How To Be The Ultimate Contrarian

Published in Investing Strategy on 15 December 2009

You can make a fortune by buying stuff no else wants to touch.

When I started writing about investments years ago I was briefly baffled about the term contrarian.

I can't understand why, because it is a very simple concept: you make money by investing in stuff most people won't touch.
If you make the right call, you can pick up high-value stocks at low-fashion prices, and cash in when they come back into vogue.

The theory is so simple, and effective if done correctly, that it has been rewarded with its own –ism: contrarianism.

The opposite of contrarianism is buying popular stocks on the assumption that if everybody else is buying them, they must be good. If that investment philosophy had been rewarded with an –ism, it would be called sheepism.

On the contrary

Naturally, contrarianism doesn't always work. Sometimes there is a very good reason why other people won't touch that rock bottom stock. Cheap doesn't always mean good value.

You also have to do your research, trust your instincts, and be prepared to defy the herd. Humans are social animals, so that isn't as easy as some people pretend.

Most investors aren't contrarian and quite right too, because if the majority were contrarians, they would no longer be contrarians.

So what should an uber-contrarian should be doing right now? Here are some of the more obvious areas, please feel free to add a few of your own.

Sell Gold

The gold price has gone berserk. It recently hit a high of $1,200 a troy ounce and some claim it could hit $2,000 or even $3,500. You can't walk along the average high street without tripping over signs offering to buy your gold at record prices. 

Yet the global economy is beginning a tentative recovery and that could quickly reverse the trend. Gold has little practical or industrial use except as a store of value, and its price can be shockingly volatile. Just a few years ago, it cost $250 an ounce. Everybody wants to buy gold these days, which makes it a contrarian's dream sell.

Buy pounds

Sterling has collapsed around 30% since the credit crunch. In January, legendary investor Jim Rogers said the pound was finished, and you should sell any sterling you have because it's rubbish. The Bank of England has since made things worse by printing another £200 billion of our junk money. 

Chancellor Alistair Darling's Pre Budget Report spooked the bond and currency markets, sending the pound lower against the dollar and yen. The only reason it didn't fall any further against the euro is that it can't. Europeans come to London to smile at our low property prices. Given all the bad news, the only sensible contrarian response is to buy. You might also take a punt on dollars, for similar reasons.

Go long on Dubai

Actually, the time to go contrarian on Dubai was last week, before Abu Dhabi stepped in with a £6 billion bailout. Panic in the Gulf didn't just lead to a stock sell off in Dubai, but also in Abu Dhabi, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia and Qatar, even though they have gas and oil reserves. 

Contrarians sometimes have to be quick on their toes, but any nimble-footed investor who bought at last week's close will now have enjoyed a 10% stock market rebound in a single day.

Sell China

China has so much money, it literally doesn't know what to do with it. While the UK heads for a 12% budget overspend, the Chinese government has underspent by 25% in 2009, and officials are desperately trying to find projects to put their money into. It's like an Oriental superpower version of Brewster's Millions. 

China has been growing at 9% a year since, um, forever. By 2040, it will be the world's economic superpower, and will be able to buy the entire UK with a bit of spare change it picks up on the street in Shanghai. China is the future. 

The contrarian mind should be flashing lurid "sell" signals at this point, although one of the most famous contrarians believes China is a trend to follow rather than defy: Anthony Bolton.

Buy RBS

Every investor will have considered going contrarian on the banks in recent times, with mixed results. 

I've had three bites at buying Barclays (LSE: BARC) at the bottom of the market, and each time it dropped much lower. I went contrarian on Royal Bank of Scotland (LSE: RBS) a couple of months ago, and I'm down 40%. 

I'm tempted to have another go, on the assumption that something this bad surely has to come good some time. Successful contrarianism is all in the timing, and so far my timing has been terrible.

