Four Signs Of A Market Bottom

Published in Company Comment on 5 March 2009

Dividends are being cut across the board. There are no signs of economic recovery. There is almost universal stock market gloom. They are sure signs we're close to the bottom of the market.

1. Share prices not being hammered on bad news

This week, life insurance company and FTSE 100 constituent Old Mutual (LSE: OML) announced a plunge in profits and a scrapping of its dividend

In previous weeks and months, such results would have lead to the shares being hammered, perhaps by as much as 10% or 20%.

Old Mutual shares actually rose 11% in early trading after their results. Whist the results were poor, the market was relieved the company have said they don't need to raise extra money.

It's a sign we're close to the bottom of the market. Most of the bad news is already priced into individual share prices.

2. The shambles of an economy

You know things are bad when master investor Warren Buffett says "…the economy will be a shambles throughout 2009 – and for that matter, probably well beyond…"

In his annual letter to shareholders, Buffett was taking about the US economy, but he could have easily been talking about any economy in the world. Only China seems to have avoided recession, but even still, with the growth rate in that country having slowed considerably, it feels like they are in recession too.

Here in the UK, we've got stories of people delaying retirement, unemployment continuing to rise, the banking sector in disarray, house prices in freefall, and all this despite interest rates and mortgage rates at record lows.

Recessions are dark and scary. Even Gordon Ramsay's company is rumoured to be in trouble, for @#%*'s sake!

As individuals, we forget what a healthy economy looks like. Using our most recent experiences of the economy, we assume only bad things will continue to happen in the years ahead. We forget that recovery has followed every recession to date, and recovery will follow this one.

The market usually rises six to nine months before the economy shows signs of recovery. If you think we are going to see signs of economic recovery towards the end of this year, it's a sign we're not far away from the bottom of the market.

3. Almost universal stock market gloom

The FTSE 100 recently hit a 6-year low, at one stage dropping below 3,500. Around that time, in the article What's Next? FTSE 3,000?, I asked readers to vote in a poll, asking the question "How low can the market go?"

Of the almost 300 people who voted, almost 90% thought the market would fall at least another 10%.

50% of them thought the FTSE 100 would fall below 3,000, and 22% thought the FTSE 100 would fall below 2,500.

You can't get more downbeat that that.

This fascinating thread on the Motley Fool’s popular Paulypilot's Pub discussion board features the thoughts of some of our most respected and prolific posters.

It started off by posing the question "Is it too late to sell?" and covered thoughts about investor capitulation, widely acknowledged to happen right at the very bottom of the market, the eroding value of cash, the death of the long-term-buy-and-hold strategy, the bottoming of commodities, and some good old fashioned praying.

Perversely, it's exactly at times of universal gloom that you can be sure we are close to the bottom of the market. We may not be there yet, but I'd wager we're much closer to the bottom than to the top.

4. Shares are cheap

As I said recently, the mad market got it wrong again with BP (LSE: BP). At their recent share price of 404p, BP shares traded on a dividend yield of 9.4%.

Now I ask you…in times of ultra low-interest rates, where money deposited in a "high" interest savings account earns you around 3% interest per annum, why wouldn't you invest your money in companies like BP?

It must be fear. Fear of losing more capital, fear of a three to five year recession, fear of oil prices permanently at $30, or simply fear of fear itself.

There are no sure things in investing, and there is risk in each and every investment. BP's dividend could be cut. The oil price could languish for a considerable period of time. Gordon Brown may win the next election. They are all risks.

But the shares of BP, and countless other companies, including smaller companies like IG Group (LSE: IGG), RPS Group (LSE: RPS), Consort Medical (LSE: CSRT), London Capital (LSE: LCG) and Chloride Group (LSE: CHLD) appear cheap.

And as well all know, buying cheap and selling dear is what stock market investing is all about! Cheap shares are other sign we’re close to the bottom of the market.

Our Chief Analyst Maynard Paton is seeing great opportunity amongst the economic and stock market chaos. Check out his very latest share recommendations by taking out a free 30-day trial to The Motley Fool's Champion Shares premium stock picking service. Click here for more details, including his very latest column, Four Shares Beating The Crunch.

More on the economy and the markets:

> The Motley Fool's Share Dealing Service remains open for business whatever the FTSE 100. Even better, it's free, cheap and reliable. Buy and sell shares in real time for a flat rate of just £10. Open an account for free today

> Bruce Jackson does not have an interest in any of the companies mentioned in this article.

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

tenuirostris 05 Mar 2009 , 10:03am

'I'd wager we're much closer to the bottom than to the top.' eh?

Well I wouldn't disagree with this but it is a particularly safe bet since the FTSE100, for example, is about half way from its past peak to ....zero!

lotontech 05 Mar 2009 , 12:37pm

These may well be signs that the market is bottoming, on the basis that it is behaving irrationally.

But as one famous investor said:
"The market can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent!"

And when researching for a book, I discovered that simple company fundamentals -- like an apparently high dividend yield -- can be very misleading and not necessarily indicative of future performance.

