP

5-years

10-years

20-years

£800

£1,277

£1,629

£2,653

£1,600

£2,553

£3,258

£5,307

£3,200

£5,105

£6,516

£10,613

With the top-up, and sheltered from tax, investments in a SIPP can grow impressively over time. The drawback is that you need to reach the age of 55 before you can take a 25% tax-free lump-sum and start withdrawing additional funds, which are treated as ordinary income. Any income over the current personal allowance of £12,500 gets taxed.

A SIPP account will also be considered alongside a workplace pension when working out annual contribution limits, which are 100% of your salary up to £40,000. There is also a lifetime allowance of £1,055,000 for pension contributions, which is expected to increase with inflation. If you breach these limits then additional taxes are due.

Individual Savings Account

You have a £20,000 annual contribution allowance that you can spread across any ISAs you hold. There are several types of ISAs, but cash (you receive a fixed or variable interest rate) and investment ISAs are the basic types. In the latter, you can hold stocks and shares, funds, and other investment vehicles.

If the ISA is flexible, you can remove and re-deposit funds so long as the total yearly inflow into the fund does not breach the annual allowance.

You do not get any tax relief on contributions, but once inside they can grow tax-free. The table below shows how different amounts grow at 5% per year over time in an ISA.

Initial contribution to an ISA

5-years

10-years

20-years

£800

£1,021

£1,303

£2,123

£1,600

£2,042

£2,606

£4,245

£3,200

£4,084

£5,212

£8,491

As you can see, the ISA underperforms the SIPP. However, there is no age requirement for withdrawals, and any withdrawals are completely free of tax. Cash or investment ISAs are truly tax-exempt, compared to SIPPs which defer taxes. 

SIPP or ISA?

If you are going to dip into your investment pot before the age of 55, then an ISA is a clear choice. If you are currently paying the higher rate of tax, the boost you get with the SIPP can’t be ignored, particularly if you are going to be paying the basic rate in retirement.

For most people, the choice is not as clear cut, but generally, an ISA provides more flexibility, while a SIPP saves more tax over time. But with either, always choose quality and diverse investments to hold inside them.

Should you invest, the value of your investment may rise or fall and your capital is at risk. Before investing, your individual circumstances should be assessed. Consider taking independent financial advice.

James J. McCombie has no position in any of the shares mentioned. The Motley Fool UK has no position in any of the shares mentioned. Views expressed on the companies mentioned in this article are those of the writer and therefore may differ from the official recommendations we make in our subscription services such as Share Advisor, Hidden Winners and Pro. Here at The Motley Fool we believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.

More on Investing Articles

Investing Articles

Should I still be cautious about Rolls-Royce shares?

Rolls-Royce shares are flying. But is now the time for this Fool to open a position? Here, he explains why…

Read more »

Group of young friends toasting each other with beers in a pub
Investing Articles

Is the Diageo share price coiled to rebound?

Christopher Ruane explains why he remains bullish about the long-term outlook for the Diageo share price and would happily invest…

Read more »

Young Asian woman holding a cup of takeaway coffee and folders containing paperwork, on her way into the office
Investing Articles

How I could make a 10% yield for high passive income a reality

Jon Smith explains how he can target high passive income from top-yielding stocks, including one specific example he'd consider.

Read more »

Investing Articles

I’d buy 1,784 shares of this FTSE 100 stock to target £350 of monthly passive income

Muhammad Cheema takes a look at how British American Tobacco shares, with a dividend yield of 10.1%, can generate a…

Read more »

White female supervisor working at an oil rig
Investing Articles

1 ex-FTSE 100 stock that I think will get promoted soon

Jon Smith flags up an energy stock that used to be in the FTSE 100 and currently has strong momentum…

Read more »

Shot of a young Black woman doing some paperwork in a modern office
Investing Articles

With an 8% dividend yield, I think this undervalued FTSE stock is a no-brainer buy

With an impressive yield and good track record of payments, Mark David Hartley is considering adding this promising FTSE share…

Read more »

Passive income text with pin graph chart on business table
Investing Articles

£9,500 in savings? Here’s how I’d try to turn that into £1,809 a month of passive income

Investing a relatively small amount into high-yielding stocks and reinvesting the dividends paid can generate significant passive income over time.

Read more »

Businesswoman analyses profitability of working company with digital virtual screen
Investing Articles

Dividend star Legal & General’s share price is still marked down, so should I buy more?

Legal & General’s share price looks very undervalued against its peers. But it pays an 8%+ dividend yield, and has…

Read more »