Skip Navigation
 

Property Prices Plunge Again

My latest blog

Sky and Virgin Kiss & Make Up

Published in Property and Home on 11 March 2008

House prices have fallen for the seventh consecutive month. But here at the Fool we go behind the headlines to see what the latest housing reports really suggest will happen to prices in the future.

Property pessimists predicting a dramatic fall in the housing market were fed further evidence today that the recent turbulent weather isn't just blowing up our brollies.

According to the latest report by the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS), house prices dropped for the seventh month in a row, with 64.1% more surveyors reporting a fall rather than a rise in prices in February.

This has led to more than half a year of house price downturn, with the report teetering close to its historical low of June 1990 when 64.5% more surveyors reported a fall, rather than a rise in prices.

Stocks of unsold property jumped by more than 8.5%, the fifth consecutive monthly increase of more than 8%. The level of unsold homes has now risen by 48.6% over the past 12 months, which is the steepest rise in unsold property since 1989.

The Property Waiting Game

RICS attributes the falls to weak demand, as opposed to panic by sellers wanting to get property off their hands. In February, 37% more surveyors reported a fall than a rise in new buyer enquiries, down from 35% in January.

This data is backed by figures released by the Council of Mortgage Lenders (CML) today which reported a continuing decline in the number of approved mortgages for house purchases. Just 50,300 mortgages were approved in January, as opposed to 62,000 in December.

It seems many potential buyers are now playing the waiting game, put off by the fact that they could be buying a house today that could be worth less tomorrow.

Also, as lenders tighten their belts and cut down on the amount of money they are willing to lend potential homeowners, fewer first time buyers are able to raise the money to get on the ladder.

What The Papers Didn't Say...

However, like me, you may think that reports about the current housing market are choosing sensationalism over substance. I say: it's time to look at all the facts.

True, figures do not lie, and a clear downturn in the housing market has already become evident. But at the same time positive news regarding the housing market is becoming almost like fine print at the bottom of a contract that no one bothers to read.

So, here's what many of the papers failed to mention:

While it may be doom and gloom across England and Wales, if you live in Scotland, you shouldn't get the violins out just yet.

According to RICS, the number of surveyors reporting price rises surged from 7% to 25% this month - an indication that Scotland is the most buoyant market in the UK at the moment.

In addition, sales expectations turned positive for the first time since last June and price expectations improved slightly for the second consecutive month. So although there is a weaker demand for housing at the moment, surveyors are more optimistic about the outlook for the housing market than in recent months, and believe that the pace of price falls will slow down.

It is also worth highlighting that homeowners are adapting to the current economic climate, as they look to get the best value out of their current property.

According to the CML, despite the decline of home loans, there was a rise in remortgaging activity, with 85,000 remortgages in January, up 43% from 59,000 in December.

In addition, more of us are opting for trackers when remortgaging, a sign that more and more of us are expecting further reductions in the Bank of England base rate in 2008. Fixed rate loans represented 57% of loans in January, down from 77% compared to June 2007.

Bargain Basement Property?

If you're really savvy, you may also be able to pick up a bargain if you know where to look and can drive a hard bargain.

RICS argues that, while it is unlikely that there will be significant price drops in the short term, the build up of unsold stocks will encourage buyers to negotiate lower asking prices.

So, we come to the end of our latest chapter in the housing market. RICS says not to panic, while the papers continue to report otherwise. Will it all balance out in the end? Who knows.

In the meantime, the saga continues...

More: How Much Will Your Mortgage Cost? / The Buy-To-Let Boom Isn't Over Yet

> Get a Great Mortgage With The Motley Fool

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

acceptedplanet 11 Mar 2008, 9:20pm

About time too, people have got to gready in this country...

trustjmh 11 Mar 2008, 9:54pm

I look forward to a day when prices are set by competition of home-owners (first time buyers) instead of the current prices set by buy-to-let. That only care about rent covering the interest payment and profiting from a small amount more, (less than any home-owner would have to make in capital repayments.)

yocoxy 12 Mar 2008, 8:15am

I guess there's a sub editor writing the headlines? This headline doesn't seem to reflect a reasonably balanced article..

"House prices plunge again" translates to: Two thirds of surveyors saw a fall, one third saw a rise last month..

Yes the market is slowing and prices are drifting off their peaks (and there may be a major fall to come (although I don't think so)) but since the article is focused on a slow down in sales rather than a fall in prices, "plunge again" is just the kind of sensationalist journalism that the article warns against.

