Nobody Knows Anything

Published in Investing Strategy on 25 June 2009

Nobody knows what is going to happen next. Here's how to plan for it.

Screenwriter William Goldman famously said the thing to remember about Hollywood is that "nobody knows anything".

Nobody knows which movies will fly, and which will flop. And afterwards, nobody knows why.

The same can be said about the global economy. Will it recover, or will it collapse? Nobody knows. Or stock markets. Will the FTSE 100 end the year at 5,000 or 3.000? Nobody knows.

Or the outlook for sectors and countries. Are we in for a commodities rally? Will smaller companies outperform blue-chips? Can China continue growing at the same rate? Will Japan ever recover?

Nobody knows.

A lucky guess

Plenty of people claim to know, of course. They might even be able to produce a few scraps of evidence to back up their claim.

With a bit of Googling, you can find articles listing the very clever people who predicted the credit crunch. Although they didn't say when. Or how.

They probably predicted lots of other stuff as well, but we don't remember that, because they got it wrong. Getting lucky once doesn't mean you actually know.

Because nobody knows.

Inflation or deflation? Nobody knows

A couple of days ago, I read a harrowing article warning of the continuing dangers of deflation.

Then I clicked on another article directly below it, on the same page of the same newspaper website. The author was giving a harrowing account of the continuing dangers of inflation.

They were both equally convincing. But neither of them actually knows.

Yesterday I read a fund manager claiming US Treasuries are set to rally over the summer. Over the weekend, another manager was claiming they would slump.

Who knows?

Jim can't fix it

Nobody knows. Jim Rogers doesn't know. In January, he panicked everybody by claiming the UK was finished, and investors should sell sterling. The pound has since risen 20%.

Warren Buffett doesn't know. He lost $25 billion last year. Fool UK co-founder and writer Bruce Jackson doesn't know (oops, this could be my last commission). He has lost money in the crunch, like the rest of us.

And please don't ask me, because I don't know. If I did, I wouldn't have taken out a pension with Equitable Life in 1999, invested in Aberdeen European Technology in February 2000, or tried to call the bottom of the commercial property market last spring (they're still looking for it).

Know your limitations

So what is to stop us from losing faith in stock tipsters, analysts and fund managers, and simply leaving our money in a spread of tracker funds?

Nothing, actually. If you know you don't know, and don't want to spend time trying to know, this is a thoroughly respectable strategy.

And if the thought of not knowing whether your portfolio will be up or down 10% next week gives you sleepless nights, then you are quite within your rights to opt for the certainty of a fixed-rate savings bond instead.

Not knowing never stopped anybody

But the fact that nobody knows anything hasn't stopped Hollywood from making movies, and it shouldn't stop you from buying shares or funds.

You will no doubt get your fair share of turkeys, but hopefully they will be outnumbered by the blockbusters.

So here are my four investment rules for people who know nothing. There were originally three, but then I thought of another one.

I didn't know that was going to happen.

  • Accept you don't know. Find out all you can about a company before investing. How good is its management? Is it making a profit? Are sales rising? How is the dividend? Is it cash-strong? What are the barriers to entry for competitors? Or better still, sign up to Maynard Paton's Champion Shares and let him do the legwork for you. But you must also accept that the more you know, the more you don't know. You don't know if the dynamic chief executive is about to take early retirement on health grounds. You don't know what its rivals are up to. Or whether there is another banking crisis around the corner. So you are effectively taking an educated guess on what you do know, and crossing your fingers about what you don't. There are no guarantees.

  • Don't believe anybody who claims they do know. We've all had our share of hot stock tips, companies that cannot fail. Some did quite well, looking back, others didn't. That's how it goes. By all means listen to your friend, but top-up his partial knowledge with some of your own.

  • Know the right things. I've rashly said that Bruce Jackson doesn't know, but there are plenty of things he does know. He knows the warning signs of a downturn. He knows The Fastest Way to Lose a Million. He knows how to prosper in flat markets.

  • Know your own strategy. Draw up some rules to guide you in both good times and bad. Spread your risk. Remember that investors have a habit of buying at the top and selling at the bottom. Remember The Importance of Dividend Yield. Remember that Most Shares are Losers. Remember the Four Reasons to Sell a Stock. And finally, teach yourself How to Play the Long Game.

There will still be a mountain of stuff that you don't know, but you don't have to know everything, just enough.

> There's one thing we do know. You can buy and sell shares for just £10 using The Motley Fool Share Dealing service. And we also know it's free to open an account.

