The Art Of Very High-Risk Investing

Published in Investing on 14 February 2012

If you play with fire, prepare to be burned every once in a while.

All investments are risky, but some far more risky than others. There's a world of difference between buying shares in Foreign & Colonial Investment Trust (LSE: FRCL) and a small oil company that has bet the farm on a single well being drilled off the Falkland Islands.

Since Foreign & Colonial owns shares in more than 600 companies all over the world, its share price will closely reflect how the world's stock markets perform. But the oil company's share price could easily double or fall by more than 50% depending upon the drilling result.

That comes with the territory. The nature of some companies' businesses means that they offer massive potential returns with a fairly large chance that you could be wiped out.

Black gold

One of my favourite sectors is oil, specifically small oil exploration companies that are drilling for oil. That's because a decent discovery can totally transform a small company's prospects but will have little effect upon a supermajor like Royal Dutch Shell (LSE: RDSB).

Over the years I've owned several oilers whose shares have increased by more than 1,000%, such as Dragon Oil (LSE: DGO), Northern Petroleum (LSE: NOP) and Fool favourite Soco International (LSE: SIA).

But I've also had my fair share of horrors, like Frontera Resources (LSE: FRR) and Nighthawk Energy (LSE: HAWK), whose share prices collapsed when things didn't turn out as expected. The oil sector contains a surprisingly large number of companies whose shares are 90% or more off their peak, and occasionally you'll see one collapse when it runs out of cash before finding anything.

By investing in these sorts of companies, you're playing with fire -- so you have to expect to be burned now and again. Don't invest more than you can afford to lose.

Be a venture capitalist

I treat these investments as if I was a venture capitalist. So I expect the majority to do badly but for the winners to do so well that their gains will more than compensate for the inevitable losses.

My philosophy is that some of these investments are such high risk that I mentally write off 100% of the investment when I make them. So far, I'm well up by using this strategy, though I've cut back on this part of my portfolio during the last few years.

Sometimes it can feel like putting £50 on a 200-1 shot in the big race. The odds are firmly against you, but if it works out as you hope then the payoff will be massive.

An Xciting ride

One of my recent successes was with the Canadian company Xcite Energy (LSE: XEL), which is developing the Bentley oil field in the North Sea and whose share price is currently 105p. You could have picked up Xcite's shares for just over 3p in January 2009 and barely two years later they hit 390p. Fortunes have been made, and lost, in Xcite.

I was in and out of Xcite in about six months, making a profit of about 250% in the process after doing something that I rarely do, setting a price target at which to sell and then sticking to it. You're never going to see that sort of return if you restrict yourself to huge companies like Diageo (LSE: DGE) and Unilever (LSE: ULVR), but they do make it easier to sleep at night!

My Xcite investment was a relatively small part of my overall portfolio, so if its shares had fallen to nothing it wouldn't have damaged my portfolio to any great extent. This is not the sort of thing in which to invest your life's savings, though if you're young with a steady job, few commitments and a few thousand pounds to invest, then this strategy is worth considering.

It's how I started off. One of my first investments was putting several months' salary (about 80% of my portfolio at the time) into Amstrad shares in the mid-1980s.

Why so volatile?

Shares in companies like Xcite are very volatile because they depend upon a single asset whose value is rather uncertain, to put it mildly. The share prices of small information technology companies are prone to behaving similarly, mostly because of investors' concerns as to whether their technology is better or worse than that of their competitors.

Plenty of these companies came and went during the dotcom boom of the late 1990s. One of the earliest social networking websites, theGlobe.com, was valued at almost $850 million on the day it went public. Two years later its shares had fallen by over 95% as the market gradually woke up to the fact that it wasn't going to make any money.

In Xcite's case, the concern is whether Bentley can be commercially developed. In the first few months of 2011 the consensus was that it would be extremely profitable, so Xcite's shares had risen almost eightfold in 12 months. Now the outlook is much less certain, particularly after Xcite filed a material change report in May that cast doubts over the project.

Be prepared

Of course, whether you're prepared to invest in the sort of company whose share price could fall by 90% overnight is highly dependent upon your personal circumstances, net worth and your attitude to risk.

Funds that invest in countries that are in turmoil might be worth considering as a punt because if their situation ever improves, this should lead to a re-rating of their stock markets. Top of my list for this would be Pakistan (civil war, corruption, terrorism) followed by Russia (institutionally corrupt), though I don't touch Russia nowadays having had a nasty experience several years ago.

Apart from oil, the next best sector for companies whose shares could multiply several times or collapse rather quickly is mining. But not the big miners like BHP Billiton (LSE: BLT); you've got to look at the small companies that have projects that they're still trying to develop.

You might pick up a life-changing bargain, or lose your shirt in the process!

> Get the latest on investing and the markets from the desk of David Kuo -- join The Motley Fool Collective today.

More from Tony Luckett:

> Tony owns shares in BHP Billiton, Diageo, Dragon Oil, Soco International and Unilever. The Motley Fool owns shares in BHP Billiton and Unilever.

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

MrWolfbag 14 Feb 2012 , 2:59pm

You are describing gambling rather than investing.

TonyTwoTimes 14 Feb 2012 , 3:34pm

Hi Mr. Wolfbag,

It's not gambling; it's the same strategy as what the venture capitalists use. They buy a basket of plausible but high-risk investments with the expectation that the winners more than cover the losers.

