Harvey Jones wonders if it's time to hang up on Vodafone Group plc (LON:VOD)?
Investing isn't all buy, buy, buy -- you also have to know when to sell, sell, sell. The question I'm asking myself right now is should I sell Vodafone (LSE: VOD) (NASDAQ: VOD.US)?
I'm not the only investor who has been wondering whether to hang up on global mobile phone giant Vodafone lately. After investment maestro Neil Woodford rang off earlier this month, plenty of us have been asking whether to follow his lead. But is Vodafone really dialling all the wrong numbers?
Can't see Woodford the trees
Woodford sold a day after Vodafone's most recent trading update, which reported a 5.2% fall in revenues in the final quarter, with particularly sharp falls in Italy, Spain and the UK. Vodafone also faces major challenges in the shape of Indian tax wrangles, regulatory overhang and tough competition. Yet it wasn't all bad news. Group data revenue rose 13% to £1.7 billion, and Vodafone's share of emerging markets looks healthy, especially in India and Turkey. Verizon Wireless, its joint venture with Verizon, punched out a £2.4 billion dividend, cutting Vodafone's net debt to £23.3 billion. Vodafone Red, its new European pricing package, has made a promising start. The company still pumps out cash and is now buying back £1.5 billion worth of shares. In fact, the market preferred to look on the positive side, and Vodafone rose 2% in response to the results. Woodford was in a minority. Trouble is, when that happens, the majority is usually wrong.
Krupp and Kabel
Woodford isn't the first investor to wonder about Vodafone. Its share price has been moribund for years, and is down 6% over the last 12 months, against a 7.6% rise on the FTSE 100 as a whole. Woodford is said to be worried about future growth prospects, but it's a long time since Vodafone could be called a growth stock. It has gradually morphed into a defensive utility, and with projected earnings per share (EPS) growth of 2%, 7% and 6% over the next three years, that doesn't look likely to change. To offset this, it has been busily lining up new business, including a new contract with mining and metals company ThyssenKrupp, a five-year cyber security tie-up with BAE, and a potential £1.1 billion takeover bid for Kabel Deutschland.
I yield to Vodafone
I've held Vodafone for years, but when I heard a long-standing investor of Woodford's pedigree had cut his connection, I started to question my own loyalty. Where can a company of Vodafone's size go from here, after all? At some point, the world will be saturated with mobile phones, although we're not there yet. At that point, growth will be a struggle, especially when you're as big as Vodafone. That said, you aren't paying for growth, at a modest valuation of 10.9 times earnings. So I won't be selling. Few other investments will pay me 5.8% a year right now. That yield, which is covered 1.7 times, is 66% higher than the FTSE 100 average of 3.5%. Vodafone remains a strong core income generator for me, I can get the growth elsewhere.
If you already own shares in Vodafone, you may wish to read this in-depth exclusive report identifying another FTSE 100 favourite with a sky-high yield. This stock doesn't just give you a great income, but offers strong growth prospects as well. This special Motley Fool report calculates that the stock, which currently trades at 700p, could soon be worth 850p. To find out what it is, simply download our free guide "Power Up Your Portfolio". Don't hang about, but download it now while it is still free and available.
> Harvey owns shares in Vodafone. The Motley Fool has recommended shares in Vodafone.