Big Losers From The Big Squeeze

Published in Investing on 12 April 2011

With the biggest strain on consumer spending since 1921, which firms will be hit hardest?

According to a report released on Monday by economics consultancy the Centre for Economics and Business Research (CEBR), UK disposable incomes are under the greatest pressure for 90 years.

The big squeeze

The CEBR warns that 2010/11 will see the biggest fall in real household disposable incomes since 1921. The forecaster predicts that 'real' (after-inflation) household disposable income will fall 2% in 2011, on top of a 0.8% fall in 2010.

This is based on the CEBR's estimates for inflation of 3.9% in 2011, which would be the highest increase in the cost of living since 1992. At 1.9%, earnings growth will be much weaker, thanks to unemployment remaining high.

The last time we Brits saw our disposable incomes squeezed nearly so hard was in 1976/77, when real incomes fell 2.7% over two years.

Indeed, this latest fall will be even greater than the infamous squeeze seen in the Great Depression of the Thirties. However, the CEBR has excluded the drops in income caused by World War II (1939-45) and the General Strike of 1926.

A 'perfect storm' hits the high street

Thus, the CEBR estimates that UK households will have £27.3 billion less spending power in 2011 than in 2009 -- a decrease of £910 per dwelling.

Thanks to this spending squeeze, together with the government's austerity programme for public spending, the CEBR has reduced its forecast for UK gross domestic product (GDP) growth. At 1%, it is well below the 1.7% rise predicted by the independent Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) in last month's Budget.

Going 'ex-growth'

With consumer spending set to shrink by 0.8% in 2011 (and remain weak for a further two years), many businesses will be hit hard when the 'growth punchbowl' goes away.

We've already seen evidence of this happening, of course. Many retailers have warned on profits in recent weeks and the British Retail Consortium said March retail sales saw the biggest monthly fall since it started collecting data in the mid 1990s. 

With such a large sum being removed from wallets and purses, my view is that consumers will focus on must-have purchases, rather than nice-to-have treats. In other words, spending on big-ticket items and top-end or impulse purchases is likely to be under most pressure.

Hence, the biggest losers are likely to be those companies who operate on low margins and have grown accustomed to their revenues and profits being boosted by rising consumer spending.

Any search for such 'at risk' companies should certainly include filters for falling sales, weakening cash flow, reduced margins, and high levels of debt and operational gearing. Firms in such poor shape are least likely to get through the next 24 months unscathed.

Who will be hit hardest?

Given that discretionary spending will be hit hard, I reckon that companies providing treats, luxuries and indulgences will suffer most. By this, I don't mean chocolates and the odd trip to the cinema, so Thorntons (LSE: THT) and Cineworld (LSE: CINE) should fare reasonably well.

However, I think that highly indebted nightclub operator Luminar (LSE: LMR) will continue to struggle, thanks to lower consumer spending and rising unemployment among young clubbers. Likewise, highly geared pub groups such as Punch Taverns (LSE: PUB) could see cash-flow dive as punters stay away.

I suspect that things could get difficult on dealer forecourts, too. On an annual basis, new-car sales fell 8% last month, largely because of the scrapping of the £2,000 scrappage incentive in March 2010. Hence, car dealers could wobble, hitting the shares of such firms as Pendragon (LSE: PDG), Lookers (LSE: LOOK) and Vertu Motors (LSE: VTU).

Things could turn nastier on the high street, too. If consumers do start to defer or abandon home improvements, then sales could slide further at the likes of Carpetright (LSE: CPR), Homebase owner Home Retail Group (LSE: HOME), B&Q owner Kingfisher (LSE: KGF) and floor-coverings firm Topps Tiles (LSE: TPT).

Also, consumers aren't going to be jetting off on holidays and short breaks if they're worried about hanging onto their jobs and paying basic bills. Hence, sales could slip for travel firms and airlines, hitting shares in cruise operator Carnival (LSE: CCL), International Consolidated Airlines Group (LSE: IAG) (formerly BA and Iberia), and tour operator TUI Travel (LSE: TUI).

On the flipside

In my view, companies dealing with high-net-worth individuals -- for instance, luxury-goods manufacturers and high-end car dealers -- will largely avoid the worst effects of this sustained squeeze.

After all, when your wealth is measured in seven, eight or more figures, losing thousands here and there isn't going to curb your desires. This should be of comfort to the likes of Burberry (LSE: BRBY) and France's LVMH, whose sales in emerging markets are storming ahead.

Similarly, commodity producers (those producing oil, metals, cotton, energy and other essential supplies) should do well as prices of these products surge. So, look to oil supermajors such as BP (LSE: BP) and Royal Dutch Shell (LSE: RDSB) and global mega-miners to do well during this squeeze.

Likewise, defensive industries -- such as pharmaceuticals, utilities, and the very biggest retailers such as Tesco (LSE: TSCO) -- could be set for another day in the sun. One test of the resilience of these companies should be their bumper dividends, such as these Billion-Pound Dividend Payers.

Also, the CEBR reckons that the sector with the strongest growth is likely to be business spending on IT, which could boost the likes of FTSE 100 software firm Autonomy (LSE: AU).

What about banks?

Finally, the Office for Budget Responsibility reckons that consumers will attempt to offset reduced incomes with rising levels of indebtedness. In other words, some Brits will attempt to borrow their way out of the squeeze. In all probability, this is likely to have a negative impact on Britain's banks, as bad debts continue to mount up.

