Skip Navigation
 

Darling Backs Icesave

My latest blog

Debt Is The Cause, And Also The Solution

Published in Your Money on 8 October 2008

Alistair Darling has just told the BBC that the government will fully compensate savers in Icesave.

The Chancellor, Alistair Darling, told the BBC at 8:30 this morning that the government will fully compensate savers in Icesave. He will give further details in a statement to the House of Commons at lunchtime.

Yesterday, many savers in Icesave were extremely concerned after the Icelandic owner of Icesave, Landsbanki, collapsed. It looked as though savers would have to claim compensation from an Icelandic scheme on any savings up to £16,100. Further compensation would come from the UK’s Financial Services Compensation Scheme.

Darling’s interview this morning has changed everything. The government will now compensate all savers in Icesave with no limit on the compensation. That’s great news. The Chancellor didn’t extend the guarantee to other banks, but we’ll be listening carefully at lunchtime for more on that.

The Chancellor also revealed that he had spoken to Iceland’s finance minister yesterday and been told that Iceland wouldn’t compensate UK savers in Iceland. Darling was clearly angered by this answer.

We’ll have more to say once Darling has made his statement to the House of Commons. We’ll also cover the bailout scheme for the UK banks.

> Compare savings via Fool.co.uk

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

hadron100 08 Oct 2008, 9:13am

The UK government should immediately seize all UK assets of Landisbanki.
This would be entirely justified in the light of Iceland's shameful reneging on their guarantee to savers. The Iceland PM has said it's each country for itself, so we should do the same.

gpmartin 08 Oct 2008, 9:13am

This is encouraging, but I won't feel certain until the money is 'in my hands' (so to speak - though perhaps that's the safest place for it at the moment!). I listened to the radio broadcast, and it seemed that AD was guaranteeing two things: firstly that money up to the first C.£16,000 would be covered by the British FSCS if the Icelandic equivalent / Icelandic government / cross-Nordic agreement didn't pay up; and secondly that money over £50,000 would also be covered. But he didn't quite make either of those guarantees explicit, and I'd like to see it made completely clear rather than assuming.

I've got less than £16k in an ISA and cash savings account, as has my wife, and I imagine that the majority of the 300,000 savers are in a similar position. So I'm crossing my fingers that at least the first guarantee applies - and I hope for those with more than £50k that the second part does, too.

gpmartin 08 Oct 2008, 9:17am

Incidentally the relevant excerpts from the interview are printed on the BBC website:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/7658417.stm

gpmartin 08 Oct 2008, 9:23am

And a couple more things (sorry for not keeping all this in one post): it would also be good to know if
(a) unpaid interest will be covered and
(b) it will be possible to retain tax-exempt status on ISA savings.
I guess the details are still being worked out, but hopefully the urge to 'restore confidence' means they'll be positive answers to these questions soon.

pinkfreddy 08 Oct 2008, 9:24am

Darling is my darling, if this turns out to be the case. Based on my experience with Icesave, I am now giving the following advice to my daughters: when saving your cash, NEVER put it in a fixed term account, and NEVER invest in a foreign bank.

As regards the Islandic government, I think they are very miffed that no-one except the Russians would give them a loan. We did not help them, so they don't feel like helping us.

MonsterMixer 08 Oct 2008, 9:32am

hadron,

Personally I was preparing to take a big sack down the highstreet and loot House of Fraser!

(joke)

MuppetKeeper 08 Oct 2008, 9:48am

My new investment advice, buy tins of food, make sure they have a long shelf life though..

MK

ThatLindseyGuy 08 Oct 2008, 9:51am

Very welcome news for a lot of people.

Must say I'm disappointed with most commentators in the media, including those on this site, repeating the empty promises of the Icelandic politicians ("First EUR 20,000 per depositor covered by our guarantee"). Especially given that so much as a brief look at the mathematics of the situation would have told you that money simply wasn't there to satisfy said promises!

elephant27 08 Oct 2008, 9:54am

I have just under £150,000 in savings with icesave. Yesterday was the most worrying day of my life thinking I had lost £100,000. I just hope and pray Mr. Darling is going to stick to his word. I have transferred all the money into my current account and it says on icesave it has been processed but I'm not sure I believe it, has anyone else experienced this?

