Skip Navigation
 

Single Mums Are Fighting To Survive

My latest blog

Is It Right To Reclaim Bank Charges?

Published in Get Out Of Debt on 8 August 2008

A recent survey finds single mums are worrying about debts, buying food, and paying the bills.

Single mums were recently asked in a survey by BrightHouse* what their top three financial priorities are. (The survey had just a small sample of 500, but I still think they will be strongly indicative.)

Of single mums with access to credit, one of their top three financial priorities is to get out of debt. More than 70% said this, which also means that the majority of single mothers who are able to borrow have in fact done so, or they have gone into arrears on bills.

Making sure there is food on the table is disconcertingly high on their minds too (70%). Paying the rent or mortgage on time (51%) was also selected in the top-three-priorities list by the majority of respondents.

These mums have understandably relegated saving for their children’s futures (29%) and saving money for a holiday (37%) in order to attend to their immediate needs: stability, surviving and getting their debts under control.

The vast majority of respondents to the survey have access to credit, which makes those results I’ve just mentioned reasonably reliable.

Conversely, the survey’s sample of single mothers who don’t have access to credit is very small. So the figures regarding them are less reliable and need to be taken with a high-blood-pressure-inducing dosage of salt. So I’ll just touch on the basics.

It seems from the results that these mothers mostly want to put money aside so their children can go on a school trip (83%), save money for their children’s futures (77%) and save for a holiday (64%). Less than a third (28%) are focusing on controlling their debts.

This second group of mothers could theoretically be months in arrears in all their bills and simply not give a damn about their debts, but I would take these results to mean that they’ve been forced, by their limited access to credit, to either live within their means or to get a soft loan from family.

I’m hoping (quite possibly naively) that they are focusing on holidays and savings because they can afford to do so, but that’s a topic that should be researched for another article using other data.

Tips for struggling single mums

Rather than analyse those less reliable data too much, I shall return to the mothers with access to credit. Preying strongly on their minds is paying the bills and surviving. A close family-member was pretty much in the same situation, so I have a fair idea of how dreadful that can be, as well as the mistakes that are often made.

The single biggest mistake you can make is not face your problem or try to tackle it. You might well have your debts and basic survival needs on your mind all the time, but that doesn’t mean you’re finding solutions. Indeed, you may be trying to hide from the problem.

I’m not one of those who believes we should all talk about money all the time, but if you have a money problem you should certainly seek guidance from friends, family, the Internet and advisors.

Before you do that, however, I have found some really quite excellent tips from Net Doctor that are about your psychological and physical wellbeing. I think that you could easily apply these 20+ tips to your attitude towards debt.

Here are the articles:

  • From moaner-to-go-getter. Rather than grumbling to yourself about your debts, read this article, follow the advice, and you’ll now take a much more uplifting and energetic approach to your money woes. (Go easy on step 7. This is not an excuse to spend more money!)
  • Get motivated for better health. Your attitude towards dealing with debt will be a lot healthier if you modify this plan that is meant to improve your fitness.

Once you’re ready mentally, you can focus properly on cutting your bills and getting out of debt.

*BrightHouse is a chain that sells electronic and domestic appliances and furniture, primarily on a ‘rent-to-own’ basis. I don’t know anything about this company, so I can’t endorse it. Please write about your experiences with it in a comment below.

> Visit our Dealing with Debt board and get anonymous tips and guidance from your peers.

Share & subscribe

Comments

The opinions expressed here are those of the individual writers and are not representative of The Motley Fool. If you spot any comments that are unsuitable hit the flag to alert our moderators.

merytsekhmet 11 Aug 2008, 5:47am

I saw a branch of BrightHouse on a short visit to Pontypridd last week. Basically, it is a chain of shops selling goods on hire purchase to anyone, regardless of credit rating. You can purchase the "essentials" of life such as huge plasma screens for your living room wall and a leather suite on which to sit as you view. Payments are calculated on a weekly basis to make them seem smaller, and the APR is a modest 30%.

JGHarney 11 Aug 2008, 10:47am

First, as a single dad I do get annoyed that writers don't use the term single parent, as not all of us are female (although I accept the majority are!).

Second, BrightHouse is a 'weekly payment store' (APR from 29.9%) whose main customer base are benefit claimants, so these results are not unexpected. However the fact remains that since the introduction of tax credits and help towards child-care you are invariably better off working as a single parent than on benefits (I work full-tim myself), and as someone who until recently worked for the DWP I do know the figures! The people who are really suffering in society are low-paid single people and couples without kids, whose standards of living are on average far below those of single-parents.

