Could The Euro Be Saved On Thursday?

Published in Investing on 31 July 2012

Is this the full-blown, save-the-single-currency moment we have been waiting for?

Albert Einstein's definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results. In that case, stock markets are insane.

Because every time the European Central Bank (also insane) serves up another half-baked rescue package, markets greet it like a gourmet meal and crack open the champagne.

It has happened over and over again, with exactly the same result. The bailout tastes nourishing at the time, but quickly leads to yet more bellyache.

Have markets learned anything? Judging by the joyous reaction to ECB President Mario Draghi's pledge last Thursday to do "whatever it takes" to save the euro, they're still as crazy as a soup sandwich.

Euro saved!

Markets greeted Draghi's boast "believe me, it will be enough" as a cast-iron pledge that the ECB was finally going to unleash its big bazooka and blow the eurozone crisis (and German resistance) away.

By Friday, markets were acting as if he had ordered full-blown quantitative easing, interest rate cuts, long-term loans and unlimited purchases of Spanish and Italian bonds on the secondary market, all on German Chancellor Angela Merkel's tab.

My shares in Aviva (LSE: AV), one of the many financial services companies exposed to a single currency slam dunk, are up 11% since his stirring declaration. Spanish and Italian bond yields fell.

As I said, insane. Because Draghi didn't promise any of these things.

Nobody asked the Germans

And how could he? By all reports, he hasn't agreed any of these things. Or rather, he hasn't agreed them with the Germans.

What sceptics read as yet another a bland catch-all assurance, markets saw as something different. In their crazy way, they reacted as if he had promised full-on fiscal union and free eurobonds for all.

Draghi's remarks were clearly designed to push the Germans in that direction, but that's a very different thing to persuading them.

Markets are even dappy enough to get excited by Chancellor Merkel's plea for all EU institutions to "fulfill their duties", whatever that means.

Are they desperate for good news, or plain loopy?

Black September

All eyes are now on the ECB policy makers meeting on Thursday. Could this be the full-blown, save-the-single-currency moment we have been waiting for?

If it is, the FTSE 100 could top 6000 within days. If it isn't, and Draghi is exposed to be full of bluff and bluster, the disappointment will be crushing. It could even force the single currency into a death spiral.

Some claim funeral could be as early as September.

Don't get pally with that rally

Draghi has talked the talk, now he has to walk the walk. Which won't be easy, with the Germans trying to trip him up.

Judging by past events, he will give markets something to chew on, maybe a bit more bond buying, or cheap cash for banks, and trigger the world's shortest ever relief rally, followed by the mother of all disappointment dips.

Wise Fools will avoid getting sucked into that rally, and buying shares in their favourite companies at inflated prices.

You should only take any surge at face value if Chancellor Merkel and the Bundesbank happily agree to pay for everything, cheered on by grateful German voters.

Now that would be insane.

Thursday, Thursday

Thursday is being billed as the last chance to save the euro. There will no doubt be other "last chances" over the next few months. Personally, I think the single currency is doomed. Only full-blown fiscal union can save it, and the Germans aren't daft enough to put that on their slate.

Whatever happens, my investment strategy will remain the same. Cash is poor. Bonds are overpriced. Gold is too speculative. Solid, cash-rich, blue-chips paying steady dividends are still the way to go. I'm thinking Aviva, SSE (LSE: SSE), BAE Systems (LSE: BA), National Grid (LSE: NG), Vodafone (LSE: VOD), Standard Life (LSE: SL), J Sainsbury (LSE: SBRY) and Admiral Group (LSE: ADM).

All of these yield above 5%, far more than you will get on any savings account. Aviva yields nearly 9%. Their share prices may remain turbulent, but the dividends should keep rolling in, whatever happens on Thursday.

Where is the UK's leading dividend stock-picker investing today? The identities of Neil Woodford's favourite blue chips are revealed in this free Motley Fool report -- "8 Shares Held By Britain's Super Investor".

Further Motley Fool investment opportunities:

> Harvey owns shares in Aviva and Vodafone. He doesn't own anything else mentioned in this article.

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

rober00 31 Jul 2012 , 5:01pm

Harvey, Harvey you should know by now that markets are NEVER RATIONAL!!! So why do you expect them to be.

After all it is that very irrationality that leads to the opportunities they constantly present.

Long may it be so.

F958B 31 Jul 2012 , 5:11pm

I would be delighted to see something truly positive come out of it though - so that the currently-collapsinbg global economy has a chance to get back to something resembling normality.