Does Cliff D'Arcy write all the headlines for property articles even when he doesn't write the article?

dan121212 12 Mar 2008, 8:55am

agree with yocoxy. MF is part of the unobjective media that the article discusses. very strange that they ignore e.g. land registry stats; rental data; any attempt to tell us where in the country are the third of prices that are rising.

StevenDW 12 Mar 2008, 8:56am

You say 'However, like me, you may think that reports about the current housing market are choosing sensationalism over substance.' and title the article Property Prices Plunge Again' Pot, Kettle, dark colour?

cheerful37 12 Mar 2008, 9:01am

I must confess that when I read the comment by yocoxy about the transition from screaming headline to (relatively) innocuous content, my reaction was that yocoxy expressed exactly my own thoughts.
I'd welcome actual figures of actual transactions rather than the straws in the wind that form the basis of so much current research, interesting though that may be. cheerful37

Jbat001 12 Mar 2008, 9:19am

Yawn. Prices rising in Scotland lagged behind England on the way up, and will no doubt lag on the way down as well.

Fundamentals show we've had a decade of above-mean house price inflation, to the point where we now need prices to fall about 35% to revert to the mean. Prices will fall, and fall and fall and fall, just the same way that they rose irrationally too.

And for those who bleat that we're a small nation and there's a shortage of rental property, answer me this - if there genuinely was a shortage of housing (as opposed to a speculative price bubble), then why haven't rents shot up at the same rate as house price inflation?

Look at the 100-year chart for house prices - it is entirely reasonable and probable that houses will be circa 35-40% cheaper by the time of the 2012 Olympics.

TMFSUZY 12 Mar 2008, 10:02am

Hello chaps and chapettes,

Just you let you guys know, the headline was my own. It wasn't written by Cliff (believe it or not :-)), or a sub, it was entirely my own creation.

In my defence, I did include a wonderfully witty (??) sentence explaining it, but unfortunately it got pruned in editing...nooooooo! In hindsight, the headline should have been 'Property Prices Plunge Again...Or Do They? or something along those lines. But alas, what is done is done. C'est la vie!

Best,

Szu

milton43 12 Mar 2008, 10:06am

any one want to buy a house

figurewizard 12 Mar 2008, 10:30am

It is a fact that UK personal debt at £1.35 trillion at the start of 2008 represents 101% of GDP. It is also a fact that the affordability ratio as to average price divided by average earnings is at 9-1; double the historical average. When you're staring figures like that in the face, 'stability' is not the right word to describe the market.

As for remortgages being 43% up on the previous year, this is hardly surprising when one considers that there was a huge glut of fixed rate deals taken out in 2006, largely inspired by the idiots at Northern Rock. Consequently most people are not remortgaging these days because they choose to - It's a case of having to.

Djaz 12 Mar 2008, 10:49am

"And for those who bleat that we're a small nation and there's a shortage of rental property... ...if there genuinely was a shortage of housing..."

Read 'Who Owns Britain' by Cahill - there's actual no shortage of land in this country whatsoever, it's owned by landed gentry who won't give it up, that's all.

And as for whether we're in a bubble - read 'A Short History Of Financial Euphoria' by Galbraith. When judging whether something is a bubble, don't look at the actual price of the product, look at the common theme in the behaviour of the people.

The facets of behaviour always the same - South Sea Bubble, Tulip Mania, Junk Bonds, Dot Coms etc. etc. The beginning of the end occurs once the product is on the media front pages with comments such as 'Are We In A Bubble?' Whilst it's impossible to call the exact top of the market with foresight, that's about as close as it gets. And that's exactly where we are. It should really have happened some years ago, but the Bank of England has kept rates low in some form of pain avoidance/denial.

Mark Twain was right, history doesn't repeat itself but it does rhyme.

I don't mind particularly who owns the land or whether there's a bubble, just wish people would speak the cold facts.

But then all publishers would be out of business, wouldn't they? :-)

Hardtruth 12 Mar 2008, 11:28am

All down to perspective. Is the glass two-thirds empty or one third full?

whitehartlad 12 Mar 2008, 11:36am

Total sensationalist headline from Motley Fool once again!
The article goes on to describe how the media fails to report the positive side of the property market and yet the SArticle headline itself is 'Plunges again'.
Total nonsense. The market is leveling off and there is absolutely no sign of a crash other than mild falling house prices in some areas. In my own area,Cambridgeshire, prices increased slightly in some parts and stay static in others. If your going to report properly,then for gods sake give a balanced view!

jillh10 12 Mar 2008, 1:14pm

My partenr and I have been looking at properties in the Monmouthshire, Gloucestershire and Chepstow area and to our suprise there are no decent properties for under £300,000, these places are not even what you might call semi rural. It seems crazy that we cannot find anywhere that we like for a quater of a million pounds.
I know we have been looking primarily at Bungalows but we also noticed that house prices are not far off that mark either.