This is not to say of course that every single-parent can get work (areas of high unemployment, or where a child is disabled etc.), or indeed should get work if the child is young (although I chose to and my lad's only 2, but he absolutely loves nursery), but until the recent lurch into recession most single parents could get work if they wanted to. In fact I actually worked in Jobcentre Plus in a typical northern town with areas of high benefit deprevation, but where jobs were readily available, and where when faced with single parent benefit claimants who said they couldn't work because they had children had to politely point out that myself and a significant amount of my colleagues were not only ourselves single-parents, but shockingly had jobs too!

Iniq 13 Aug 2008, 1:24pm

Why do you persist in sending me umpteen E-mails per day, many containing detailed information about products which I do not have, do not need, do not want and have no interest in aquriring?

If you lot are so wise, why can't you target your mailouts a little - and reduce to volume to a less spam-like quantity?

maiden47 14 Aug 2008, 4:59pm

I am a single mother with NO debts and I didn't much like Neil's article.As he rightly says there needs to be another survey with different data.MY main priority is to STAY OUT of debt,everything else involves struggling to survive on a limited budget.Holidays and savings are a dream,at least for now.

margaretc 19 Aug 2008, 12:36pm

"At 05:47 on August 11 2008, merytsekhmet said:

I saw a branch of BrightHouse on a short visit to Pontypridd last week. Basically, it is a chain of shops selling goods on hire purchase to anyone, regardless of credit rating. You can purchase the "essentials" of life such as huge plasma screens for your living room wall and a leather suite on which to sit as you view. Payments are calculated on a weekly basis to make them seem smaller, and the APR is a modest 30%."

This is appalling. No doubt the incautious and the unwary will be tempted by this. The article above mentions food on the table and saving for children's school trips - in contrast, the idea of tempting people with plasma screens and leather sofas at an eye-watering APR of 30%, is nothing short of immoral.

TMFVertigo 19 Aug 2008, 1:02pm

Hi JGHarney

You said:

"First, as a single dad I do get annoyed that writers don't use the term single parent, as not all of us are female (although I accept the majority are!)."

Sorry that annoyed you, but the data I was using only analysed single mums. As I said in my article, it was not the best survey ever, so we need to both take it with a pinch of salt and extrapolate it further as required.

Neil

BelfastBob 21 Aug 2008, 4:52pm

At the risk of starting a flame war... there are 3 types of single parent, 1)Working, 2)On benefit & playing by the rules & 3) On benefit & not playing by the rules. By my estimate, experience, the numbers not playing by the rules are 50%. Guess which can afford a plasma TV at 30% APR ? I have had my eyes opened when I wonder how individuals can afford a car on HP, go on foreign holidays & have a plasma screen while they work 24 hours part time or on benefit. The majority have partners in full time work who "reside" at another address. The press \ professional bodies do not have a clue of the scale & are only able to quote the honest as what sensible fraudster is going to go on record about their scam?

jomactaylor 22 Aug 2008, 8:05pm

I agree with JGHarney, since my husband was made redundant just before Christmas last year we have claimed benefit as a couple and have suffered greatly as a result. The couples rate is less than for two single people (even then it is breadline). We never go out, we don't have a Plasma TV taking up half the room and it is a daily struggle simply trying to exist. Even my mother, who is a pensioner does not understand why people in our cirumstances should receive less money. On another note, I know very few people who actually defraud the benefits system. This is some kind of urban myth perpuated by certain types of people. It is bad enough claiming benefits in the first place without the social stigma attached to it as well.

griffend08 26 Aug 2008, 12:06pm

I am a single mum. Yes, I am receiving benefits and no, my 6 year old son does not receive all the toys and gizmos that his friends have (he doesn't care about all that).

Having been quite seriously in debt in my former life (and climbed out of it), it's my priority to stay out of debt to protect my son and his future. We grow our own veg, conserve water, switch off lights etc etc, conserving the planet and what little money we have to live on. WE LOVE IT. My son has learnt, and is learning the value, not only of money, but also his own property.

What do we do with the money we save? My son is home taught and any 'spare' money goes on his home education. (yes I pay for it)

The one thing I am bitter about is that the government are bringing down the child age from 16 to 12 and then to 7 for those single parents staying at home and receiving income support, which means that in less than 2 years, as a single parent, I will have to put my son in school, find a job, and put my son in some sort of childcare situation.

My son has NEVER had childcare, it goes against everything I believe in (it's fine for other people if that's what they want, but not for me). I brought him into this world, and it's up to me to look after him, not hand him over to someone else to raise him.

My son was severely bullied at school and still has panic attacks about even the thought of going. Since being taken out of school, he is back to being the happy little chappie I loved pre school.