Maybe the 'odds' are now stacked in our favour, but they are only 'odds' and not certainties. Fortune favors the brave, but I've learnt from bitter experience not to bet the farm.

mmepani 05 Mar 2009 , 1:18pm

lol, people still trying to call a bottom.

One of these days we will reach it - I'll guarantee to you that on that day some egos will be the size of the planet.

fujirobin 05 Mar 2009 , 1:43pm

As useful and inspired as the Racing Post saying "this horse should win". Applying past pattern-recognition to a new situation is a particularly human trait - you can see patterns or Jesus' face in burnt toast - but it doesn't make it correct.

Smiley61 05 Mar 2009 , 6:43pm

If you don't think you can pick a winner, pick the whole field!

Some of the horses might fall, but those that finish will give you a return.

My favoured approach is a good looking equity income fund invested in companies with good cash flow for 2009, So...

How about the Edinburgh Investement Trust. Look at the investments....

Portfolio Breakdown Largest holdings %

BP 7.9%
GLAXOSMITHKLINE 7.8%
BRITISH ENERGY GROUP 6.9%
VODAFONE GROUP 6.4%
BRITISH AMERICAN TOBACCO 6.1%
ASTRAZENECA PLC 6.0%
BG GROUP 5.3%
IMPERIAL TOBACCO GROUP 5.2%
NATIONAL GRID 5.2%
BT GROUP 5.0%

Total 61.8%

The yield is about 6.8% at today's price and even if some of the dividends go by the wayside it should provide a healthy yield without exposure to the banks and insurers.

Its also a good recovery play. Expect the more robust companies to be re-rated first.

By the way, its managed by Neil Woodford

Phlopp 06 Mar 2009 , 7:37am

NO, NO, NO! remember what that nice Mr Wilson did to us. 15% inflation. We've got another dose coming around the corner. We have a SOCIALIST govt. so they don't care about the private saver. They have announced they're about to print money so as REAL interest rates soar, and your mortgage costs 15% then is the time to think about recovery. Until then it's GOLD, GOLD GOLD!

supasap 06 Mar 2009 , 10:16am

Call this government socialist? When have they ever suggested socialising the means of production, after all they were reluctant to nationalise Northern Rock and as for RSB et al they, like the USA, nationalise through the back door just to avoid the term nationalisation. As for Mandelson, Brown, Darling and co it's a case of workers of the world unite you have nothing to lose but your chains ... and err index linked pensions, seats in the Lords, cash cow biographies and chat show appearances.....

Varlic 06 Mar 2009 , 11:39am

Where I am, the sun is shining, the daffodils are coming out of the ground, and that dratted squirrel is stealing all the nuts in the birdfeeder again. I'm ready for some green shoots.

Sexagenarian 06 Mar 2009 , 11:49am

This government is nothing like socialist.

Reducing the interest rate to zero still won't work. Rate cuts were effective only to about three percent, and that was questionable. Cuts below that will have no further effect.

QE? It will all end in tears and stagflation.

Wilson gave us 15% inflation? I thought it was more under Silly Billy.

The "correction" has to happen. Prices have to come down after the insane bubble of the last ten years. There's no way governments can prevent it now. They don't want to stand by and do nothing. They did for all those years when it was going wrong. Too late now.


PRMARJORAM 06 Mar 2009 , 12:03pm

For those investing through a stocks and shares index tracker( so loved by the Fool) long term, is this not the time that the Fool told us we should be clapping as we see the index fall lower and lower?
Should we not be buying up all we can each month as it remains this low?

jdbgilbert 06 Mar 2009 , 12:15pm

Hi,

Regarding #1, did you write this before or after Aviva's share price was trashed yesterday! I think the market is still reacting to bad news.

Luniversal 07 Mar 2009 , 9:42am

Yes, Old Mutual may have taken a dividend cut in its stride, but the far larger Aviva (Britain's #1) reacted in horror to a dividend INCREASE.

Bruce is trying to talk up a bull correction, and good luck to him; but on considerations such as historic earnings multiples, dividend prospects (especially if sterling bounces back somewhat, given the quantum of foreign earnings in UK company results), fears of hyperinflation instead of/after deflation, fears of further financial sector toxic meltdowns, fears of higher taxes to pay for it all... it's hard to argue that ALL the bad news is in ALL the prices on the LSE.

I know this is what worrywarts always say at what proves to be the cyclical nadir of the market, and I think there are still a few bombproof high-yielders that look great value compared with 0% interest on cash... but instead of filling my boots with blue chips, I'd rather miss the first 10% of the Great Jackson Bounce and sleep easy.

Hell, the proximate cause of Aviva's terrors is the shonkiness of corporate bond values and insurance thereon-- and bonds are supposed to lead equities back up.

MrHankie 11 Mar 2009 , 12:27pm

Re: Point 1
"Share prices not being hammered on bad news"

What nonsense. John Humphries on the Today programme makes a joke of being able to predict share movements based on results. Good results = shares down, bad results = shares up

Join the conversation

Please take note - some tags have changed.

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: [b]bolded text[/b], [i]italicised text[/i]. All other tags will be removed from your post.

If you want to add a link, please ensure you type it as http://www.fool.co.uk as opposed to www.fool.co.uk.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.