Niblet82 08 Oct 2008, 9:59am

Compared to stories like Elephant27 I'm small fry in this game, but does anyone else feel like getting all of their money putting it on a box and guarding it?

It does not surprise me that the bank is protecting its Domestic interests first and I fear that the first £16,000 will be lost the rest up to £50,000 will be safe. The Times reported the bank has a large deficit if they cover the £16,000 as promised.

All we can do is sit tight. Boo!!

aninymis 08 Oct 2008, 10:09am

I withdrew almost all my money from Icesave on Sunday, and the transaction was marked as "processed" on Monday morning. But the money hasn't arrived in my current account today - and I see others have the same problem. It looks like Landsbanki was in trouble earlier than Tuesday.

Anyway I guess we all have to wait and see what happens. I'm one of the lucky ones and I took out half of my savings last month, which is now safely sitting (at a lower interest rate) in a UK building society...

Yukimaru 08 Oct 2008, 10:11am

Yay!

I don't really feel any major animosity towards Iceland. If they haven't got the cash, they haven't got it, right? Am I being too simplistic?

Got to wonder why people would put more than £50k in the account though when they know it's not guaranteed. Did they know it wasn't guaranteed and thought they'd risk it or did they just not know?

IanAbroad 08 Oct 2008, 10:12am

Hello (ThatLindseyGuy), yeterday I posted to say my CHAPS out of Icesave went through. Last night, I got through to Icesave to find out that the transfer had been stopped and would be returned back to my account.
I felt sick as this puts me back way above compensation limits. I am in for £135k.
So now, my money shows as gone from account, and it looks like the statements won't be updated, so I do not know what will happen. Realistically, I am sure it is not lost, and I am only losing interest. I can afford that, I can't afford to lose the capital.
If Darling walks the talk, then he is my, and a lot of peoples saviour.
I hope all deposits are honourned.
Banks and deposits are supposed to be the 'safe'.
We are not in the Third World here, this is the EU.

anubis1275 08 Oct 2008, 10:17am

Hello, does anyone know just how the process of claiming our money back is going to work, what forms we have to fill in and to whom do we contact? Thank you.

ThatLindseyGuy 08 Oct 2008, 10:23am

IanAbroad>> Oh dear. Really sorry to hear that. Hope the chancellor comes through for you!

At the same time, that's very disturbing news. CHAPS is what is know as a real-time gross settlement (RTGS) system. That means that money is exchanged between banks immediately at the time of transfer rather than being netted off between at the end of each day like BACS and cheque clearing is

So if your CHAPS payment bounced it means there were no funds actually in Icesave to cover the payment

So the obvious question is, if the money wasn't in Icesave at the time of transfer, where was it???

Yukimaru 08 Oct 2008, 10:32am

Anubis, there's a site that's said something about the FSCS will send us all a form. Will take about 3 months.

wilwak 08 Oct 2008, 10:34am

Can not the UK government not just seize Icesave.co.uk and nationalise it? They would initially have to fund it just as if the FSCS had paid out but not only would they be left with a very saleable internet savings bank but also all those savers with Icesave Fixed Rate Bonds would not have to be immediately paid out their savings - they could be left to run their term thus reducing the cash demands on the government. Icesave could possibly become the internet bank of Northern Rock much the same as Abbey has Cahoot, Co-op has Smile, HBOS has IF and HSBC has First Direct. At least that way savers would not have to make claims and the government would end up with an asset for it's compensation.

wilwak 08 Oct 2008, 10:39am

To those people asking why anyone would have more than £50k with Icesave. Well, I think many folk would be in the same situation as me - I took out 3 year fixed rate bonds well over 12 months ago when things looked a lot better than they do today. On the face of it Landsbanki was the biggest bank in Iceland, making good profits and had been around since 1885. They looked a safe home and all the papers and press were recommending them.

anubis1275 08 Oct 2008, 10:41am

Hello again,

In my investments with Icesave I had £3600 in their ISA that I opened in August. If this is now closed will I be able to open another ISA account or will it stand against me for this tax year? I have just read on the FSCS web site that they are gearing up ready to help UK savers "If the default is triggered as expected, FSCS will contact all UK savers directly with details of how to apply for compensation". Thank you.