I'm more than happy to work, but not at the price of my son but, where does this leave us?

nicolacairncross 29 Aug 2008, 2:06pm

Hi all. As a single mum who worked right through my kids childhoods, I always feel a bit exasperated at the attitudes of single parents who think that having a job (or not) is their only option. What about starting a small business from home, that would fit with kiddies routines? I taught myself how to use the internet, and as well as training as a life coach, initially, building up that business, I learned how to do internet marketing, recommending other people's products and services to my ever-growing mailing list, before finally writing my book The Money Gym. All around me, people are making money with small businesses, like gardening (I wish I could find a reliable one!), ironing, cleaning and starting ironing and cleaning companies, babysitting businesses, delivering leaflets (again, someone reliable would be fabulous!). There are the network marketing companies like Virgin Vie, Avon and Nuways, that can bring in extra income too and provide training, and there are online versions now like Success University that are very good fun. There is evidence to show that over the next 10 years, over half the population will become self employed, the USA has already topped 50% I believe, and being self employed is so much more flexible. You have to be willing to turn the TV off and learn new skills though, but you can do that while the babies sleep and they can be learned from books which are not expensive or online videos which are usually free. I saw a great article on this site somewhere about attitude and that's what needs to change. A job = Just Over Broke and worse, you are dependent on your employer - horrendous! No security there. Best wishes to all from a fellow mum of two! Cheers, Nicola (http://www.themoneygym.com)

fee2705 01 Sep 2008, 1:32pm

Hi all,
Aren't we missing a blindingly obvious point? That basically there should be no such thing as a single parent. I am a working, divorced mother of one 14yr old, and after 5 years of my ex husband making csa payments, all on time and to the letter of the law, he has decided to take voluntary redundancy with no job to go to. So, for the first time in my life I am indeed a single parent. With a £500 school trip to pay for (booked before his redundancy decision was taken), and all the other expenses of which I'm sure you are all too familiar.

If the government would maybe make it a little easier for the csa (or whichever new body follows the csa) to chase up absent fathers (and absent mothers I'm sure, in some cases), then we wouldn't have to have this discussion at all.
It takes two to make a child, and it takes two to pay for it's upbringing. It should never, ever be down to one parent alone. Time we put our foot down and put an end to the "opting out" of so many parents.

Fee2705

Dread1977 02 Sep 2008, 9:18am

As a father who is currently about to go through a seperation/divorce i fail to see why a father would not want to pay for his childs welfare and safegaurd their future. If im honest I would much prefere my daughter to live with me as I have been her primary carer for the last 5 years anyway, but that is something I will have to deal with as it seems widely accepted that a child should live with the "MUM" despite not really having been there for the last few years (Dont get me wrong, work and circumstances force her back to work)but i managed to bend my work life around looking after my daughter, why could`nt she?

Even so, its moving away from the point, any father worth being called that would be more than happy to pay, i know i would (Just need to figure out how as i`m being left with a huge mortgage to pay, and for all of the other things as my partner no longer works).

Really, the government needs to do more to safegaurd Single parents rights to look after their children and make life easier, I mean lets face it, they put the welfare of illegals and other visitors to these shores before us!!!

Good luck to all single parents out there, men and women.

samseed52 09 Sep 2008, 2:00pm

Hi All

In response to fee2705's comment that the government should make it easier for the csa to obtain money - I believe we should view all such suggestions with a degree of caution. Giving the government the power to extract more money from people is not necessarily a good thing as it invariably goes wrong (loads of unintended consequences).

I'm a personally aware of a significant number of resident parents (mainly mothers)unable to obtain money collected by the csa from the non-resident parent.

Similarly, I'm aware of non-resident parents who are experience deductions of over 50% of their monthly salary for the support of only one child. While children in second families are experiencing poverty.

On the other hand, working tax credit debt as a result of supposedly overpayments is well documented. These government agencies argue that nothing ever goes wrong, but that does not help those individuals struggling to get payments from non-resident parents or others who are are facing the prospect of paying thousands back to working tax credits.

Without a properly organised and structured financial support system that ensures that everyone has a viable income regardless of their circumstances, we will continue to have a situation where groups of disadvantaged people are played off against each other.

dippy1 05 Oct 2008, 11:25pm

hi all,l've just joined.l'm also a single mum..also got another on the way..problem is my x hubby claims benefits,works on the side and doesnt pay a penny for our kids yet goes away on holidays with his g/f and her daughter,has a lovely life whilst l'm struggling to make ends meet.l was on a course to get a job but then found out l was pregnant...l certainly could write a book lol.plus if l was to get a job once the baby is older and my x take me to court again over contact then l'd have to pay but he wouldnt..it's so annoying!!!

Join the conversation

Instructions

Line breaks are converted automatically.

You may use the following tags in your post: <b>bold</b>, <i>quoted text</i>. All other tags will be removed from your post.

Hello stranger

To add your own comment, please login.

Not yet registered? Register now.