The Simplest Investing Strategy

Published in Investing Strategy on 12 January 2009

There’s a lot to be said for keeping things simple when it comes to investing. It’s one of the reasons index trackers provide an excellent way to invest in the stock market.

Perhaps the thing I like most about index trackers is their simplicity when compared to other forms of investment. As we’ve discovered in the past eighteen months, many complicated investment strategies offer little transparency and even less in the way of protection when times get tough.

With an index tracker, all you are essentially trying to do is capture the return of a particular stock market for as little cost as possible. Choosing a fund is simple as there only a few factors to consider. It’s also easy to invest your money and monitor its progress.

Choosing an index tracker

Trustnet lists almost 3,000 unit and investment trusts and nearly 7,000 funds that you can put into a pension. How on earth does the novice investor know where to start when choosing a fund?

With index trackers, the process is much simpler. You choose which market you want to track and then pick one of the lowest-cost funds which follow that market.

Most investors will want to start with a fund tracking the UK market. Here index trackers will either follow the FTSE All-Share index or its more famous younger brother the FTSE 100. There’s not a lot to choose between the two although I slightly favour the former as it captures a larger percentage of the market (98% versus around 80%-85%).

Then you look for a fund that has a low total expense ratio. Most funds tracking the UK market fall between 0.3% and 0.75% so look for something in the bottom half of that range. You might find this article from last June a useful starting point - it lists the ten cheapest UK trackers at that time and has a brief introduction to the different types of fund. This follow-up piece lists looks at trackers following overseas markets.

Investing in an index tracker

Putting your money in an index tracker is also very simple. Exactly how you do it will depend on the type of fund you end up choosing.

If it’s a unit trust, OEIC or investment trust then it should have a savings scheme that will you allow to invest from as little as £10 a month or from £250 as a lump sum. The minimum amounts vary between funds, with the combination of £50 a month and £500 for lump sums being the most typical.

If you choose an exchange traded fund like an iShare then you can use a service like the Motley Fool’s ShareBuilder to make cheap, regular purchases.

When it comes to index trackers, I reckon regular investing is the place to start. It eases you into the process of investing and then, when you have a bit more confidence, you can look to invest more money with a lump sum.

Regular investing also removes the need to make a decision on whether now is a good time to invest or not. Nobody knows what the market will do next week, next month or next year and it’s pretty pointless agonising over it as a novice investor. I’m a great believer in the old saying that to be a successful investor, it’s time in the market that’s important and not timing.

Reinvesting your dividends and keeping your investments safe from the taxman by putting them in an ISA also makes a lot of sense. Many funds will allow you do both of these without incurring any additional costs.

As with all types of investment you want to diversify, so I reckon it’s a good idea to build up a portfolio of, say, four different index trackers over time. Two of these could follow the UK market and two could invest overseas. This gives you a solid base on which to add other funds and shares when you become a more experienced investor and feel comfortable taking on a bit more risk.

Following your index tracker

If you invest in managed funds or shares, you need to keep monitoring them to see how they are performing. You may want to ditch some and replace them with others. This can take time and quite a lot of it too. You also incur transaction costs which reduce your overall returns.

With an index tracker you don’t have these concerns. You know its performance should closely match the index it’s attempting to follow and it’s pretty easy to check that this is indeed the case.

There will be some differences, mostly due to the annual cost of the fund but also due to what is known as tracking error (as no fund can precisely match the index). You can also compare your trackers against others tracking the same index with a similar cost structure to ensure your fund is up to scratch.

Find out more in the Fool’s index tracker centre

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

retiredhooray 13 Jan 2009 , 9:59am

I want to put my full ISA allowance into a tracker, but have only done cash ISA's before so not entirely sure how to go about it. Advice please! I presume you don't go to the building society. Also I was thinking of waiting until the index drops a bit before investing, but don't know how quickly they would respond after I put in an application. A little basic help would be good!

jonathanheenan3 13 Jan 2009 , 10:06am

Having actively played the stock market for just over 10 years now I can proudly claim to have beaten the market by 3%. Broken down all my hard work has rewarded me with the mouth watering 0.3% a year! Cash, property and under the matress beat this performance.

Therefor I totally agree. It was impossible to predict the banks collapse as they didnt have to tell us about the unregulated stuff. therefore I will never buy an individual stock again. It is the same as gambling.

Instead I have chosen 7 funds to chuck into my SIPP, either index trackers or funds of funds. I have chosen them on the following criteria

1. Must have grown at a reasnable rate over past 15 years
2. Can not be too volatile
3. Good geographical spread
4. Asset class spread of equities, bonds, property
5. Low TER preferable

Here are my little beauties,

1. I shares FTSE 100
2. Capital gearing Trust
3. fidelity European values
4. HG Capital Trust
5. I share Emerging Markets
6. RIT Capital partners
7. TR property Investment

Let me know your thoughts
2.