Buy Iceland

Iceland was the first entire country to fall foul of the credit crunch, and the subsequent disarray its currency fell by half against the euro. But at least it has its own currency, and its vicious devaluation is already laying the groundwork for a recovery. 

Iceland has taken its medicine early, but eurozone Greece and Spain have been denied their medication by ECB strictures. True contrarians would have been snapping up property in Reykjavik months ago, but there's still time. 

Ireland could be another opportunity, having recently swallowed harsh budgetary remedies. But unlike Iceland, it can't devalue its currency.

Buy Greece

Er, on second thoughts. This is taking contrarianism too far, but maybe in a few months…

More from Harvey Jones:

> Motley Fool writers have picked their favourite shares for the coming year. Order Shares 2010 today 

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

lotontech 15 Dec 2009 , 11:53am

As a contrarian, whenever you are right you will make a lot of money. But the real trick is to not lose much money when you are wrong.

So yes: do go short on Gold and China; and do go long on the Pound, Dubai, Iceland, Greece, and RBS...

.. but be sure get out quick if any of those positions go against you.

Remember the wise words of Warren Buffett, Mark Twain, or whoever said it first: DON'T LOSE MONEY!

TamesisChild 15 Dec 2009 , 4:31pm

Many of the areas that you have highlighted take a great deal of skill/ luck (and money) to invest in successfully and I would hate to invest in something just because someone else isn’t.

For the most part I still think that it is best just to do your own research and then buy what you really believe in. Sometimes you may end up moving with the herd whilst you’ll be following a contrarian approach at other times...

rober00 15 Dec 2009 , 4:49pm

Harvey my undrstanding of this style involves more than just going opposite to the current situation on nearly every issue in sight. Surely the skill lies in distinguishing one thing from another in some meaningful way, which brings exceptional reward!!!

bagash 16 Dec 2009 , 11:40am

I tried the contrarian approach with Woolworths and lost my shirt. So I thought I would save my bacon by selling Northgate at 15p and its rights for 5p. Lost both ways, just how things work out for me!!!

YNOSITHE 16 Dec 2009 , 11:50am

There's nothing wrong with contrarian investing if you believe a stock has been unfairly punished and has a history of good revenue, profits, dividends, PE ratio and a good business model.
Barclays could be a buy, it is well capitalised, non-government owned and Barcap its investment arm is doing very well. The aquisition of Lehman Bros minus their debts at firesale prices was a bargain.
On the other hand Lloyds aquiring HBOS as well as their billions of debts and bad loans may not be such a good buy.
RBS is currently trading at 31.93p, on Nov 23 2009
Stephen Hester one of RBS's directors sold 250,886 shares at 37.48p each, the shares of RBS have gone down by almost 6p since that director sell, so as an investor, you need to ask yourself : do you want to own these shares when even the directors don't want to touch them.

houghtie 16 Dec 2009 , 12:21pm

I can understand some of the logic to some of this advise, BUT, long pounds. I'l say short euro (wait for the next round of fallout from the credit crsis), long dollar (price has suffered too much). Unforntately we are a smallish economy, with a dominant financial services industry. My questions to the author are:
1) Where will futue tax revenue come from now we can't rely on the city milk cow?
2) The current UK gov seems to be playing games wth the UK debt issue. If we get a new tory gov, things may improve, but is the population ready for the kind of spending cuts we need. If we get a hung parliament my bet would be the pound will plummet.

Now its one thing to be "contrarian", its another to do it in a vaccum of information, which this author seems to be doing. Is he arguing that these currencies/assets are over sold, mis priced orjust that they have gone done? Where is his justification for the mis pricing or is it simply "no one else is buying this stuff"?

k861 16 Dec 2009 , 12:26pm

Please please please do not think that ci is simply doing the opposite to the herd.
My best advice to anyone wanting to get into ci is to read up on it thoroughly before parting with cash.
I think David Dremen's books are probably as good as anywhere to start.

Jonesey12 16 Dec 2009 , 12:50pm

Harvey Jones here.