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

lotontech 25 Jun 2009 , 4:01pm

Great Article! One of the most intelligent and honest articles to appear on Fool.

I could be picky and point out things like "Nobody knows, so hey why not sign up for Maynard Paton's Champion Shares" but I'll try to be constructive instead...

When establishing a position I try to think not only can this stock go up, but what will I do if it goes down? Blindly hold in the hope that it recovers, or cut my loss with a Stop Order?

Readers might also be interested to know that the trend-following approach is based almost entirely on the premise that nobody knows if the market will go up or down; but if it's going up then it is more likely to keep going up, and if it is going down then it is more likely to keep going down.

I think the phrase "more likely" is key here. An undervalued stock is 'more likely' to go up -- but it's not guaranteed, and we don't know when. A market price is 'more likely' to bounce of its support level than to break it, but don't bet the farm on it!

I say again -- a great article!


elaineellensteed 26 Jun 2009 , 12:34pm

Fantastic article I am 62 still working running my own business and I have decided to live for today because as you say "nobody knows" 70% of the population has lost 39% of its wealth the rest are probably on benefits or in serious debt

Jonesey12 26 Jun 2009 , 1:34pm

Harvey Jones here

Thanks for your kind words, lotontech and elaineellensteed.
lotontech, you got me! Please don't be too "picky", I might unravel..!!

Iniq 26 Jun 2009 , 2:04pm

Agreed: a modest, sensible and realistic article.

The only comment I would make, as a cautious investor, is that in a fluctuating market, pound-cost averaging is beneficial.

Even if the market ends where it started, you will make a profit just from the fluctuations, and the greater the fluctuations the greater your profit.

roberto2008 26 Jun 2009 , 2:24pm

Nobody knows that’s true but what I do know is that the DISCIPLINE of saving a good portion of your earnings over a long period will accumulate you a fair bit of money.

Nice if you get interest on it and nice if you make a profit on some shares by investing it but the “discipline of saving it” is the most important thing you can acquire.

Also the ability to DENY yourself things and learn to be happy with what you do have ,not what you don’t have.

Discipline and denial are the key factors for wealth with out them you chance loosing whatever you do
make!

Also always remember that its NET WORTH that counts, you can have a massive empire and lifestyle but if its not paid for its only a liability.

TheHeroTheDavid 26 Jun 2009 , 5:01pm

No one knows where it's going?

Well I'll have a pop at it then!

I'd predict another economic crisis between Mid Sept & Mid October, resulting in even more money being created, or dramatic devaluations of the dollar.

Last year in September I was telling a friend that HBOS was about to go belly up on the Friday when all its one year loans were due, only to have my prediction thwarted by a government sponsored LloydsTSB takeover.

There will be something similar this year in the wider economy with 3 factors - loans becoming due - the impact of increasing unemployment on both retail, ability to pay existing debt, & concomitant government assistance combined with falling tax revenues - and finally; the fact that all the banker/investor holidays are over & most HY reults have been published.

I can't see how a large dose of inflation won't follow, & therefore the wisest choices in investments would be in things which retain their value & are essential in keeping civilisation going, like farmland, precious metals etc.

As I've posted before, inflation is a form of taxation. There would be no general inflation in a non fiat currency. Under a fiat currency money is created & interest charged upon its loan e.g I create £100 in a currency & charge 10% interest. If there is only £100, how can it be paid off?

Simple, create more money & charge interest on that - & on & on it goes, as multiples of the original sum are still only able to purchase the same asset.

The guys creating the money reap all the benefits, & any economics model shows that ultimately they own all the assets - sped along by periods in which the money supply is cut & businesses & individuals are unable to pay the interest & have their assets seized.

The Federal Reserve (run by a selection of private banks) is the biggest printer of money in the world but is unanswerable evn to the US Govt. Obama has no control over it, nor the legislature.

Trillions have been created in the last year alone, & economics 101 states that too much supply (money) chasing too few assets creates inflation. It's all a question of timing. How many more unprecedented bailouts will occur. It only delays the inevitable.

Futhermore, the easiest way for a government to get out of its debt obligation is to create more money, thus pay its bills or simply devalue in order to become more competitive via exports, & use the enhanced tax receipts to pay off its debts.

Guess who suffers most - all the average Joes out there, as your hard saved cash becomes worth less by the day in either scenario.

The UK borrowings for next year have been seriously underestimated, & whomever wins the next election will have to make savage public spending cuts - across the board to be fair. This in turn will lead to even greater unemployment.