Here are my lovelies, what do you think?

jerryrc 13 Jan 2009 , 1:07pm

I have also ventured into stock-picking, with varied success and confirm index tracking is really the ONLY way to invest in the stock-market in my view. OK, there is little adventure, but who cares when you are beating the majority of investors.

1. Automatic re-investment of dividends ensure the magic of compounding.
2. Virtually impossible to lose 100% your money (unlike many other forms of investing)
3. long term outperformance of most other, more expensive funds/hedge funds/pooled investments vehicles.

Problem is it takes ventures into other forms of investment to realise the above (as I've discovered).

Happy tracking...

cost124 13 Jan 2009 , 6:00pm

I totally agree. My first investment in the market was in 1970 and since then I have been an active player.
Overall I am ahead but only really because of the sustained bull market in the 80s, privatisations, and when I did not try to do it myself.
My main gains have come from investing via PEPs over 20 years in a spread of investment trusts, and I too am now using trackers as it stops me trying to beat the market which I have finally accepted is very very unlikely for a small player like me.

gordonbanks42 13 Jan 2009 , 10:11pm

The biggest difficulty I have encountered in shopping around for trackers is that no-one seems to take tracking error seriously.

Does anyone publish comparative tracking error figures? I think not. Presumably this is because the vast majority of funds are not trackers and tracking error would be meaningless for a non-tracker fund. It is possible to work out the tracking error (if you can get long-term performacne numbers for accumulation units and an equivalent total return index value), but given their popularity it's about time "someone" did it for us, don't you think?

And perhaps there should be some kind of maximum tracking error that a fund can deliver while still legally claiming to be a tracker? Or at least an obligation to quote a target maximum tracking error in the prospectus.

At the moment I don't see anything that protects a retail investor from buying into a tracker that doesn't track.

gordonbanks42 13 Jan 2009 , 10:20pm

There is a tempting amount of divergence and rise/fall timing difference between the FTSE100 and FTSE250 indices, which leads me to think that some kind of lazy portfolio strategy based on rebalancing between the two might work.

eg Define an allocation to FTSE100 and FTSE250 in the proportions (say) 90%:10% and find a tracker that would track each index. Invest regularly (monthly) in both and tweak the amounts from time to time (say quarterly) so as to bring the overall proportions back to 90%:10%. Once the portfolio is big enough the new money might not be enough to achieve rebalancing, so in that event a switch might also be required.

This should have the effect of buying whichever's cheap at the time and cashing in whichever's just gone up a lot.

Anyone tried it with these 2 indices?

jerryrc 15 Jan 2009 , 1:57pm

gordonbanks42.

Am not a statistician, but would not the above give you roughly what a FTSE All Share Tracker does?

If you are seeking to try and 'outperform' by taking differing positions depending on the relative width of p/e ratios between the 2, if you're only (on average) 10% in FTSE 250 at any one time, then your outperformance will be pretty marginal won't it, that's assuming you make the right calls in the 1st place about when each index is 'cheap'?

CunningCliff 18 Jan 2009 , 5:21pm

Anyone doubting the superiority of index-tracking as an investment strategy should wise up by reading this compelling book by the 'father of indexing':

"The Little Book of Commonsense Investing: The Only Way to Guarantee Your Fair Share of Stock Market Returns" by John C Bogle
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Little-Book-Commonsense-Investing-Guarantee/dp/0470102101

Cliff

sep09 26 Jan 2009 , 3:01pm

I read with interest all the comments above on index tracking. I have little/no experience in the area of stocks and shares, but I have a few thousand pounds I would like to invest. My goal is to provide for my future.. at age 50 with no pension (I know... I made some serious errors of judgement in my misspent youth) all I have is my savings and I would like to make them work for me.
At the risk of sounding rather thick... exactly how does one go about index tracking?? I would be very grateful for any advice - but please keep it in simple terms... :)

peers100 27 Jan 2009 , 5:46pm

I have recently returned from a trip to the US staying with an old friend. He is a canny investor and he invests only in the US and buys municipal Tax free bonds and gets a 5% interest on his money. Does anyone know any similar investments in the U.K

Join the conversation

Please take note - some tags have changed.

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: [b]bolded text[/b], [i]italicised text[/i]. All other tags will be removed from your post.

If you want to add a link, please ensure you type it as http://www.fool.co.uk as opposed to www.fool.co.uk.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.