Hi houghtie. Like you, I'm worried about where UK growth is going to come from. I'm not saying that all these contrarian positions will come off, I'm just alerting readers to some of the most extreme. I think the pound is more likely to rise on weakness elsewhere, than strength over here. If the problems in Ireland, Spain and Greece spread through the eurozone, that will probably help the pound. Sterling has picked up against the euro in recent days... and also enjoyed an inexplicable resurgence in the spring. So it can happen.

YNOSITHE: I'm with you on Barclays. But I've already squandered my money on them, and haven't got much to spare.

daveyboy76 16 Dec 2009 , 1:23pm

I think an event so disastrous as the collapse of the US dollar would have repercussions of unprecedented unpredictability. The knock on effects are incalculable in my opinion. Gold may well hit $5000 per ounce and is one thing, but buying it or selling it in any form other than having it under your mattress in a climate of economics where the dollar is melting down is another. I don't think anyone would argue about the lengths the USA will goto to protect their security and exchange controls will be the tip of the iceberg... in my opinion.

hibernian63 16 Dec 2009 , 2:40pm

I don't know how the dollar/pound/euro weightings will work oput eventually- probably a case of who's worst- but it strikes me that sooner or later the winning currency relative to all three must be China's. Is it possible to buy a straight bet on their currency, rather than on their stockexchange index?

houghtie 16 Dec 2009 , 4:02pm

I would say the resurgence in spring was a good example of a "contrarian" bet, the pound was sold down too much. I would say that it is ripe for another down turn, although I would say that the euro is overvalued. I'd say that the issues affecting the euro are equally concerns for the pound, look at our fical issues and some emerging market exposure (think Dubai), although I would guess the euro zone is more exposed to any CEE problems. If the chances of a hung parliament increase, the pound will dive again (at least against the dollar). You might get a bounce with a tory government (but think 4/5 months down teh lin not now).

I would say the dollar is more of a contrarian bet (maybe long dollar or short gold).

BTW, most UK investors are all long pounds anyway. A lot of (foreign invested) Unit Trusts and Invstment Trusts have hedging policies and have little in the way of options to go the other way (sovereign and international bond funds are some of the easy options) to go the other way (which if you had already you could sell). There are some covered warrants from the likes of SG that let you easily "bet" on currency movements (which would let you go long pound against Euro).

houghtie 16 Dec 2009 , 4:14pm

BTW, I have 2 contrarian punts of my own and can provide good reasons to buy.

1) Any Japanese funds. Reasons, capitualation of foreign investors, end of yen strength against teh dollar (e.g. much more moneytary loosening in JP as US thoughts are turning ever so slowly towards tightening). Nicely hammered down prices vs other major indices.

2) Ecofin Power and Water. Nicely run IT, used it in the past bull run as it was heavily sold down after previous zeroes problems (I bought the capital shares then, which are no longer available). Not sure what is happening with the price or why, price is drifting, NAV is steady or firming, so discount is now > 20% (worse than some commercial property!!!). Also has a very defensive infrastruture background (also recently under performed), with some renewables exposure.

houghtie 16 Dec 2009 , 4:18pm

Hiberian, you'll find it extremely difficult to go long CNY. I reckon the chinese will let it appreciate next year. Owning a currency and owning a share demoninated in a currency are entirely diffent things. See last couple of copies of saturdays FT for 2 US based funds, but these use derivatives I think.

Mike10613 16 Dec 2009 , 5:28pm

I think gold still has a way to go, particularly when the jewellery trade starts buying again. India will start buying again at some point. I have a friend in gold and it's affecting cash flow. When demand for her products picks up she will buy more and keep a stock. I think you are quite right about the pound being worth buying, the question is when is the right time? I think when the Bank Of England increases interest rates a 1/4 points upwards, that will be the right time.

