RBS Cuts Boss's Bonus Below £1 Million

Published in Company Comment on 27 January 2012

The taxpayer-backed bank trims its chief executive's windfall to six figures.

This week, stories about big bonuses have been like buses: they've arrived in threes.

On Tuesday, I covered Vince Cable's plans to curb excessive company pay, followed by the aborted £2.5 million payout to the chairman of FTSE 100 firm Cairn Energy (LSE: CNE).

RBS = Reducing Bonus Size

The latest news about big bonuses comes from Royal Bank of Scotland (LSE: RBS), which is 83%-owned by our government, following £45.2 billion of taxpayer-funded bailouts.

Earlier this week, the news that Stephen Hester, chief executive of RBS, was in line for a seven-figure, £1 million-plus bonus caused a predictable storm of protest from politicians. First, Prime Minister David Cameron firmly stated that Hester should not be paid a windfall exceeding £1 million.

In the House of Commons, Labour leader Ed Miliband argued that the RBS CEO should receive no bonus. This cry was also echoed in the House of Lords by Lord Oakeshott, Liberal Democrat ex-Treasury spokesman, who complained that RBS had not met its small-business lending targets under Project Merlin.

In 2011, RBS set aside six million shares to pay Hester's 2011 bonus. At Thursday's closing price of 27.7p, these would be worth more than £1.66 million. Last year, Hester banked £2 million in shares as a bonus.

However, following a meeting by RBS's remuneration committee, Hester is set to receive only 3.6 million shares. These would add just under £1 million to Hester's salary of £1.2 million.

Also speaking in the Commons, Angela Eagle (Labour MP and Shadow Commons leader) blasted the coalition government, saying, "The board of RBS is thinking of paying their [sic] chief executive in one day more than someone on average earnings would make in a lifetime." Of course, Eagle should be familiar with Hester's contract, as the previous Labour government negotiated and agreed it.

What about other bank bosses?

Then again, it is well worth putting Hester's bonus into context, given that he runs a business worth close to £16 billion.

One of Hester's direct reports, head of investment banking John Hourican, is expected to pick up £4.6 million in RBS shares from a long-term incentive scheme. Also, Bob Diamond, the boss of banking rival Barclays (LSE: BARC) is rumoured to be in line for a bonus of £10 million for his efforts in 2011, which is nearly eight times his £1.3 million salary.

In addition, Antonio Horta-Osório, CEO of Lloyds Banking Group (LSE: LLOY), has waived his entitlement to a bonus of £2.4 million, following two months of absence due to stress.

Public protests

Of course, given ongoing falls in disposable incomes, the steeply rising cost of living, and the fact that the UK economy shrank by 0.2% in the last three months of 2011, any big banking bonuses are sure to play badly with the public.

Indeed, in an online poll today at the Daily Telegraph website, over half (52%) of respondents voted for Hester to receive no bonus at all, with a further 22% recommending a bonus below £100,000. A mere 15% of Telegraph readers voted for a bonus above the million mark.

In summary, almost 4½ years since the credit crunch arrived in August 2007, Britain's anger for fat-cat bankers has yet to subside!

> Here's your free Essential Investor Kit. Over the next few weeks, you'll get share ideas, a sector report and much, much more. Don't miss out!

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

AlysonThomson 27 Jan 2012 , 12:55pm

If RBS can afford that for bonus, why don't they pay back the taxpayer?

AlysonThomson 27 Jan 2012 , 12:56pm

David Cameron was completely wrong to tell them that they had to limit his bonus to £1million.

rich02 27 Jan 2012 , 1:18pm

This should be easy: Remove your accounts from RBS and move them to a more ethical bank, if Hestor accepts his bonus.

Tykethat 27 Jan 2012 , 1:57pm

Quite simply, no bonus should be payable until the share price at least reaches 75p.

Upidee 27 Jan 2012 , 2:06pm

The shareholders (ie us, the taxpayers) need someone with talents and experience to manage our interests and let us claw back the £45.2bn. Can we find someone better than Steven Hester (or as good) without offering a bonus of almost £1m? If so, let's have that person!

Kippford 27 Jan 2012 , 2:23pm

Steven Hester is worth every penny he is paid; he did not bring RBS to the edge of ruin; he was headhunted to save it and turn it round!
He was interviewed, selected, Contracted, and is performing to Contract!
Just because the mentality of the herd in the UK is no longer what it was, and is now orchestrated and pandered to by the Media, Unions, and Politicians, does not mean that the norms of business are wrong; its that honouring of those norms is being undermined!
The Law is the Law. Labour were glad to secure Hester to help get them our of the soup! All he is doing is what is normal for a very intelligent and experienced business man; who can command a much bigger Compensation in other Democratic Societies!
When he has finished his work in a few years time, RBS will be a healthy, profitable and vigorous Company, and a valuable asset to the GDP of the UK.
The Share Price will be many times what it is now, and the British Taxpayer will make a good profit on its 83% Shareholding!
If only people were more educated as to the reality of survival in the Business world, they would be ashamed of the scapegoating of such an eminent person as Hester; who has the qualities that are needed in business; and I might add, in Politics!
More power to his elbow, keep up the good work, and please ignore the whiners, which includes the Government and Opposition, who are playing to the "masses" for votes.
Also,lets not forgetting that every Labour Government since WW2 has left the Country bankrupt at thre end of its Tenure!!!