As ever, watch this space for the latest corporate news...

More from Cliff D'Arcy:

> Your tax-free ISA allowance has now increased to £10,680. Open a Motley Fool Self Select ISA today.

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

mcturra2000 12 Apr 2011 , 1:01pm

"However, the CEBR has excluded the drops in income caused by World War II (1939-45) and the General Strike of 1926."

Yeah, let's not have pesky facts ruin a good soundbite.

mcturra2000 12 Apr 2011 , 1:09pm

Any views on DXNS (Dixons)?

Remember to add TCG (Thomas Cook Group) as a company that is likely to be hit hard by consumer belt-tightening. It has a worrying level of debt, too.

CunningCliff 12 Apr 2011 , 1:19pm

Hi mcturra2000,

In fairness to the CEBR, the UK saw a steep (but wartime) drop in income during WW2, so it's best excluded from peacetime comparisons. Likewise, the 1926 drop was a short, sharp shock lasting roughly a year -- and it was nothing like as drawn-out and painful as the subsequent Thirties depression.

As for Dixons Retail (LSE: DXNS), it gets a firm thumbs-down from me, as do Currys, Comet and other consumer-electronics retailers. Who would buy a 50" plasma TV when his/her job is on the line?

Likewise, the future looks less than bright for Thomas Cook Group (LSE: TCG) and other travel & leisure firms.

In a nutshell, I'm bearish right across the high street! ;0)

All the best,

Cliff

Mike10613 12 Apr 2011 , 2:16pm

Most holiday firms are a bad investment, people will eat out less and buy more food to eat at home so supermarkets are a good investment as has already been shown. People are going frugal - retailers selling designer clothes - bad investment. I think even Amazon could struggle while EBay could benefit. People won't buy Plasma TV's or stay in posh hotels except for the rich who are never short of a few quid. I think some technology could stay stable though, computers are seen as more of a necessity than a luxury now. I think mobile phone contracts could be replaced by PAYG though. Some firms supplying central and local government have already suffered and they will continue to do so. It's not just about investment with small to medium sized companies it's about jobs if you are unlucky to work for one.

It's a good time to go frugal and thrifty - check out my free blogs - http://wp.me/P194MF-2D

peawackmf 12 Apr 2011 , 3:49pm

How will commodities do well when nobody wants the end product ?

carloswhizz 13 Apr 2011 , 10:51am

Thanks Cliff, useful stuff. No surprises here though, the UK consumer has been on a binge since the mid 80s and bar a brief dip in the early 90s has kept the spending tap fully on. So there will be a few less large scale retailers in the high street and retail parks, does the UK consumer really need to do their houses up yet again and buy a new car yet again? Smaller scale purchases will still have to occur though.

Can you invest in dry cleaners that do clothes repairs or Timpsons?!

AlysonThomson 13 Apr 2011 , 12:43pm

McTurra: I believe that the Curry's/Dixon's/PC World group will have to close one or more of these chains to survive. They all sell the same things and are being undercut by supermarkets and the Net.

CunningCliff 13 Apr 2011 , 1:49pm

By the way, I think Halfords and similar chains could do well during the spending downturn, especially as expensive fuel deters motorists from driving.

Any other suggestions in this penny-pinching vein? Thanks!

Cliff

mackeson29 13 Apr 2011 , 2:34pm

Hi Cliff,

Yes, Halfords might do quite well - due to people washing their own cars & not using car washes, but also due to the upturn in cycling - halfords cater for all price brackets for families with the carrera & boardman brands. Cycle to work schemes have been bumping up bike sales for halfords & others, but is being clamped down a little on the financial incentives after people (as always happens) taking the p#ss.

I disagree with your outlook on cinema's - its an expenive trip now with ticket prices & then kiddies demanding popcorn & sweets (unbelievably expensive). With a DVD rental or sky/virgin box office being a fraction of this, people will stay in & have their takeaway's to replace cinema & eating out.

I thnk B&Q will fair fine - we don't know what else to do on weekends in this country (especially bank holidays) apart from DIY. Plus things will always break/wear out & more of the public will fancy having a go themselves rather than getting in a pro (if you can find one in between all the cowboys).

People will always be buying big plasma's (or the like) some becasue they can afford it & shop around on amazon, etc, rather than buying on the high street - others who can't afford it still will, because they always have to have the latest gadget & retail therapy always hits the spot for them.

Only my humble opinion, anyhow.

DrFfybes 14 Apr 2011 , 2:45pm

Different people will economise in different ways.

If I'm fed up and short of cash am I more or less likely to go and buy some choccy to lift my mood? However I (personally) am more likely to go and get a purple bar from tesco than a small expensive bag of Thorntons (sometimes quantity wins over quality :-)

If I'm forking out £50/month to take the family to the cinema then a big telly, surround system, and popcorn maker will pay for itself in 18 months , won't it dear? ;-)

The thing is that as people cut down, they still like the little luxuries like getting the car washed or a Mochacino latte with extra marshmello, so instead I think they'll start using Value toilet roll and toothpaste.

Personally I'll start using shop-brand products before I'll stop paying someone to launder my shirts.

I think there'll be drops all the way across the board, apart from the very high end products.

Join the conversation

Please take note - some tags have changed.

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: [b]bolded text[/b], [i]italicised text[/i]. All other tags will be removed from your post.

If you want to add a link, please ensure you type it as http://www.fool.co.uk as opposed to www.fool.co.uk.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.