Why I'm Hoping For Further Market Falls

Published in Investing Strategy on 29 October 2009

Fingers crossed for a fall in share prices.

It's been a great year for investors, but suddenly I'm not enjoying looking at my portfolio as much as I was a week or two back.

The FTSE 100 dropped 2% yesterday, and Barclays (LSE: BARC) and a couple of my emerging markets investment trusts are down 5% in a single session. I can live with that, but I'm not too happy about one or two of my recent decisions.

A few weeks ago, I also made a disastrous recent foray into washed-up banks, throwing good money at Lloyds Banking Group (LSE: LLOY) and Royal Bank of Scotland (LSE: RBS) for reasons that now seem inexplicable, and was routed. Lloyds is down 26% and RBS is down 21%, and I have to admit it serves me right.

I threw money at them in a careless moment, based on a couple of half-baked suggestions that they could double their value, rather than taking a cool and focused look at the banking sector and their individual prospects.

I got greedy. That's what happens when markets have been ladling out the gravy a little too long.

What a pudding!

When your luck turns, it turns. I was down 8% on both Prudential (LSE: PRU) and Jupiter India within three seconds of clicking "buy". What kind of Fool am I? At least I didn't make the mistake of thinking I was wise during the good times, confessing in September that I'm not the one getting everything right, It's the markets, stupid.

But my recent share buying decisions have certainly been rash and I've got my just desserts.

My only consolation is that these are all intended to be long-term buy and holds, so I shouldn't get too distracted by short-term price movements. As I wrote in A lousy year to sell shares, the only monumentally bad decision I've made this year was to sell off good companies with strong growth prospects too soon.

No, actually, Lloyds was a terrible decision.

5,500 or 4,700?

At time of writing, the FTSE has just closed at 5,068. The way 2009 has been, it is anybody's guess where it will end up at year end. It could still rally to hit 5,500 to make this a barnstorming 12 months, or it could just as easily slump to 4,700. Nobody knows.

Perversely, I hope it doesn't race ahead. We've had enough fun for one year, let's leave some growth prospects for 2010. I also suspect stock markets have raced ahead of the broader economy, and the economy needs some time to catch up.

And I'm worried that excess liquidity from low interest rates and quantitative easing has flooded equity markets, leading to bloated valuations. The last thing we want now is another unsustainable surge. A bit of treading water wouldn't go amiss.

Calm down, people

A slowdown now might also temper the excitement of private investors, who have been pouring into investment funds like there's no tomorrow.

Fund managers have enjoyed record net retail sales, selling more in the first nine months of this year than the whole of 2000, the previous best sales year on record, according to the Investment Management Association. Maybe that's the best sign that that this boom is getting toppy.

The current reversal could be a much-needed shot across their bows. I hope so. I don't know about you, but I've had enough of boom and bust.

A multitude of sins

Another worry is that flying share prices may obscure the need for serious reform and restructuring of our banking sector, if not the whole City, both of which have been having more fun than they deserve this year.

And given the tax hikes and spending cuts heading our way, it doesn't make sense for the stock market to be all fun and games.

Others may actively want markets to fall, so they can run around buying stuff on the cheap. I suspect Maynard Paton is, so he can load up on cheap stocks and get his Champion Shares PRO portfolio off to a flier.

I'm trying to get into the same mode of thinking, but it isn't easy, especially since I have now invested most of my spare cash (badly).

Please sir, can I have some more?

We should be pleased that markets are pausing for breath, or even retreating slightly, even if it does hurt.

If you're investing for the long term, as I am, a short-term stutter can present healthy buying opportunities. It also give us all a bit more time to decide where we want to go with our portfolios, rather than ploughing in because we're worried markets will rise even higher.

A dry end to this champagne year may be a good thing. It might give us more sober expectations for 2010, which looks like being a rumbustious year, politically and economically.

More from Harvey Jones:

Harvey owns shares in Barclays, Lloyds Banking, Prudential and RBS.

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

Petrean 29 Oct 2009 , 2:56pm

Interesting read. You might want to have a look at Value Investing by Ben Graham (and popularised by Warren Buffet). This has been working well for me lately (though, it's been less than a year so time will tell if my trades are any good). Check out my blog if you'd like more information and don't hesitate to get in touch:
http://thinksaboutthings.com/portfolio

BrnzDrgn 29 Oct 2009 , 3:57pm

I have Lloyds and RBS but I bought just when it was rising from its major crisis drop so I was just above even when it dropped. I also could have bought more - but decided against due to seasonal realities and the end of cash injections - just don't sell them yet - hold them for the long term, my thoughts are it may have been better to buy in December, as I will if the market conditions are right.

LetsGoa 29 Oct 2009 , 4:12pm

Fund managers have enjoyed record net retail sales, selling more in the first nine months of this year than the whole of 2000

Looks like a lot of retail investors are going to be losing money. This is nothing but a bear market rally.

The FTSE will breach the march lows before its over!

rober09 29 Oct 2009 , 4:50pm

Harvey the more I read of your stuff (which I like by the way)the more I get the impression that you have not thought through your investment objectives clearly. You appear to be pulled from pillar to post by events, which in my opinion is no way to make money.

I have made and continue to make errors of judgment in my investing career, leading to losses, but am happy I understand how these impact on my investment objective(s) and what lessons are to be learnt.

More importantly I know I am moving forward against my measured objectives over time.

theRealGrinch 29 Oct 2009 , 4:57pm

i really believe we are heading for 4400 or worse before easter 2010.

Dozey1 29 Oct 2009 , 6:16pm

I don't pretend to be an expert, and those that do usually disappoint, but my recent policy is to avoid big UK earners like the plague. My most recent forays (and I tend to be ltbh by the way) have been McBride, Braemar Shipping Services, De la Rue and Consort Medical all of whom earn much of their profits overseas. Consort Medical has the most stodgy record imaginable, and lost a big contract early in the year, but it's 5% yield twice covered doesn't look threatened and it's taking over The Medical House (my favourite holding bar none) for an absolute steal. Banks?? You must be mad! (Now watch my choices crumble!)

Doze

Jonesey12 30 Oct 2009 , 11:49am

rober09.

My objective is long-term capital growth, but you're right, I do get pulled around by short-term market sentiment. Still, I'm hoping readers will learn from my mistakes - and that one day, I will too!

Thanks for input, Harvey Jones

theRealGrinch: You could be right, or is your view just another brick in the wall of worry? Time will tell.

gordonbanks42 31 Oct 2009 , 8:07pm

I can't say I'm hoping for further market falls, or even that I'm expecting them, but I am expecting the main UK markets to move at best horizontally (on average) for a year or two, given the recent rises. Hence a strong case for a tactical reduction in FTSE 100/All Share exposure.

Bigger bets on weak Sterling and emerging markets seem to be the order of the day from here on in.

RobinnBanks 09 Nov 2009 , 12:12am

Do not despair Harvey - you will be able to buy more Lloyds for about 20p in the forthcoming rights issue, and the market price will be nearer £1 by Christmas. It needs to hit £3 for mine to break even. There's little hope for RBS though, not this year, or next.
I like your honest articles and your Norman Wisdom - Don't Laugh At Me 'Cos I'm a Fool!
Keep them coming, we all can learn from your mistakes, and hopefully not make so many as a conseqence.

Join the conversation

Please take note - some tags have changed.

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: [b]bolded text[/b], [i]italicised text[/i]. All other tags will be removed from your post.

If you want to add a link, please ensure you type it as http://www.fool.co.uk as opposed to www.fool.co.uk.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.