The Cheapest International Trackers

Published in Investing Strategy on 6 May 2009

When it comes to tracking international stock markets, the choices for investors have increased greatly in recent years, but how can you do it cost-effectively?

Following on from my recent article on UK-focused index trackers, today I'm looking at the international trackers that are available. There's a huge range of funds on offer and, as with UK trackers, they consist of unit trusts/OEICs, investment trusts and exchange traded funds (ETFs).

I've broken the selection down by regional focus, and this is a bit subjective: I've included the iShares MSCI Eastern Europe (LSE: IEER) with the BRIC countries (Brazil, Russia, India, and China), for example, as more than half of its value is in Russia. And we could debate whether South Africa and Korea are emerging markets or developed economies. Funds focusing on particular investment styles (value, small cap, etc.) have been excluded.

In any case, investors should check the details of any fund before buying, to be sure they know what they're getting.

Global funds

Some investors want to get exposure to all the world's markets, and there are just a handful of funds tracking these.

FundTotal expense ratioType of fundLump sum minimum (£)Monthly minimum (£)
db x-trackers DJ STOXX 600 (LSE: XSX6)0.20%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers MSCI World TRN (LSE: XMWD)0.45%ETFn/an/a
Lyxor ETF MSCI World GBP (LSE: LWOR)0.45%ETFn/an/a
iShares MSCI World (LSE: IWRD)0.50%ETFn/an/a
Aviva Investors International Index Tracking Fund0.95%UT/OEIC1,00050
Legal & General Global 100 Index Trust1.00%UT/OEIC50050

Developed economies

Within the developed economies you have the option to track individual countries as well as regions such as Europe or North America. The cheapest funds that I could find were the db x-trackers ETFs from Deutsche Bank, specifically their DAX (Germany) (LSE: XDAX) and DJ Euro STOXX 50 (LSE: XESC), both of which have total expense ratios (TERs) of just 0.15%.

Other db x-trackers are available with charges up to 0.5%, while iShares ETFs cost between 0.35% and 0.59%, Lyxor's from 0.3% to 0.65%, and the Russell 1000 Fund (LSE: RONE) from ETFS costs 0.35%.

As regards unit trusts, the cheapest is the HSBC Japan Index Fund at 0.67%, while the cheapest focusing on Europe is the M&G Group European Index Tracker at 0.71%.

The Edinburgh US Tracker (LSE: EUS) investment trust has a TER of 0.33% and currently trades at a discount to net asset value of 3%.

FundTotal expense ratioType of fundLump sum minimum (£)Monthly minimum (£)
db x-trackers DAX (Germany) (LSE: XDAX)0.15%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers DJ EURO STOXX 50 (LSE: XESC)0.15%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers CAC 40 (France) (LSE: XCAC)0.20%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers MSCI Europe TRN UK (LSE: XMEU)0.30%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers MSCI USA TRN (LSE: XMUS)0.30%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers S&P/MIB Index (Italy) (LSE: XMIB)0.30%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers SMI (Switzerland) (LSE: XSMI)0.30%ETFn/an/a
iShares AEX (Netherlands) (LSE: IAEX)0.30%ETFn/an/a
Lyxor ETF NASDAQ 100 (LSE: LNSQ)0.30%ETFn/an/a
Edinburgh US Tracker (LSE: EUS)0.33%Investment Trustn/an/a
db x-trackers SLI (Switzerland) (LSE: XSLI)0.35%ETFn/an/a
ETFS Russell 1000 Fund (LSE: RONE)0.35%ETFn/an/a
iShares MSCI Europe (LSE: IMEU)0.35%ETFn/an/a
iShares S&P/MIB (Italy) (LSE: IMIB)0.35%ETFn/an/a
Lyxor ETF MSCI USA (LSE: LMUS)0.35%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers FTSE All-World Ex UK (LSE: XWXU)0.40%ETFn/an/a
iShares FTSEurofirst 100 (LSE: IEUT)0.40%ETFn/an/a
iShares FTSEurofirst 80 (LSE: IEUR)0.40%ETFn/an/a
iShares MSCI Europe ex-UK (LSE: IEUX)0.40%ETFn/an/a
iShares MSCI North America (LSE: INAA)0.40%ETFn/an/a
iShares S&P 500 (LSE: IUSA)0.40%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers MSCI Japan TRN (LSE: XMJP)0.50%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers S&P/ASX 200 (Australia) (LSE: XAUS)0.50%ETFn/an/a
Lyxor ETF Dow Jones IA GBP (LSE: LIND)0.50%ETFn/an/a
Lyxor ETF Japan TOPIX (LSE: LTPX)0.50%ETFn/an/a
iShares MSCI Japan (LSE: IJPN)0.59%ETFn/an/a
Lyxor ETF FTSE JSE TOP 40 South Africa (LSE: LSAF)0.65%ETFn/an/a
HSBC Japan Index Fund0.67%Unit trust / OEIC1,00050
M&G Group European Index Tracker0.71%Unit trust / OEIC50010
Legal & General US Index Trust0.78%Unit trust / OEIC50050
Legal & General Japan Index Trust0.79%Unit trust / OEIC50050
Legal & General European Index Trust0.80%Unit trust / OEIC50050
Prudential European Index Tracker Trust0.80%Unit trust / OEIC50050
HSBC American Index Fund1.14%Unit trust / OEIC1,00050
HSBC European Index Fund1.20%Unit trust / OEIC1,00050
Allianz RCM European Equity Income Fund1.27%Unit trust / OEIC50050