Grumpyoldadmin 12 Mar 2008, 2:44pm

> I did include a wonderfully witty (??) sentence explaining it, but unfortunately it got pruned in editing.

Was it unrepeatable? Could you drop us a hint as to what the "wonderful witty sentence" was?


...and then, instead of you, we can whinge about the editor! ;-)

freshfaced 12 Mar 2008, 2:51pm

My boyfriend and I have being looking to buy as first time buyers for the last 6 months and we have decided to rent. It is the best option for us at the moment and think it would be crazy for us to buy at the moment. The prices have definitely dropped but for a crash to happen? Who knows? Know one really knows what is going to happen. I think also people need to look at what's going on globally.

Zweiblumen 12 Mar 2008, 3:11pm

My maths is usually pretty good, and if so yocoxy can't add up - if 2/3 say "fall" and 1/3 say "rise", 67-33=34, not 64. To get a difference of 64%, 82% of surveyors are seeing falls and only 18% seeing rises.

Actually, I've just looked at the report itself, and the way they phrase it is quite confusing. In fact only 4% of surveyors in England and Wales report a rise in prices, while 40% report no change. Of course, the surveyors reporting "no change" may well be the same ones reporting rising stocks... When looking for the silver lining, don't fall for a mirage!

CunningCliff 12 Mar 2008, 3:43pm

yocoxy,

Your maths is faulty. You said,

"House prices plunge again" translates to: Two thirds of surveyors saw a fall, one third saw a rise last month.."

Wrong, wrong, wrong! The balance was 64.1%, which means roughly 18% reported falls and 82% reported rises.

Go to the back of the class! ;0)

Cliff

KRGS 13 Mar 2008, 1:55am

Don't shoot the messenger! Suzy should be praised
for reporting the facts that potential first-time
buyers need to know. If history repeats itself,we
can expect UK house prices to fall further over the next year or so. You only have to look across
the pond to see what's going on in the USA,with
the sub-prime mortgage crisis causing many to hand in their keys to the lender, because their home's value has fallen below what's owed
on the mortgage. Let's hope it doesn't get that
bad here. But first-time buyers should await their opportunity to get a toe-hold on the property ladder. Good Luck!

duta 13 Mar 2008, 12:21pm

I believe the media have been key to the house price boom. Endlessly talking up price rises, with a certain kind of accent in the reports that price rises are always positive and a sign of prosperity and increasing wealth. (Of course thats all nonesense. Higher house pices do not increase wealth, it simply transfers wealth to those people who own property and away from those who have to borrow to buy at those inflated prices). On top of that you have endless shows on how to make a fast buck from buying and selling, renovating.....
Well now I suspect and hope that the media will now be equally influential in halting the rise in property prices. Self fulfilling forecasts of gloom, reports of impending US recession and house price falls there should do the trick. They talked it up and I am sure they can talk it down,

If it happens then I for one will be happy.I do not want to live in a have and have not divided nation where the younger generation have mortgaged away their futures to feather the nests of older house owners.

And on top of all that there is the stark reality that many young people cannot buy. Can the market sustain itself when the first rung on the ladder is out of reach to more and more people? I dont think so.

And I am not a bleating homeless youngster. I own my own home and the mortgage is paid, but theres got to be more to life than killing yourself to put a roof over your head. I think sooner rather than later somethings got to give. And on BBC World right now....homeless repo families in calafornia living in trailers...Here we go...

nicolabirchley 27 Sep 2008, 7:55am

My family and I have just returned from overseas and need to buy a house. Only to be plunged into this turmoil. We had an offer of 250,000 accepted on a house marketed at 280,000. It needs some work too. That was in July and since then the property has gone to probate as the vendor died.

Should we now try to re-negotiate the price or exit and rent (not what we want to do as we have small children in need of a family home). PLEASE ADVISE ME!!

Join the conversation

Instructions

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: <b>bold</b>, <i>quoted text</i>. All other tags will be removed from your post.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.