Tara1492 18 Dec 2009 , 5:22pm

Houghtie - I had a look at Ecofin - it looks interesting but the talk of 'derivatives', makes me a bit nervous bearing in mind that next year looks like being a difficult one - I don't understand derivatives but unfortunately a lot of the people who deal in them don't seem to understand them either. Do you think Ecofin does?

tdoghouse 22 Dec 2009 , 4:58pm

How about shorting banking pref shares / bonds. The banking board has now become a full time discussion board for buying pref shares / bonds. A feeding frenzy has begun :-) PS. Some very good analysis there of course. Above statement tongue in cheek.

Questorien 22 Dec 2009 , 7:26pm

I mentioned to a friend that now ought to be a good time to buy pounds.
He asked me "How do I buy pounds?" and "What do I pay with if I only have pounds?"

My attempt to explain only produced bafflement. Has anyone out there got a good explanation?

Quest.

jerryrc 23 Dec 2009 , 4:40pm

houghtie.

I may be too late to this discussion, but many, like you, are talking about how cheap Japanese stocks are. Looking at FT actuarial stats, it claims the Nikkei is currently on a P/E of over 30 with barely a 1% dividend yield. Is there another valuation basis to back up the 'cheap' theory ?!

houghtie 26 Dec 2009 , 11:06pm

Tara1492, I don't think Ecofin deal in derivatives, LON:ECWO. Take a look on trustnet and you'll see their major holdings, this is a share I've followed for over 5 years. They have some holdings in private companies, which amkes things a little opaque, but the majority of holdings are quoted companies. BTW the price has aleady moved a bit and I'm womdering what to do now. There's also some value in Monks and Alliance trust, alliance holds developed market stocks with emermging market exposure (near 20% disount).

houghtie 26 Dec 2009 , 11:08pm

Tara1492, the comment on dirivatives was related to investing in the chinese yuan (CNY).

houghtie 26 Dec 2009 , 11:42pm

jerryrc, I think the p/e is something to do with accounting standards in japan and other reasons (see http://boards.fool.com/Message.asp?mid=14871234&sort=whole), the current p/e is probably a lot lower than the historic one going back over 2 decades (see http://boards.fool.com/Message.asp?mid=14871234&sort=whole). On a price to book value measurement, things look a lot better (see http://www.indexuniverse.com/sections/features/6968-japan-rising.html), in some cases companies are actually valued at more than their assets, but don't earn a lot each year, guess it depends on how you value a company, assets or earnings. Anyone's thoughts on this would be appreciated.

houghtie 26 Dec 2009 , 11:53pm

jerryrc, the main reason I like Japan (apart from the fact it may on certain measures seem cheap, which should limit the amount of downside), are two other reasons:
1) There is a good chance Japanese monetary policy will be loosened (or at least that impression will be given). (see http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/988c8ec0-f119-11de-bcfc-00144feab49a.html). This will lower the price of the Yen.
2) Japan is better placed to exploit asian growth than any other developed country (see http://business.timesonline.co.uk/tol/business/markets/japan/article6964181.ece).

houghtie 27 Dec 2009 , 12:02am

Another positive for the exchange rate (although not for Japanese employment). ("Japan Jobless Rate Climbs for First Time Since July" http://www.businessweek.com/news/2009-12-24/japan-jobless-rate-climbs-for-first-time-since-july-update2-.html).

Also possibly for earnings too! Fortunately Japanese exporters are not relying on home sales for revenue growth.

houghtie 27 Dec 2009 , 12:04am

Yet another weaker Yen story ("Hatoyama Proposes Record Budget, Exacerbating Japan Debt Burden" http://www.businessweek.com/news/2009-12-25/hatoyama-proposes-record-budget-exacerbating-japan-debt-burden.html).

Join the conversation

Please take note - some tags have changed.

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: [b]bolded text[/b], [i]italicised text[/i]. All other tags will be removed from your post.

If you want to add a link, please ensure you type it as http://www.fool.co.uk as opposed to www.fool.co.uk.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.