ScottishDavie 27 Jan 2012 , 3:12pm

There was a very interesting discussion about this on BBC Radio Scotland this morning. The more sensible and less politically-motivated contributors largely accepted that Mr Hester was being paid the going rate and Kippford's point about him having been head-hunted was also made. Personally I'm completely agnostic on this issue. I've never owned RBS (other than as a taxpayer!), I don't bank with them and if Mr Hester is the right man to sort the mess, so be it. However the row shows two fairly obvious things: (1) bankers inhabit a different planet with different values, particularly when it comes to what is considered an acceptable income and (2) most ordinary people are thoroughly fed up with what they perceive to be outrageous salaries and bonuses. With due respect to Kippford, no amount of "education as to the reality of survival in the business world" is going to persuade somebody on a frozen salary of £25,000 that any banker, however capable, is worth this level of remuneration.

alanhs 27 Jan 2012 , 4:37pm

When I worked (retired now) bonuses were only paid if the company made a profit - has RBS made a profit? If so shouldn't it be using this to reducing the tax payers liability or am I too naive - anyway when Scotland declares UDI sorry independence then all the money the various Scottish Banks (RBS, BOS, Halifax) owe the British will be re-paid so all will be well!!

alanhs 27 Jan 2012 , 4:39pm

Maybe Cameron would like to cap the welfare payments rather than at the excessive £25k when most people would do this at £12k - instead he could offer RBS shares at this inflated rate Hester has been!

BarneyCowshed 27 Jan 2012 , 4:41pm

Kippford

It may well be that Mr Hester is a highly talented,motivated individual with a skill set capable of running a major organisation for which he receives an annual remuneration of £2million.

Let me introduce you to Mr B. who I met a few times.A highly talented,motivated brain surgeon with a skill set matched by only a few hundred people worldwide who receives an annual remuneration of £200k.

...and to Mrs C, a highly talented,motivated council carer who looks after 40 elderly people in her local area demonstrating a remakable skill set on a remuneration of £12k.

Kippford - It's the disparity which makes Mr Hestor's remuneration indefensible in terms of his worth - and your defence of it a homage to the 'I'm all right - sod the rest until I need them' philosophy.

longpod 27 Jan 2012 , 7:31pm

Come clean Kippford - we know you are really Mrs Hester!

ScotsKen 28 Jan 2012 , 2:04pm

Kipford, if and when the share price reaches the levels you suggest, then Mr Hester will have earned his bonus but NOT BEFORE. I would also suggest that the company should have resumed paying dividends to its shareholders.

I am one of the mugs that not only bought in at £20 per share (later converted in a 3 for 1 scrip issue) but I also fell for the call for more cash in a rights issue at a time when (it became obvious later) the management must have known the the bank was bust. I know that it is not he fault of Mr Hester hat I am nursing a large loss in what was supposed to be a safer investment than the ones I sold to make it, but so far he is doing his job (for which he is well paid) and nothing more.

hccme 28 Jan 2012 , 4:58pm

Since the RBS share price was 46p at the beginning of his year, why give him bonus at all? If he must have one on top of his salary for the job then should he not have the £900,000 in shares priced at 46p instead of 27p that they cost now.

ANuvver 30 Jan 2012 , 11:12am

Monday:

Nice to see bank CEOs waiving their bonuses, instead of waving them...

Actually, I don't see quite what remarkable skills, experience and qualities are required to slash headcount, increase capital reserves and let your teams advise you on ringfencing - all under the excuse of pressure from government and international regulation. The job's done for him. "I'm terribly sorry but my hands are tied" style of management.

Hester is simply being paid for volunteering to be unpopular.
Ask yourself this - damn the bonus shares, would you be prepared to sit in the stocks for a basic salary of £1m a year? I'd take a tomato or five in the face for that.

RobinnBanks 30 Jan 2012 , 4:33pm

'Nice to see bank CEOs waiving their bonuses, instead of waving them...' Brilliant, ANuvver!

RBS = Real Bonus Scheme
HBOS = High Bonus On Schedule
LBG = Large Bonus Guaranteed
HSBC = High Shares Bonus Coming
NR = No Refunds

What a wunch of bankers!

RobinnBanks 30 Jan 2012 , 4:39pm

BAR = Bonus Arranged Regularly

Join the conversation

Please take note - some tags have changed.

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: [b]bolded text[/b], [i]italicised text[/i]. All other tags will be removed from your post.

If you want to add a link, please ensure you type it as http://www.fool.co.uk as opposed to www.fool.co.uk.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.