I can't see us coming out of this for years; it's not like we have a functioning manufacturing base to get us out of it, & whilst we have Globalist/Internationalist leaders who prefer to send British jobs abroad & suffer the domestic social consequences of reduced taxation & unemployment - we are - as both Jim Rogers & Gerald Celente say - through.

The best growth prospects are in the BRIC countries - but sending capital there just reduces the availabilty at home.

Visa apllications anyone ;-)












Terrapin1 26 Jun 2009 , 6:29pm

Here's the big things I KNOW how to trade without knowing what's going to happen. I'll give up that secret to 12 people for £250,000, and guarantee its success for a lifetime.

HenryScottTuke 26 Jun 2009 , 7:47pm

Nobody knows what is going to happen to the stockmarket. But I know with certainty that at some point we will die. When is the question, which very few of us know. By all means plan and invest for the future, look ahead ten years and adjust your portfolio accordingly, but also live life today. You might not wake up tomorrow.

LastChip 26 Jun 2009 , 11:04pm

Essentially, I agree in principal with this article, but the questions that spring to mind; if nobody knows, what's the point of paying money to tipsters, or having analysts within institutions pouring over data?

In spite of all this "expert" help, another article recently published, suggested in the USA (and the UK is likely to be similar), about 95% (I think?) of all shares loose money. After all, the stock market is indeed a weighing machine and for all those investors making a profit, someone else is making a loss.

I can happily (hand on heart) say, I've never spent a penny on tips and rarely look at what analysts have to say, yet my losses over the past year, are pretty much the same as the average of everyone else from what I can make out.

Isn't it simply a bunch of leaches trying to suck blood from the ill-informed? Or indeed, an inbuilt desire to allow someone else to take the blame when your shares crash: "it wasn't my fault governor, I was told to buy them"!

UpHillAllTheWay 29 Jun 2009 , 5:59pm

A very good, common sense article. It's true that nobody knows, but some know less than others. Not many know less than I, though.

TheHeroTheDavid - a very thought-provoking post. It gave me some slants on inflation and interest that, while obvious when they are pointed out, had never occurred to me. Thank you.

Terapin1 - that's not how to advertise. You have to write at least 12 pages of rambling text, going on and on and on about the benefits - and only then, talk about money. And when you do, don't, whatever you do,give anything away about method or price without getting them to "Sign up" first, so you can pester them with junk mail for the next 2 years.

LastChip - "for all those investors making a profit, someone else is making a loss". I agree with this also, which suggests quite strongly that some people have a better idea of the future than most do.

Before this whole credit crunch started, I read two books, and both of them did't get much wrong.
"The Coming Crash in the Housing Market" by John R Talbot was copyrighted in 2003, and "Wake Up! Survice and Proster in the Coming Economic Turmoil" by Jim Mellon and Al Chalabi has a 2005 copyright. Both books give a full analysis of markets and worl events, and I believe that anybody with a similarly broad view of our economic world, and a sense of history, stands a better chance than most of us of getting it right.

NigelTMF 01 Jul 2009 , 11:08am

Harvey,

Well done - good article. It is my mantra for life - be don't lieve anyone who tells you they know..... they don't.....

Nigel

michaelbarr 03 Jul 2009 , 11:57am

This is in part a great lesson for investors as I have never seen any compelling evidence to support the idea that forecasting works. There may be those who can get it write but we only get to know with the benefit of hindsight.

It would be much better if those attempting to predict the future would be more up front and say they are making a guess.

If you are relating this article to a boxing match though, the forecasters would be on the ropes until the last round, but you give them a chance for a comeback and you end up with a lucky draw. What am I talking about?

Well, its best to understand that just about all of us have a particular limitation - the inability to pick stocks, which after all, is a form of forecasting. You are picking stocks that you are expecting - forecasting - will do well in the future, and excluding – forecasting - those you expect to underperform.

Again, based on the evidence available, very very few people have the skills to consistently beat the market, we cannot identify them in advance, and for the great majority of people a passive index strategy would be the best solution.

To have a successful outcome over the long run, you should do your best to avoid disasters- big losses- and buying an index fund effectively removes such a risk.

If you want to pick stocks then do so with a small part of your portfolio and regard it as entertainment.

Join the conversation

Please take note - some tags have changed.

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: [b]bolded text[/b], [i]italicised text[/i]. All other tags will be removed from your post.

If you want to add a link, please ensure you type it as http://www.fool.co.uk as opposed to www.fool.co.uk.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.