A Solution To The Annuity Rate Nightmare

Published in Investing on 4 July 2012

The financial crisis has a real human cost.

The last four years have been a disaster for anybody buying an annuity. In July 2008, a 65-year-old man buying a level annuity with a £100,000 pension pot could have bought £7,855 income a year. Today, he would get just £5,743, an incredible £2,112 a year less, according to Hargreaves Lansdown (LSE: HL).

Once you have bought an annuity, you are stuck with it for life. If our unhappy pensioner lived another 20 years, he would have lost £40,240 in total.

To make matters worse, his pension pot is likely to be smaller, because of the hammering handed out to equities. The financial crisis has a real human cost.

How low can you go?

Tumbling annuity rates are largely down to the Bank of England (BofE)'s Weimar-esque policy of printing its way out of the financial mess we are in. On Thursday it is expected to dash off another £50 billion, on top of the £325 billion it has already printed, equivalent to roughly 20% of the UK's annual GDP.

Every time the BofW prints more virtual money to buy gilts, it forces down gilt yields, and those lower yields are quickly reflected in annuity rates.

With some pundits predicting quantitative easing (QE) will top £500 billion in total, things can only get worse.

Quantitative, not quality

So far, more than one million pensioners have been quantitatively eased into a poor standard of living. In its defence, the Bank of England claims QE has protected pension pots, by propping up asset prices.

The truth is, nobody knows what would have happened without QE. The BofE suggests the alternative would have been economic ruin, but it has failed to produce any evidence that virtual money printing has boosted growth and employment in the real world.

One thing is certain. It has punished thrifty savers to bailout spendthrift borrowers, profligate politicians and greedy, shameless bankers.

Annuity nightmare II

Anybody approaching retirement now faces a miserable choice. Should they buy an annuity at today's rotten rates, or delay in the hope they recover?

Those who postponed their purchase over the last few years will have regretted it, as rates have been driven lower and lower. And the trend looks set to continue, thanks to a combination of continuing QE and forthcoming regulatory changes.

The European Solvency II directive, to be implemented in November, will force annuity companies to hold more capital in reserve to guard against financial shocks, forcing rates even lower.

And in December, the EU will make it illegal to offer different annuity rates based on gender. Currently, men get better rates than women, because they typically don't live as long. In future, rates will be equalised. Men will get a worse deal, while women will only see a small improvement.

When you throw in rising life expectancy as well, there is little prospect of a great annuity rate revival.

Divide and rule

If you're approaching retirement, there are some things you can do to mitigate the pain. You don't have to commit all of your pension pot to an annuity.

You could convert, say, half of your pot into income drawdown, and leave the rest invested for income. That way you will reap the benefits when markets finally recover.

You can then use the rest of your pot to buy an annuity. Or rather, two annuities.

You could spend half the money on a level annuity, to get the best possible income now, and the remainder on a rising annuity, to ensure your income keeps pace with price rises. Because at some point, all this money printing will surely end in inflation.

Remember, you can also take 25% of your pension asset tax-free lump sum.

A Foolish dividend

If you are a wise Fool, you will have another trick up your sleeve. You will have used your ISA allowance to build a portfolio of tax-efficient income-generating shares.

If you've done that, you won't be completely skewed by falling annuity rates. My own portfolio includes Aviva (LSE: AV), which currently yields 9.1%, Vodafone (LSE: VOD) yielding at 5.3%, GlaxoSmithKline (LSE: GSK) at 4.9% and Royal Dutch Shell (LSE: RDSB) at 4.8%.

Other top FTSE 100 (UKX) dividend-paying stocks include BAE Systems (LSE: BAE) yielding at 6.5%, Standard Life (LSE: SL) at 5.9%, National Grid (LSE: NG) at 5.7% and Sainsbury's (LSE: SBRY) at 5.2%.

Better still, all of these have substantial scope for capital growth, when the economy finally recovers.

These are dismal times for anybody relying on an annuity for all of their retirement income. If you are holding dividend-friendly blue-chips as well, life looks a bit more cheerful.

Investing is by no means easy in today's uncertain economy. That's why we've published "Top Sectors Of 2012" -- our guide to three favourable industries. This free report will be dispatched immediately to your inbox.

Further investment opportunities:

> Harvey owns shares in Aviva, Vodafone, GlaxoSmithKline and Royal Dutch Shell. He doesn't directly own any other stocks mentioned in this article. The Motley Fool owns shares in Hargreaves Lansdown.

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

goodlifer 04 Jul 2012 , 8:53pm

I've never invested in a SIPP, or anything else that might commit me to buying an annuity.

Advocates of SIPPs get a lovely glow from saving all that tax, and seem to assume, rather blithely, that everything's going to be OK.

Maybe I've missed something, but I've never heard of a happy, newly fledged annuitant.

Do such animals exist?

If so, it might helpful if they could tell us the best way to go about it.

OxonianCambion 04 Jul 2012 , 9:16pm

Don't forget the large Gilt fraction of the 65 year olds' portfolio has massively increased in capital value. Don't blame low Gilt yields for not paying enough in.

Oh don't forget he has won the house price lottery...

taken2often 05 Jul 2012 , 1:05pm

If you are unlikely to pay in more than 100k over a 40 year period then the tax relief would be worth giving up and you may be better with an ISA. If more, then a SIPP may be better with the right investment plan.

A big mistake is forgetting what a pension is for. Income for life. Taking the 25% tax free lump sum unless used to pay debt or fund an ISA is a realy bad idea.

Buying an annuity is even worse unless you have very poor income from your fund.

I have three SIPPs all are earning more each year than I am allowed to draw, but thats another story.

One Sipps details. Period 7 years
Annual IncomeYield on original cost 11.25%
Annual Income Yield on to-days value 7.5%
Average gain from original cost to to-days value 7%

Although the portfolio is in profit by a very modest 2% Some Shares and PIBS which are showing losses are still making a substantial contribution of income. As I will not sell shares to get the 25% or to buy an annuity I dont care whether the market is up or down, only a dividend stopped is important.
With dividend growth shares my income will increase each year hopefully keeping up with inflation.

Buy an annuity and in 20 years it will have very poor purchasing power.

Hope this helps somebody

Cheers

Davidthebard 16 Jul 2012 , 10:12am

For those of us unfortunate enough to have been prudent, we are forced to buy an annuity. What we should be offered at this time is the ability to put our pensions into whatever is the best option, such as investing in the top share dividend companies like Aviva. It would have been better for those in ELAS to have been able to do that 10 years ago. But no, we have to get properly screwed.

DtB

Join the conversation

Please take note - some tags have changed.

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: [b]bolded text[/b], [i]italicised text[/i]. All other tags will be removed from your post.

If you want to add a link, please ensure you type it as http://www.fool.co.uk as opposed to www.fool.co.uk.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.