How The Horsemeat Scandal Could Benefit Wm. Morrison Supermarkets Plc

Published in Company Comment on 19 February 2013

Farm-to-fork vertical integration could give Wm. Morrison Supermarkets plc (LON:MRW) an edge.

Over the last few months, Wm. Morrison Supermarkets (LSE: MRW) has been increasingly tipped as a likely prospect -- either as a value play, a recovery play, or an income play. And given its status as a defensive stock on a forecast price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 10, and a forecast yield of 4.9%, it's easy to understand why.

Putting the company's income attractions to one side, though, until recently it's been difficult to see where exactly the upside could come from.

Yes, the business is now aggressively moving into the local convenience store market, and has picked up 49 former Blockbuster stores in the last few days. But others -- such as Tesco are much further ahead. Online? Yes, Morrisons is dipping its toe into the water. But others, such as Tesco, are much further ahead. Brand extensions, such as banking, telecommunications and so on? A recent deal with Lakeland is a start -- but others, such as Tesco, are further ahead. And so on.

Farm-to-fork

The horsemeat scandal provides Morrisons with something of an opportunity, I believe. Here is an area where Morrisons, for once, is much further ahead of its rivals.

Let's start with a simple quiz. Name Britain's largest food manufacturer. And here's the rub: thanks to its firm policy of farm-to-fork vertical integration, Britain's largest food manufacturer is now... Morrisons. Formerly Britain's second-largest food manufacturer, Morrisons is now top dog.

That's right. The company owns 18 food manufacturing plants, employing 7,000 people. And that employment figure, I'd stress, excludes the people employed in Morrisons' in-store bakeries and so on. Other companies -- such as Greencore, for instance -- have more employees, but not as many located purely in the UK.

Quite simply, Morrisons buys its meat straight from the farm, sends the animals to its own abattoirs, and butchers it directly in its own stores. Critically -- and here's where some of those food manufacturing plants come in -- it also supplies its own food preparation sites with meat, in order to make its own pies, sausages, cooked meats and other products.

Vertical integration

Now, that's a very different business model from that adopted by most of its competitors. And up until the last three weeks, Morrisons has been promoting this model by extolling the benefits to farmers, better quality control, less waste and better use of resources.

But with the horsemeat scandal now breaking over even giants such as Nestlé -- which must, I reckon, have thought that it must have been immune from the risk -- fate has handed Morrisons a marketing card that its competitors can't quickly deploy for themselves.

For with its farm-to-fork supply chain, Morrisons can be more assured than most that horsemeat isn't entering its supply chain. The challenge ahead: persuading fastidious customers of upmarket outlets such as Waitrose and J Sainsbury that Morrisons should be their meat products purveyor of choice.

Upside

On a P/E that's currently a fair bit below the market average, and with movement afoot in terms of the Blockbuster and Lakeland deals, I reckon that Morrisons has probably more upside than downside. Factor in a boost from the horsemeat scandal -- assuming the business has the marketing nous to leverage it -- and that upside could be considerable.

Heck, even if Morrison's were simply to reach the FTSE 100's average P/E, that still implies a 30% uplift on today's share price.

Even so, if you're looking for a company that should soar in price, there are other juicy prospects out there. Here at The Motley Fool, for instance, we've recently pinpointed our favourite growth share for 2013, and produced a free report in which we evaluate its finances and risks, and its growth prospects going forward. Simply click here to get your copy delivered to your inbox immediately.

> Malcolm owns shares in Tesco and J. Sainsbury, but not in any other companies mentioned here. The Motley Fool owns shares in Tesco.

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

ProfessorMarcus 19 Feb 2013 , 3:56pm

Interesting stuff and similar to the Questor article in today's Telegraph.

MDW1954 19 Feb 2013 , 4:47pm

ProfessorMarcus,

For the avoidance of doubt, I should stress that this piece was pitched to TMF yesterday!

Malcolm (author)

ProfessorMarcus 19 Feb 2013 , 4:52pm

No problems, I should stress that I wasn't accusing anyone of plagiarism!

vinchainsaw 19 Feb 2013 , 6:53pm

I surmise it'll be a short-term advantage at best.

People (generally) eat meat. And people that eat tesco value meals and burgers generally do so because they cant afford anything else.

This'll pass. And its not even as if there was a health scare.

Morrisson would need to get this ad campaign running pretty sharpish if they want to take advantage of this.

UncleEbenezer 19 Feb 2013 , 8:27pm

Do you hear Morrisons' advertising shouting "no horses" from the rooftops? Me neither: it would be grand ὕβρις to take that risk just now. They are, after all, full of products from a huge range of different suppliers including some who have been found to supply horsemeat, and any of whom could be implicated in the next scandal (whatever that may be).

The media are all over this story, but when they give us a bit of vox pop the overwhelming sentiment seems to be a shrug. If you're happy to eat cow, why should horse be any different? So long as the consumer is happy with the flavour - which is in any case probably lost in these highly-processed products.

(I hate Morrisons because they play muzak, and have trolleys I can't use. But I still sometimes use them, as they're our only biggish supermarket and have things I can't get in the local shops. Sainsburys keeps applying for planning permission, so maybe one day we'll get a competitor).

jaizan 19 Feb 2013 , 9:56pm

Horse meat poses no health risk.

However, not one piece of analysis I've seen asks what other potentially poisonous ingredients may be sneaking into our food? That has to be the big question, right?
As for Morrisons, this horse story has negligible upside and a PE of 10 is not cheap enough.

SevenPillars 20 Feb 2013 , 11:16am

There is a potential recovery for Morrisons on the cards for the next 12-18 months, but I suspect that it is unlikely that the horsemeat scandal will play much of a part in it. After all, Tesco hasn't really seen a hit on its share price and it is more the providers of the products that may have more to lose, hence the large fall in Greencore's shares earlier this week. Greencore has recovered from that, but could easily be hit further if more scandal comes out.

As for Morrison, the reason why they may turn things around over the next year or so is that they are finally addressing weaknesses in the major areas of convenience stores and web presence. This is likely to interest the market more than where they get their meat from, unless the horsemeat scandal became a real health issue which is probably unlikely.

The trend, and thus market sentiment towards Morrison on the monthly chart is still negative, but looks to be leveling off. Like Tesco a couple of years back the market is now looking for Morrison to address its problems and it looks like that might be happening as can be seen in the purchase of Blockbuster stores.

vinchainsaw 20 Feb 2013 , 5:33pm

Indeed Pillars, tsco has been forging ahead this year!

Join the conversation

Please take note - some tags have changed.

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: [b]bolded text[/b], [i]italicised text[/i]. All other tags will be removed from your post.

If you want to add a link, please ensure you type it as http://www.fool.co.uk as opposed to www.fool.co.uk.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.