ThatLindseyGuy 08 Oct 2008, 10:41am

WilWak>> In theory yes but as I suggested in my earlier post, I'm pretty sure the UK Icesave operation had no cash at all in it as of yesterday; hence the bounced CHAPS payments.

All that the government would have been taking over would have been a stack of liabilities (i.e. depositors savings).

With today's proposed action, this is effectively what has been done.

IanAbroad 08 Oct 2008, 10:44am

Icesave said that as the bank stopped transacting on 7th, and transfers were stopped, not bounced as such. I think the clearing banks are sitting on a tidy sum at the moment.
I don't care where it is actually, as long as it finds it's way home to me!
Nothing now surprises me, until the next surprise.
It's a hope and pray game now for all those above the £50k.

Yukimaru 08 Oct 2008, 10:54am

"Can not the UK government not just seize Icesave.co.uk and nationalise it?"

It's not ours to nationalise. Don't think we can just grab some other country's stuff.

There was talk yesterday of maybe selling the arm off, so a UK bank may buy it.

aninymis 08 Oct 2008, 10:55am

IanAbroad: Thanks for posting this.

So it seems money withdrawn on Monday is sitting in the clearing system at the moment. Does anyone know why this should be? Presumably Landsbanki had the money to fulfil these transactions on Monday, or they wouldn't have entered the system at all? Are they frozen as part of the British government's freeze on UK Landsbanki assets (now reported by the BBC)?

Can someone familiar with the BACS system comment on what might be happening?

MuppetKeeper 08 Oct 2008, 10:56am

Sorry to hear about those with huge amounts of cash in the game. No EU bank has gone down in my memory, so these "limits" were just theoretical until recently. I've only recently had enough money to worry about such things, but still have £30k with Icesave and £10k with Kaupthing. Whilst I'm pleased all of that will be coming back, I use the Kaupthing money to live on, so am having to bail out of the bank just in case.
Buy shares in the makers of safes... there is going to be a surge in demand!

petervt 08 Oct 2008, 10:57am

Till yesterday savings were protected up to £35.000 per savings provider so why didnt these savers think about spreading their savings amongst several institutions or did the wish to maximise their return affect their judgement

MonsterMixer 08 Oct 2008, 10:58am

Coming through newswires that Ing have bought the Netherlands Icesave operations, and Kaupthing operations.

Still think it's plausible that someone might buy UK savings accounts - have to wait and see. Bet UK govt are praying!

howcoh 08 Oct 2008, 11:02am

A 'passport'compensation scheme should never have been approved with a country so small and in such a dire financial situation as Iceland. It is now obvious that the Icelandic Government could never have compensated savers fully-whatever the situation had been.

Darling has probably secured more voters by this one statement than anything else this Government has ever said!

welovedarling 08 Oct 2008, 11:05am

There seems to be a problem with CHAPS. I asked KAUPTHING EDGE to do a CHAPS transfer on Monday to get my money down to within 50K.

They had so many in the backlog that KAUPTHING didnt process it until Tuesday. But the money didnt hit my account same day or even this morning. Ringing them just now I was told that yesterdays troubles meant that the clearing centre was swamped and my CHAPS order didn't go through.

I like others have had a dreadful last couple of days. I'm relieved that Darling has said that all ICESAVE customers are protected. Fantastic news! I am also delighted that ING DIRECT have now taken over KAUPTHING EDGE savings. Makes me a lot less worried as I wait here for my money to appear out of a black hole and into my account via CHAPS.

All this goes to show how much the banking system needs an OVERHAUL. Why do customers always lose out and never the Banks? My money was taken out of my account on Monday and has yet to appear in the destination account.

I have also asked KAUPTHING to liquidate savings in 3 fixed interest accounts. This has still not been done more than 48 hours later - as they are so busy.

Regulators (phoned them tis morning) need better sticks (they write to the bank and give them 6 weeks for a response!).

