Skip Navigation
 

Egg Cancels 161k Credit Cards

Alison Hunt

By

Alison Hunt

From the Fool blog

The Right Financial Decision

Published in Credit Cards on 4 February 2008

With letters from Egg falling onto many of its customers doormats revoking their credit cards, we ask what can you do?

If you are one of Egg's 2.3m customers that received a letter from the bank recently, entitled "Your Egg Credit Card Has Been Cancelled", you may have been quite surprised.

High Risk Customers

The internet bank has sent out these letters to around 161k people (approx. 7% of its customers) whom it has deemed "high risk" and the decision means that in 35 days time, their credit cards will cease to work. While payments can still be made to the accounts, the credit cards of those affected will be useless.  

"So what?" you may be thinking. After all, we're constantly complaining that lenders dish out ridiculous credit limits to all and sundry, which has contributed to the ongoing "credit crunch" situation. A bank deciding that high risk customers (i.e. those that may have missed payments or exceeded their credit limits in the past) should have their credit withheld has to be a responsible one, right?

Good Credit Histories Affected Too

Well, things are never as clear cut as they seem and there's more to Egg's decision than meets the eye, as high risk individuals are not the only ones that have been targeted. As a number of our readers have explained, many of you with excellent credit histories have, somewhat bafflingly, received one of these letters, too.

So what on earth is going on?

Well, putting my cynical hat on for a moment, it's pretty clear. Although the current climate means banks are trying to offload high risk customers to reduce the potential number of bad debts they have responsibility for, they also, as always are looking at ways to boost profits. And Egg has clearly decided that as some customers with excellent credit histories who always pay off their credit card balance on time don't make them any money, what's the point of keeping them?

What's more, as our resident guru David Kuo has pointed out, the people most likely to have been targeted are aged between 35 and 49 and homeowners. Egg may well be hoping to push them away from unsecured lending such as credit cards, and persuade them to take out secured loans on their homes instead (which is deemed safer from a lender's point of view, but certainly not from a homeowner's).

Indeed, infuriating as this may be for many of Egg's responsible customers, it seems that this may be the tip of the iceberg with other banks watching the response and waiting to follow suit.

So what can you do?

Well, if you're unhappy with Egg's decision the best thing to do, as always is to vote with your feet. And that doesn't mean to head down the secured lending route - if you must borrow money and know you're responsible enough to handle the repayments, cheap personal loans and credit cards offer the best option without risking your home.

And while Egg may have launched its savings accounts with a flurry of excitement back in the nineties its rates are far from market-leading now, so it may be time to also move that cash to a better savings account. As we always say: don't stick with a provider out of misplaced loyalty - it won't be loyal to you!

But on the other hand if you are someone that has failed to keep up with their credit card payments in the past, or exceeded your credit limit, think long and hard about borrowing more, or having a credit card at all. Try and stick to using a debit card instead and keep your spending under control - and avoid getting into debt.

More: Find a better card in our Credit Card Centre | Eleven Cracking Credit Cards

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

scrambleegg 07 Feb 2008, 12:03pm

Take action now by registering your disgust here: http://scrambleegg.bigforumpro.com/

SliverBull3t 07 Feb 2008, 7:58pm

I am one of the ones that has had my card cancelled by Egg, to be honest it's the best thing thats happened. Although i've been good recently and been paying off my cards, seeing my "available debt(credit)" going up each month the temptation to use my cards has been building. But now this has happen it has refocused my resolve not to use my cards and save for what i want.

splodge101d 08 Feb 2008, 10:03am

i received my letter from egg this morning cancelling my card. Must admit i am angry about it. Only 4 times in 5 years have i gone over my limit and that was by pence not pounds. I always pay by direct debit and on time and pay extra off as well. Would never recommend them to anyone.

Zweiblumen 08 Feb 2008, 11:39am

From what I have been able to ascertain, the unprofitable customers being dumped are mostly older people who pay their balance off in full every month. This could set an awful precedent, reducing access to financial products to a potentially vulnerable group, namely those on a fixed income who live within their means. Losing a credit card that you pay off every month is inconvenient, but what about other products that are not profitable if used sensibly, like current accounts? It certainly takes customer profitability analysis one step too far, and it is a very worrying sign from Citigroup that they are prepared to endure this kind of bad publicity just to save a few quid. This is a dreadful shame: had they done what they claimed to be doing, namely reducing access to credit to its most indebted customers, I would have been the first to laud their efforts!

FinalFurlong 11 Feb 2008, 8:51am

I received my letter last week without realising that it had been sent to thousands of others too. My credit history with Egg has never been a problem; I pay by direct debit each month, don't settle my account monthly and have never gone over my limit. I don't seem to fit into any of the categories that would make me high risk - unless renting my home makes me so? If this is the case then I'm going to be high risk with all companies and therefore refused credit.

rex5939 11 Feb 2008, 4:19pm

Had my EGG card cancelled-good riddance! However just got a letter from Virgin telling me they are doubling my interest rate to 34.9% which I regard as robbery! Any ideas how to fight this?

tishtash 11 Feb 2008, 10:34pm

I let go of Egg a few years back but I've been hit by virgin cranking up my intrest rate too! I spoke to virgin and explained that the higher rate would make me unable to pay at all and they put it back to its original rate. Needless to say I'm being very Foolish now and getting rid of this cards and only making use of my other one which has a decent cash back facility!

sandiegillam 18 Sep 2008, 9:53am

I don't have any access to credit cards - just thousands of pounds of credit card debt that I have to payback! Credit card companies are the same as banks - they offer you an umbrella when it's sunny and take it back when it starts to rain. The only difference now is that they're taking the shelter back when the FORECAST is rain! Credit cards haven't helped me - the only thing I miss is the insurance that they offered on failed product purchases. And even that's being called into question. If you have good credit and can get a card that you pay in full each month, lucky you! Use it until they decide it's not worth providing you a service! Remember, they WON'T provide you a service if they can't earn from it - that's their sole purpose, so we can't really blame them!

Join the conversation

Instructions

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: <b>bold</b>, <i>quoted text</i>. All other tags will be removed from your post.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.