But I think they'll leave something not properly covered, or use this as an opportunity to kick the can down the road once more - allowing them to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory at some point in a few months time.
I expect Thursday's response to be a Euro too little and a day too late, and to be subsequently watered-down by future political bickering among nations when it comes to finalising the details.

But as I said at the beginning; I would be ecstatic if they really mean business; I'm longing for an end to the uncertainty and I think that an end to Euro uncertainty would see the global economy start to recover surprisingly strongly once business and consumers feel less worried about the ever-present risk of imminent financial collapse.

ANuvver 31 Jul 2012 , 6:04pm

The currency that is immediately at stake seems to be Draghi's reputation. He's pointedly put the ECB's credibility on the line, so heaven help us if he's not in a position to announce at least a viable plan.

Brave words indeed. Especially from a central banker.

Spain has played the role of perfect pupil to the EU's stern disciplinarian, so if there's insufficient quid pro quo forthcoming it's all shot, to the serious detriment of all concerned - very much including Germany.

If only there's a spectacular announcement that CERN have discovered a way of using the Higgs Boson as a catalyst to convert debt into a revolutionary new clean energy source. I'm not expecting a miracle but some interesting concessions on policy may well be on the cards. Given Geithner's very visible involvement and the Fed sharing the billing on Thursday, we're in for a very interesting day. Oh, for a crystal ball...

Back2Value 01 Aug 2012 , 2:56am

Who wrote this ? Lee Child? Or a Sun leader writer. Talk about short paragraphs. And sentences. Wow.

Jonesey12 01 Aug 2012 , 6:51am

I know Roberoo. I should have learned.
ANuvver. Fully agree. I can't see how Draghi can deliver on his boast. Thursday will be interesting.
Back2Value. Sorry. Sentences clearly too. Short. Full apology. Will. Write. Longer. Sentences. Next. Time. ;)

DirtyDollie 01 Aug 2012 , 10:58am

At the end of the article is the usual disclaimer:
"Harvey owns shares in Aviva and Vodafone. He doesn't own anything else mentioned in this article."

But earlier in the article:
"Cash is poor."

You don't own any cash at all?! Harvey, you can't buy food with shares! Maybe think about keeping a tenner or so as working capital.

SevenPillars 01 Aug 2012 , 12:17pm

What do the markets actually want?

Full blown reflation of the system?

Full guarantees for the debtors?

Germany to carry the load?

Full financial integration?

Whatever they want, they want it quickly, because markets like a quick resolution to perceived problems. The reality is that there is no quick resolution to the debt problems built up over the last 20-30 years.

The quickest is probably default, countries leaving the euro and possibly eurozone, who would then reflate, print money like there's no tomorrow, devalue their new currency, etc.

Markets would tank on such a scenario.

The UK would be hit hard by the latter scenario. A report today suggests that Britain would suffer the worst of a euro breakup and would need £1 trillion further QE.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/financialcrisis/9441120/Eurozone-break-up-would-trigger-1-trillion-of-QE-see-banks-nationalised-and-deep-recession-warns-Fathom.html

So, for all those that want to see the euro fail, the grass on the other side is not necessarily as green as you might believe it to be.

Jonesey12 01 Aug 2012 , 3:04pm

DirtyDollie. Yes, I do own cash. Although not enough of it, sadly.

Harvey Jones

Jonesey12 01 Aug 2012 , 3:04pm

SevenPillars, I fear you may be right.

Harvey J

ANuvver 02 Aug 2012 , 2:02pm

13:57 on Thursday:

Pathetic, mealy-mouthed back-tracking performance.
Heads down, people.

But that's Europe these days - an Italian banker and a German pope.

ANuvver 02 Aug 2012 , 2:16pm

German foot on his throat, it seems, and he's visibly squirming.
Arrividerci credibility.

ANuvver 02 Aug 2012 , 2:31pm

His backstop seems to be a blunt reiteration of "the euro is irreversible".
I rather agree - it was designed as a suicide pact.

Sorry for the multiple posts - I don't do tweets or any of that rubbish.

jaizan 02 Aug 2012 , 10:59pm

All these articles miss the point that the Euro is doomed to EVENTUAL failure.

Even if club med tries to deflate its way back to competitiveness or Germany starts to directly subsidise them, that's unlikely to last in the long term.

Even political union would eventually fail.

Join the conversation

Please take note - some tags have changed.

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: [b]bolded text[/b], [i]italicised text[/i]. All other tags will be removed from your post.

If you want to add a link, please ensure you type it as http://www.fool.co.uk as opposed to www.fool.co.uk.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.