ANyone else in the same boat?

LaCatedra 08 Oct 2008, 11:17am

Way to go Alistair Darling. At last someone has the guts to say you can't take investors money and then walk away. I had more than £50k in a 1year bond and so was unable to repatriate my cash despite repeated efforts. It was like being mugged in slow motion and I was the mug........

We should all voice our support for the positive action the chancellor is taking. Landsbanki were a supposedly finacially strong company with huge international assets and liquid reserves backed by the Iceland government. I hope Darling seizes Landsbanki's and Icelands assets today and makes them feel the pain that we all feel today.

Darling for Prime Minister................

Yukimaru 08 Oct 2008, 11:25am

This is no more likely to make me vote Labour than free school dinners. Brits in trouble? Government helps Brits. That's the way it should be, really. I appreciate their gesture but it doesn't change anything else.

birdybird 08 Oct 2008, 11:32am

On the BBC news this morning Darling guaranteed that he would ensure that all ICESAVE customers would recover 100% of their money. He said he would confirm this during the Commons debate at lunch time.

@welovedarling
Did Kaupthing Edge charge you the £20 for a CHAPS transfer? They'd have a nerve to do so seeing as your money has not reached your account within the promised time. Did they say when the transfer would be complete? I transferred £20K yesterday via BACS from my KE account so goodness knows when I'll see that in my link account. I still have £10K with KE and not sure if I should transfer that as well.

Will all KE customers now become ING Direct customers?

Stacpoole 08 Oct 2008, 11:41am

Let's invade Iceland and sort that lying Prime Minister..

pmweneedyou 08 Oct 2008, 11:41am

I have not slept in days, have saving above 50k. GO Gordan go, sue Iceland, for robbing our hard earned savings. My account shows 0 wondering where my bacs payment is.

Stacpoole 08 Oct 2008, 11:42am

If they go on like this I might have to vote Labour for the first time...

telfor1 08 Oct 2008, 11:44am

I am concerned that Darling who I have no faith in, has said all uk savers money in icesave will be returned. If he can guarantee savers money in a foreign bank why can't he guarantee all of savers money in a uk bank.
TJ

Offal 08 Oct 2008, 11:45am

It's been a tough 48 hours...

I realised on Sunday that the Icelandic scheme only mandated a minimum total deposit of (about) £500,000, when converted from the plummeting Icelandic Krona. That's less than £2 each! I guessed that the Icelanders would default on their "guarantee" (I've read a lot of their Sagas, so should have twigged much earlier!). Thank goodness enough people had money in IceSave for the Government to sit up and take notice.

I did move £500 out on Monday (Sunday instruction), closing that particular account. I didn't use CHAPS for such an amount, but the money hasn't shown up on the third day in my bank. I'm hoping it will be there by tomorrow, since the account is already being treated as closed, i.e. I can no longer see it within IceSave. Presumably the sheer volume of similar transactions has clogged the system up.

Does anyone know if there is a compensation procedure for such "leaky" transactions, if the money doesn't eventually surface?

MisterGrumble 08 Oct 2008, 12:16pm

Why is the Fool still advertising the KauptingEdge account? since this bank is clearly the next one to the wall? Isn't it a bit irresponsible?

welovedarling 08 Oct 2008, 12:28pm

Yes I paid £20 CHAPS transfer fee and yes still no money. KAUPTHING say its extraordinary circumstances and that I'll just have to wait. I transferred 200K so someone else has had this in their account not me.

That's not the point though seems that we take the risks and carry the can if we do something wrong but the regulator is weak.

If CHAPS cannot cope the regulator should make them work through the night until they finish their workload.

I'm a pharmacist - if there was an emergency I'd stay until the job was done. Bankers work until 5pm then that's it. How much does the regulator get paid and where was he last night when CHAPS was breaking down?

Aidan1927 08 Oct 2008, 12:28pm

I am no fan of Brown and Darling but I have to say they have gone up in my estimation by taking this action so promptly. As for the Icelandic gov, an absolute disgrace. I stood to lose £13,000 so am mightly relieved. Thankfully most of my saving are in a thoroughly reliable old British institution the Bradford and Bingley.

nickwall 08 Oct 2008, 12:33pm

My Mum has 180k in an Icesave fixed term account. This matured TODAY. You cannot imagine the frustration yesterday at being within hours of having the money but no way of getting to it.