BRICs

I've separated the BRIC economies from the rest of the emerging markets, and the only tracker I can find focusing on all four countries is the iShares FTSE BRIC 50 (LSE: BRIC), which charges 0.74%.

Other BRIC-focused funds cost are available from iShares, db x-trackers, and Lyxor, and they are all in a narrow cost range of 0.6% to 0.85%.

FundTotal expense ratioType of fundLump sum minimum (£)Monthly minimum (£)
db x-trackers FTSE/XINHUA China 25 (LSE: XX25)0.60%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers MSCI Brazil TRN (LSE: XMBR)0.65%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers MSCI Russia Capped (LSE: XMRC)0.65%ETFn/an/a
Lyxor ETF Brazil (Ibovespa) (LSE: BRZ)0.65%ETFn/an/a
Lyxor ETF Hong Kong (his) (LSE: LHKG)0.65%ETFn/an/a
iShares FTSE BRIC 50 (LSE: BRIC)0.74%ETFn/an/a
iShares FTSE/Xinhua China 25 (LSE: FXC)0.74%ETFn/an/a
iShares MSCI Brazil (LSE: IBZL)0.74%ETFn/an/a
iShares MSCI Eastern Europe (LSE: IEER)0.74%ETFn/an/a
iShares MSCI Latin America (LSE: LTAM)0.74%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers SP CNX NIFTY (India) (LSE: XNIF)0.85%ETFn/an/a
Lyxor ETF India S&P CNX NIFTY (LSE: LNFT)0.85%ETFn/an/a

Emerging markets

The lowest cost ETF in this area is the db x-trackers MSCI Pacific ex Japan TRN (LSE: XPXD) at 0.45%, followed closely by the Lyxor ETF Eastern Europe (LSE: LEEU) at 0.5%. Other ETFs cost up to 0.95%, with the iShares range pitched at 0.74%.

The only unit trust trackers in this sector are the Legal & General Pacific Index Trust (0.83%) and the HSBC Pacific Index Fund (0.98%).