If you do it for your entire portfolio then it is gambling. I put a limit of no more than 10% of my portfolio to be invested using this strategy (about ten years ago it was closer to 50%).

Without it I'd have never gone near investments like Dragon Oil, which are now worth about 45 times what I paid for them almost ten years ago.

Cheers,

TonyL

15551 14 Feb 2012 , 4:20pm

I would have to agree with Mr Wolfbag on this one. You're gambling with 10% of your portfoilio and there is nothing wrong with that provided that you are comfortable with the risk - and you seem to be. If it makes you money then all well and good. I'd be interested to hear how you go about selecting the small companies, as the information on them is so limited.

psatek 14 Feb 2012 , 4:33pm

"Eightfold times" that's some serious tautology going on there.

Lexeyeplural 14 Feb 2012 , 5:28pm

Interesting article. I nearly got burned with Desire Petrolium last year. Since then and after becoming a TMF convert I've decided to take another look at my investing strategy and follow the HYP method. I did have most of my SIPP in dodgy AIM stocks hoping for big gains but have decided to slowly pull money out of the risky shares and buy blue chips with decent yeilds as and when they're appealing. I still have about 90% of my SIPP in one AIM company - Monitise however I'm very confident MONI and if it does go horribly wrong I can start again as I'm a relatively young Fool at 29. I think in 10 years though I'll be doing as Tony and only have around 10% is speculative high risk shares.

TonyTwoTimes 14 Feb 2012 , 6:11pm

Hi 15551,

The best sector for this type of investing is oil and gas because of the nature of the business. A decent discovery can literally put a rocket under a small company’s share price.

Not finding oil wrecks the share price (look at Aminex for this).

Get the names of companies from trawling the sector categories (Stock Exchange website under Oil & Gas).

The oil and gas shares board here on TMF is a treasure trove of names and information.
http://boards.fool.co.uk/oil-gas-companies-50029.aspx

There’s no substitute for reading the most recent annual report as it gives you an idea as to what the company is doing, what it has already found, how much cash it has to fund its drilling, etc.

Oil and gas reserves are not valued in the balance sheet – they appear under “intangible assets” are what was spent to find them, not what they are worth.

In Dragon Oil’s case, unlike most small explorers it had already found a huge amount of oil (well over 600 million barrels of reserves). It acquired the concession to extract oil from a couple of Soviet Union-era oilfields which had been very badly run.

Currently my really speculative stuff is only about 5% of the portfolio (3 oils = Faroe Petroleum, WesternZagros Resources and Sterling Resources plus iRobot Corporation which as its name suggests isn’t an oil company).

For people who prefer small mining companies the mining shares board is a good place to start (I’m hopeless when it comes to small miners, which is why I generally avoid them!)
http://boards.fool.co.uk/mining-sector-50030.aspx

Cheers,

TonyL

fergus14 14 Feb 2012 , 9:20pm

Gambling is a zero sum process involving random outcome generators, it is a process that rearranges existing wealth.

Venture capital speculation also rearranges ownership of existing wealth, but is also capable of creating new wealth.

Resource stocks have an "exploration cycle" and the amount of risk is dependant on what stage it is at in that cycle.

These stocks are quite volitile and you should not only have an understanding of the company, but also of the resource sector in general.

ram59 15 Feb 2012 , 4:56pm

Tony never mind the art of very high-risk investing, how about living with the picks of an exIFA that are of that ilk.

Fortunately I was able to reduce my tax liability in 2010/11 as 1 of my exIFA picks went belly up & another I sold more or less on it's year high before it went pear shaped. But still a large loss on original investment with commission.

There is at least another for 2011/12 so need to earn plenty between now & April.

Mind you I have learned much by holding these excessively risky investments.
Skin in the game.

TonyTwoTimes 15 Feb 2012 , 5:45pm

Hi ram59,

Ouch! Sorry to hear about that, but as you've said it's a small consolation that you could offset the losses,

It's an unfortunate fact of life in investment, as in many walks of life, that we learn far more from our losses than our successes.

Cheers,

TonyL

Accountant007 16 Feb 2012 , 3:21pm

Hi Tony,

Its funny you said Pakistan because I am originally from Pakistan and I have been waiting for ages for 'Imran Khan' to come into power. He is becoming more and more popular now. Elections are early next year and he is expected to get something and if he does, it will most likely be a very positive turning point for Pakistan.

Which funds do you think are good for Pakistan, sorry never invested in Funds before.

Thanks

TonyTwoTimes 16 Feb 2012 , 5:35pm

Hi Accountant007,

Yes, Imran Khan is definitely stirring things up for the good.

As to funds, I haven't come across anything specific to Pakistan though I've started looking (a few investment trusts like Templeton Emerging Markets do have some investments in Pakistan)

One company that has a lot of interests in Pakistan is the oil company Premier Oil (LSE: PMO).

Good luck!

TonyL

Join the conversation

Please take note - some tags have changed.

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: [b]bolded text[/b], [i]italicised text[/i]. All other tags will be removed from your post.

If you want to add a link, please ensure you type it as http://www.fool.co.uk as opposed to www.fool.co.uk.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.