Until 9am this morning I thought most of it had gone (held out no hope of Iceland paying their part, which was proven correct), and now I just hope the govt comes through on it's pledge. I have been an extremely vocal critic of most things this govt stands for, but Alistair Darling has done something that will be remembered for a long time by a lot of people. Well done to him, and thank you.

cotula6 08 Oct 2008, 12:40pm

Little bit more information on BBC website, at:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/7658417.stm

Yukimaru 08 Oct 2008, 12:51pm

"The Treasury said that arrangements were being put in place to ensure that all ISA customers of Icesave would continue to benefit from the tax-free status of their accounts."

Brilliant news!

bibbia 08 Oct 2008, 12:58pm

Does anybody know how we might go about seeking compensation?
I currently hold some £37000 in ice bank. (£31000 of this in a 2yr fixed term bond, expiring in oct 09 and the remainder in an 'easy access' account.)

I have attempted to contact the FSCS, Icebank & Landbanski direct but have received no answer.

limpanliten 08 Oct 2008, 1:01pm

Just watched the live speech of Alistair Darling at the House of Commons.

All UK Deposit Holders of ICESAVE money will have their money back.

Seen it, heard it - so no return back now.

Morrisdriver 08 Oct 2008, 1:24pm

Just heard that Kaupthing has gone under but that UK government will bail out their savers too.

MrRee007 08 Oct 2008, 1:40pm

I will not be happy until the money is actually back in my UK Bank Account, despite what the Government says ... talk is cheap, as we have seen by the Icelandic PrimeMinisters words stating that we are all safe!

Those notices on the Icesave website stating that all funds were safe were simply lies! Luckily I took those re-assuring words as my trigger to empty my accounts (just leaving the ISA).

I have a feeling that those up to £16,000 will be cut adrift. The £16,000 - £50,000 will be paid in full. Those over £50,000 will be offered a portion of their money back. But this is just my suspicious mind working. It depends on what happens from now on - if there is a big UK Bank go down and further bad news then we Icesave customers will get forgotten very quickly!

But, if Darling comes good I may well vote Labour next time!

Yukimaru 08 Oct 2008, 1:44pm

MrRee007:- "I have a feeling that those up to £16,000 will be cut adrift."

Why would there have been numerous announcements from the government, Treasury and chancellor to the contrary? There'd be quite the risk in simply going "Oh, no, not doing it now."

MrRee007 08 Oct 2008, 1:50pm

The devil is in the detail ..... that's all I will say.

pmweneedyou 08 Oct 2008, 1:57pm

Please mr darling keep your word, my money turned up this aftrnoon in my icesave account. Really annoyed as was assured by icesave yesterday that it had left my account.

\can they stop money in transit or was it in transit.

If and when I get my money back staight to national savings me don't care if they give 1% interest.

Does anyone know when are we going to see our money???

welovedarling 08 Oct 2008, 2:02pm

Update to earlier posts. Just listened to Darling in the Commons. Kaupthing has now too gone bust. Looks like I've been told a load of b*llocks!

Now I'm sure that the real reason why my CHAPS payment didn't go through was because they have now money. How can they do this?

Is anyone else out there also waiting on money being transferred from

aninymis 08 Oct 2008, 2:04pm

Yes, my money (withdrawn on Sunday and supposedly processed on Monday) has now appeared back in my Icesave account as a "correction". Oh well, I guess at least I know where it is.

FYI, there is an official statement from the treasury about Landsbanki here:

http://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/press_101_08.htm

It seems clear and unequivocal that savers' money will be returned.

Niblet82 08 Oct 2008, 2:08pm

"The Chancellor has also spoken to the Icelandic Finance Minister about the importance of the Icelandic authorities ensuring that UK depositors in Icesave are given the same protections as depositors in Iceland and receive their deposits back in full promptly."
"The Chancellor has also today taken steps to freeze assets of Landsbanki in the UK until the position with respect to the future of the firm and UK creditors becomes clearer."