FundTotal expense ratioType of fundLump sum minimum (£)Monthly minimum (£)
db x-trackers MSCI Pacific ex Japan TRN (LSE: XPXD)0.45%ETFn/an/a
Lyxor ETF Eastern Europe (LSE: LEEU)0.50%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers MSCI AC Asia ex Japan TRN (LSE: XAXJ)0.65%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers MSCI EM Asia TRN (LSE: XMAS)0.65%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers MSCI EM EMEA TRN (LSE: XMEA)0.65%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers MSCI EM LatAm TRN (LSE: XMLA)0.65%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers MSCI Emerging Markets TRN (LSE: XMEM)0.65%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers MSCI Korea TRN (LSE: XKS2)0.65%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers MSCI Taiwan TRN (LSE: XMTW)0.65%ETFn/an/a
Lyxor ETF DJ Turkey Titans 20 (LSE: LTRK)0.65%ETFn/an/a
Lyxor ETF Kuwait (FTSE Coast Kuwait 40) (LSE: LKUW)0.65%ETFn/an/a
Lyxor ETF MSCI AC Asia-Pacific ex-Japan (LSE: LASP)0.65%ETFn/an/a
Lyxor ETF MSCI Emerging Markets (LSE: LEME)0.65%ETFn/an/a
Lyxor ETF MSCI Korea GBP (LSE: LMKO)0.65%ETFn/an/a
iShares MSCI AC Far East ex-Japan (LSE: IFFF)0.74%ETFn/an/a
iShares MSCI AC Far East ex-Japan SmallCap (LSE: ISFE)0.74%ETFn/an/a
iShares MSCI Korea (LSE: IKOR)0.74%ETFn/an/a
iShares MSCI Taiwan (LSE: ITWN)0.74%ETFn/an/a
iShares MSCI Turkey(LSE: ITKY)0.74%ETFn/an/a
iShares MSCI Emerging Markets (LSE: IEEM)0.75%ETFn/an/a
Legal & General Pacific Index Trust0.83%Unit trust / OEIC50050
db x-trackers FTSE Vietnam (LSE: XFVT)0.85%ETFn/an/a
db x-trackers S&P Select Frontier ETF (LSE: XSFR)0.95%ETFn/an/a
HSBC Pacific Index Fund0.98%Unit trust / OEIC1,00050

Obviously these categories are very broad groupings, and the main question should be what exactly do you want to buy -- it makes little sense to buy a different country because it's 0.1% cheaper, for example.

You can buy ETFs and investment trusts for as little as £10 using The Motley Fool Sharedealing Service.

More: The Cheapest Index Trackers

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

gordonbanks42 06 May 2009 , 9:20pm

Nice idea for an article, and asked for recently by readers. BUT surely we need to know what the tracking errors of these funds are before deciding which one to go for? If one fund has a slightly lower TER than another but tracks much less accurately, I might well pay the higher TER. On the basis of the tables above, I would go back to source data to assess tracking errors before deciding. So I'm afraid these tables don't save me much work.

The other factor people need to now about in assessing VFM is trading costs. ETFs have a bid/offer spread. Some UTs have spreads too. But are the spreads all the same? I think not. OEICs are typically single-priced. These are factors which hardly ever vary according to how or where you buy so could readily be included in a survey like this.

gordonbanks42 06 May 2009 , 9:27pm

Another thing to bear in mind is that some of these indices are very broad and some are really very narrow relative to the "host" country's stock market as a whole.

A standard criticism of the FTSE 100 is that it isn't really all that well diversified by industry sector. But if you look at the FTSE/XINHUA China 25 or the India S&P CNX NIFTY they are desperately narrow (top-heavy) measures of the performance of the Chinese and Indian markets generally.

So even if the fund tracks its index accurately you may be buying an index which doesn't represent that country's market performance that well. There are good technical reasons why this is so, but it's something people should be aware of and take into account.

Esquilax100 07 May 2009 , 12:53am

Gordonbanks42, thanks for your comments.

On the basis of the tables above, I would go back to source data to assess tracking errors before deciding

I'd be interested to read your findings. There's a long list of things to be considered when buying; as I said in the article, investors should check the details of any fund before buying, to be sure they know what they're getting.

Also:
[i]FTSE 100 [and others] ... isn't really all that well diversified by industry sector.[/i]

I fully agree, and have written on this in the past:
http://www.fool.co.uk/news/investing/investing-strategy/2006/12/19/exactly-what-are-you-tracking.aspx

While you say these tables don't save you much work, I'm confident that many people will find them a useful starting point for further research, and they don't pretend to be more than that.

- Padraig

Jaguar177 24 Jun 2009 , 8:05am

I want to get into buying iShares but live in the UAE though retain a house etc in the UK. Any advice as to the best way to buy these given that I cannot open a sharedealing account with Motley Fool due to my residential status.

Jaguar177 24 Jun 2009 , 8:05am

I want to get into buying iShares but live in the UAE though retain a house etc in the UK. Any advice as to the best way to buy these given that I cannot open a sharedealing account with Motley Fool due to my residential status.

Join the conversation

Please take note - some tags have changed.

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: [b]bolded text[/b], [i]italicised text[/i]. All other tags will be removed from your post.

If you want to add a link, please ensure you type it as http://www.fool.co.uk as opposed to www.fool.co.uk.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.