Its a waiting game now....

Morrisdriver 08 Oct 2008, 2:17pm

I suspect that many people, as I do, have a sum (£20k) in an Icesave fixed term account. Mine is/was to mature in Jan 2009.

I don't need the capital at present but would prefer to have capital and accrued interest paid as per original deal on due date.

Does anyone know whether the UK government intend to compensate us:

(a) for invested capital sum only,
(b) for capital plus interest due at some time when it suits them to pay out or
(c) capital plus full interest payable at maturity?

Or even give us a choice...

zanna38 08 Oct 2008, 2:18pm

I have just over £5ooo in an instant icesave account, and somewhere in the system is my £1000 i transferred on Sunday. I used the BACS system and it has been processed according to my Icesave account but so far nothing in my bank account ! I actually got hold of someone yesterday at Icesave help and they confirmed that as all withdrawals have been cancelled if it wasn't showing up yesterday then it will be returned to my icesave account, but I seem to be having trouble signing in to my Icesave account to check is anyone else having this problem?

I am hopeful we will get this back, and we are lucky that the amount we have is much smaller than other people had in there. I think a lot of the media encouraged us in to Icesave as it was always in the top list for savers, huh I deliberately didn't go with an alternative indian online bank as I thought the one in Iceland seemed safer, looks are very deceptive........

bobfruit 08 Oct 2008, 2:27pm

Someone please correct me - the money that 'wonderful' Darling is using to pay those with deposits above the guaranteed limits is our collective money as taxpayers, right?

That being the case, I don't want to hear a peep next year from those being 'saved' today when income or council taxes rise to foot the bill for this.

The money has to come from somewhere and has to be paid by someone, so everyone pays eventually?

tux222 08 Oct 2008, 2:30pm

A Labour government is never going to utterly shaft the many savers with up to £16,000 (their core voters?) while bailing out the relatively few with lots more (probable Tories?). And in any case, if that's what they were determined to do, the chancellor would simply have kept his mouth shut. The existing rules would then have operated unchanged, and the small savers would have lost 100% while £50K savers lost only about 40%.

I think everyone with up to £50,000 can breathe more easily now. Whether those with more than this will lose the excess, and whether we'll get paid interest owed as well as capital, remains to be seen. If I get all my capital back, I will be fairly happy to write off the interest.

I suspect that most of us were unaware until too late, that the (original unmodified) UK guarantee was merely a top-up, not also a guarantee of the Icelandic guarantee. Had I realised this, I'd not have saved a penny with Icesave, even 11 months ago when this seemed a very remote possibility. I wonder if even the authorities realized the implications?

Darling is now my darling. Interesting times, indeed.

ar2507 08 Oct 2008, 2:39pm

Like others I am anxiously awaiting my funds from KE to reach my linked bank account - paid the £20 for CHAPS yesterday morning and my bank assures me it should have been received yesterday .....but nothing as yet - no reply to email to KE, phones constantly busy .....small amount from IceSave also in a big black hole somewhere but hopeful that it will reappear in the IceSave account in the fullness of time to be claimed back as described by AD. Please let it happen...!!

stevemanc 08 Oct 2008, 2:43pm

I withdrew funds from Icesave on Monday via the usual BACS transfer and was told that the transfer was successful. On returning today (you can still get in to view your accounts) I saw that the account status showed ’funds returned“ so my transfer has been cancelled and the funds returned to my now closed account. Someone commented earlier about feeling mugged?

Tenuse 08 Oct 2008, 3:00pm

I see that a lot of people have been trying to get money out. I'm in the opposite situation - transferred a sum of money into Icesave on the 3rd October. It's showing in my processed, but not my clear balance. Anybody any clue as to whether this is now stuck there, or if it will be bounced back to the bank it came from??

CunningCliff 08 Oct 2008, 3:03pm

NEWS JUST IN:

My father tells me that his regiment is parachuting into Reykjavik under cover of darkness tonight. Don't worry, dear Fools -- we'll get your money back for you!

Cliff ;0)